To muddle or not to muddle, that was the question
This past Sunday I had a conversation with a bartender about muddling a cucumber. He was telling me about a drink that requires muddling a cucumber and then adding citrus. When he was finished I asked, why muddle the cucumber to begin with? His response was "yeah, it seemed like double the work". (If you haven't made the connection, no worries, I'll explain). A cocktail that contains citrus is usually shaken hard with ice. This will macerate the cucumber and so muddling was never really necessary.
During the past few years I have done my share of muddling, including Mojitos, Smashes, Midwest Style Old fashions etc.... I'm going to share with you my opinion on the topic and I hope that some of the information will help you advance your own style of the craft.
Muddling should be used when necessary or when you have "lots of time" and just want to add some flair for your customers. So, if you are going to muddle, there are a few things that you should know.
Which mixing vessels and which muddlers to use
If you are currently use a pint glass, then I suggest you find a different glass with a wider base. This will allow you the space to properly muddle citrus.
Yari mixing vessels have a wide base, and work very well if you need to muddle. (Beware! The bottom might crack off if you wash with extremely hot water. This is because the Yari vessels are not tempered.)
Muddlers I have three types of muddlers in my bar kit
My Large Muddler- I use this muddler with mixing vessels that have wide bases. This allows me to complete my muddle with just a few presses.
My Smaller Muddler- I use this muddler if building my drink inside of an old fashion glass.
The flat end of a stirring spoon, -is also used for muddling and I find that I use this instrument when bartending in establishments where I need not muddle very often and am limited to using a pint glass as a mixing vessel. I only use this tool to muddle half wheels of citrus, berries, and herbs. Never wedges.
If you are going to use a muddler that has a sharp pattern on the flat end, you will need to be very disciplined. These sharp edges dig into the citrus peel and if you are not careful you'll end up getting a cocktail that is horribly sharp (taste too much of the peel). I don't recommend this type of muddler...
Muddlers with a lacquer finish
Any Muddler that has a lacquer finish should be sanded down. If you don't sand down the lacquer, it will eventually peel off and land in the drink..
So, why muddle in the first place?
We muddle to extract juice and oil, we muddle to crush spices (sometimes), we muddle to open the veins in herbs, and if need be we muddle to break down sugar (though, I highly recommend that you use simple syrup).
Muddling citrus to get fresh juice- If you are going to make a sour, a mule, or a mojito etc...I suggest that you invest in a juicer so that you can have fresh juice on hand and need not use a muddler. You can also buy a citrus press if you plan to infrequently make fresh juice cocktails.
If you want to get the oils from the skin in your cocktail-I suggest that you execute a zest rather than muddling.
***DISCLAIMER- Some cocktails historically were muddled and so you would muddle to keep with tradition. Caipirinha, Midwest Old Fashion, Smash etc***
If there is any lemon, lime, grapefruit, or orange juice, in the drink you are making, then you need not muddle. Throw your berries in the shaker with the rest of the drink and macerate them.
If there is no citrus, then by all means muddle and stir
Veggies, Melons, herbs, flowers, and anything else that can be muddled
If there is any lemon, lime, grapefruit, or orange juice, in the drink you are making, then you need not muddle. Throw your Veggies, melons, herbs, flowers, etc... in the shaker with the rest of the drink and macerate them.
If there is no citrus, then by all means muddle and stir
If you plan on making many a muddled cocktails, then I suggest making a syrup, this will save you time, add to consistency and save you time. (I said it twice because it's important.)
**You may have in the past worked with a fruit, or veggie, or anything else that is too hard to macerate, but can be muddled. If that is the case, then yes, my rules above don't apply**
Yes, there are different ways to muddle
Any fruit that contains citrus oils
Muddle the fruit part hard and muddle the rind or peel soft (if you muddle the rind or peel too hard you basically throw your cocktail out of balance. Too much oil is not a good thing.
Herbs- Muddle soft, if you muddle to hard, you are like to turn your cocktail bitter
Flowers- I suggest you steep them and then make a syrup, but if for some reason you feel like muddling an orchid, then study up on it and practice different ways with different conditions to muddle. I'm not in the habit of muddling flowers, but I've seen tea made from flowers, so, study what you are using and learn how to extract the right amount of flavor....
Remember... My mom's spaghetti sauce might be different than your mom's, but it's still spaghetti sauce. Be open with your cocktails....