Do you still take deviation memes? Dragons are strong, fearsome animals while humans are more or less fragile compared to them. Any accidents that Toothless could have done unintensionally and harm Hiccup? Perhaps even accidentally killing him?
Toothless didn’t mean it. That’s what Hiccup tells himself as he cradles his broken arm and curls in on himself on the ground.
It was an accident. They were play-wretstling with some dragon-nip and Toothless bit down too fast and too hard.
The dragon is immediately contrite and Hiccup tries to be understanding, but pain makes him waspish. Wincing, he tells Toothless it’s okay but he has to go.
Hiccup has trouble climbing out of the cove. He stumbles back to the village and straight to the healer. His forehead is sweaty and he’s breathing hard. He says he fell while climbing a tree. There are teethmarks in his flesh but he stubbornly sticks to the story.
Gobber pays more attention to him after that. Hiccup gets to sit out of dragon training and observe, his arm in a splint. Snotlout kills the Terror. Tuffnut high-fives him and Astrid pats his back. Snotlout looks at her with a dreamy smile.
Hiccup feels guilty and queasy. Watching the teens from afar makes him question his old desire to be One of Them.
Hiccup skips a day in visiting Toothless but when he does return the dragon is subdued and sorry. Learning to fly takes longer and Hiccup is more reserved when handling Toothless. Their relationship progresses slower.
Hiccup isn’t flying when his father returns. He isn’t a part of the final test due to his arm. It’s between Astrid and Snotlout and Astrid easily wins. Stoick still gives Hiccup the helmet–happy to hear of his successes before the accident. Hiccup is still considered a great Dragon Fighter among the village, despite not being in the final round in default.
He’s required by his father to watch the Champion kill the dragon against all his excuses. The Nightmare is defeated, Astrid sustains grievous burns–her left arm may never hold up a shield as well again–but she kills the dragon in the end. The village wildly celebrates. Hiccup spends it with Toothless. He forgets the arm incident, gets on that dragon and flies.
Three nights later, Hiccup discovers the nest.
Astrid is still suspicious of Hiccup. She knows she was only pitted against Snotlout because of Hiccup’s injury, but his successes before that never leave her mind. She would follow him, but her own injuries as still healing and Hiccup is well on the mend. His flying becomes more daring and more complicated as he stews over how to handle knowing the truth about dragons. Even if he told someone about the giant dragon, and they didn’t immediately hunt down Toothless, it seems impossible to defeat it.
A dragon raid happens two weeks later. Astrid’s injuries are just healed enough to participate. She and the others of her class are no longer on fire brigade and battle. Hiccup isn’t out running about and causing a mess this time. He’s not in the forge either, which worries both Gobber and Stoick (though both have to focus on fighting). He’s flying on Toothless.
It’s the first time he’s in the air for a fight and it’s scary and mess. He knows of the Queen’s control and he starts looking for signs. At first he’s observing, then he tries shooting down dragons.
His absence is confronted and he gets in trouble with his father. He did well in training and he’s expected to help out. Hiccup gets into a fight with him about how he doesn’t want to fight dragons. Stoick doesn’t know what to do with him. A rift grows.
Hiccup’s inventions in the forge move from hurting dragons to aiding himself while flying. Arm-guard crossbows and hand-held bola nets. All of his time is spent either in the forge or gone and the village thinks he’s lost his mind. Refusing to fight and becoming more anti-social than ever.
Astrid no longer has to compete with Hiccup for the title of greatest warrior in their generation, but she hates that she never found out Hiccup’s success secret. He’s still illusive and the incentive isn’t strong enough to keep tracking him down every spare moment… especially now that she’s a full-fledged shieldmaiden with responsibilities and expectations to fight.
Hiccup travels farther and farther on Toothless. He doesn’t come home a few times. He gets in trouble but he always runs off again because he’s making allies. He’s studying new weapons and learning about explosives. He’s working with chemicals and fire and methods to contain and release them.
Hiccup is so preoccupied with the Queen, with his inventions and travels and dragons, that he hardly notices that Stoick’s written him off as unreachable. He’ll never understand the deep, gut-wrench disappointment Stoick has to swallow after hearing that his son excelled at dragon training, only to have it all slip away. Instead of trying and failing to be a Viking, Hiccup isn’t even trying any more.
Over the next couple of years Hiccup’s armor, newfangled weapons, and explosive know-how gives him the skill and intelligence to take down the Red Death. Everything he’s worked for.
He does it. Those he trusts most–no one on Berk, that is–know where he’s gone. He manages to acquire some injuries–burns mostly, a shattered foot that takes away all grace when walking–but his intense planning has paid off.
He returns to Berk and finds his father. He looks like a different man.
Stoick fumbles awkwardly with hard news.
“Snotlout will be chief, I think. It makes sense and…”
“There won’t be any more dragon raids,” Hiccup interrupts tiredly. And there aren’t.
He doesn’t care about being chief. He leaves a few days later because he’s learned of other nests. There’s a responsibility that comes with his knowledge and skill-set, and he plans on meeting it.
((I’m sure by now, anyone who’s reading all of these will start to see some re-occuring themes. That’s because I feel like some of these deviations will go full circle and meet the same end))