Title: Gladiator WC: 900 Episode: Setup (3 x 16)
She doesn’t know how to fight.
It’s an embarrassing revelation this late in life, but here she is, a year into her thirties and belatedly realizing that she’s never learned to fight. It would be nice if there were some feel-good explanation for it—that her problem-solving skills are so superior, that her parents modeled an idyllic relationship, that she’s some kind of zen master.
It would be nice, but she’s well aware that she doesn’t so much solve problems as she brute forces them; her parents had their knock-down, drag-outs, and it was always a two-way street. And the way she’s abusing her phone this morning suggests the likelihood of the Zen Master Committee tapping her for membership anytime soon is pretty low.
Her skills in the How to Have a Fight arena are so limited that she’s not even sure how she wound up in this one, which is pretty messed up, given that she’s very sure she’s the one who started it. He’d blindsided her. Josh had completely blindsided her with the announcement that he was heading off to Haiti before his laundry from Africa would have a chance to dry. And she, apparently, had blindsided him with her You’ve Got To Be Fucking Kidding Me response.
He’d been reasonable. He’d taken her hands in his and tried to make her sit and talk things through. He’d even hit her with a carefully gentle Kate, where is this coming from?, which had accomplished nothing other than pegging the relationship-based rage meter she’d been unaware of until that very moment.
He had been reasonable at the start, but that’s over. He is no longer being reasonable. He is texting, though her responses aspire to be terse. He is calling, though she answers solely to bite out that she is working—that she will be working until who knows when. He is here—at the precinct—which is exactly the last place she needs, wants, or expects him to be.
And he snaps at her. It’s a shock to the system, because this is what not reasonable actually looks like. He hisses at her because Castle has shown up with his-and-hers coffee in tow and he’s pissed about it. He has, up to this point, been concerned, surprised, frustrated, unhappy . . . but now he’s pissed, and she wonders how many fights with Josh she has had without having prior to this moment.
She wonders what fights she should have been having, because he’d had no idea she’d give a damn if he went sailing off again for some indeterminate length of time, and she, until five second ago, had had no idea that Castle was a problem. Inaccurate. She’d had no idea that Josh had any idea that Castle was a problem.
He is a problem.
The world is ending, or her part of it is, anyway, and she’s stuck with him. He’s peering through the zipper flap and imagining the vaporization of New York City. She feels closer to miserable, petulant tears than she thinks she’s been since she was waiting on her learner’s permit. And the sting at the corners of her eyes—the thickness gathering at the back of her throat—isn’t about the end of the world at all. It’s about the fact that she has no idea how to fight.
The tears are a downstream effect of the fact that she’s here and he’s here, and all she wants to do is tell him about it. And so, of course, he asks. She snaps at him to change the subject—to stop talking about the end of the world—so of course he asks: How’s Josh? Those are the two conversational gambits he has at his disposal: Josh and the end of the world.
It comes pouring out of her—her resentment of Josh for being the person she was attracted to in the first place, self-loathing for being so needy that she’d try to keep him from his work, and between the lines, her deep embarrassment the she doesn’t know how to fight for something, fight with someone; she doesn’t know what to fight about or how far to take it.
All of it comes pouring out to him—to Castle—and it’s like she so comprehensively doesn’t know how to fight that she’s managed to show up on the wrong day at the wrong ring for her bout. All of it comes pouring out at the end of the world, and she knows it’s not a coincidence that she’s here with him—with Castle—and not at all with Josh, and it’s easy. She’d like to write it off to adrenaline or the fear of dying with things unsaid.
But the fact of the matter is that it’s easy with him. It’s easy to talk about everything and nothing, now, tomorrow, or at the end of the world. The fact of the matter is that it’s not a coincidence that he, of all people, is here at the end of the world and it’s not exactly true that she doesn’t know how to fight.
She has fought with him. She has fought for him. She has fought alongside him. And here they are, at the end of the world, and she doesn’t know how to fight with anyone else. She wouldn’t know how to begin.
A/N: Swirling anger about morphousness.
images via homeofthenutty








