Some traditions are completely off-limits to outsiders, like Yezidi, Druze, or Sun Dance. Some traditions seek converts like Christianity, Islam, or Buddhism. But the majority of traditions are somewhere else on that spectrum.
Speaking of traditions being purely “open” or “closed” is incredibly reductive. A great many traditions don’t actively seek members but may occasionally bring newcomers into the fold who prove themselves to be respectful and dedicated. Some traditions, despite their relative obscurity are enthusiastic to receive interested parties. Others will test potential recruits, some of whom will pass, some of whom will not. Still others are loose affinity groups with little in the way of formal membership, where people come and go. And overall, within any given tradition, different lineages or sects may not only take different approaches, but distinguish themselves from one another on this point.
Tumblr, I’m begging you, stop treating this like a black or white issue. It would be so much more productive to talk about attitudes of entitlement or humility and the present day effects of historical injustices than simply slapping a “no entry” sign on traditions you may not even belong to.
