Pretty sure this is a lyric from a song but not positive, "I'm better as a memory than as your man."
I can really picture it for Bagginshield, especially in the healing tents after the battle of the five armies. I think it works well as a line coming from Thorin, perhaps when he wakes up after Ravenhill and Bilbo is like don't you dare! You are not going to decide for me if you are a better memory than a romantic partner. I expect all the courtship after you have recovered or so help me, Mahal will not save you from my wrath. So of course Thorin has to recover.
Any opinions on this scenario? Who do you think would use the line? Any other pairings you think it would work for?
*Asks are sent for fun, no pressure to answer.
I looked it up, and apparently this is a lyric from a Kenny Chesney song. Unfortunately, this immediately put me in mind of Merle Highchurch from The Adventure Zone and now I can't take it seriously as a Bagginshield story at all.
Yes, obviously you're correct and I can't really improve on your Battle of Five Armies set up here. Thorin, asking Bilbo to remember him as he passes on. Bilbo, disagreeing with that assessment. It's all very dramatic and colored by a terrible death wish. But there are two scenarios where someone says "I'm better as a memory than your man," and I think the other is much funnier.
Consider Merle Highchurch, a beach dwarf and cleric of Pan, telling his ex-wife, "I move on like a sinner's prayer."
"My only friends are pirates," he says to Lucretia as they sit buried in mud at a spa. She nods regally. She knows his friends very well, after all.
"I'm built to fade like your favorite song, getting reckless when there's no need," he shouts over the din of battle, as Magnus rushes in.
"What's that, my Dude?" asks Taako.
"Never sure when the truth won't do."
"Bud, that is practically always," the wizard informs him sagely. "Keep your truths to yourself and let me do the talking."
"I move on the way a storm blows through," he informs his stepdaughter Mavis. She glares at him, unimpressed, until he quickly adds, "I never stay, but then again, I might."
Merle Highchurch is the kind of dwarf who would truly believe that he's better as a memory than as a man. Because his memories tell him that goodbyes are like a roulette wheel and that bouncing ball always lands on loss. This is a song about someone who doesn't stay, who can't commit.
I don't think that's Thorin Oakenshield.