Young fiction writers, tack this sentence on a card above your laptops.
He was miffed with the poetry editor Howard Moss for cutting too many of his best lines...You sense the slate beneath the purling surface current in his comment to (Roger) Angell: âYour turning down a story doesnât make it any worse, any more than your taking it makes it better; so the effort, to please and challenge myself, remains the same.â Young fiction writers, tack this sentence on a card above your laptops.
â Dwight Garner, from "John Updike Called His Letters Dull. Theyâre Anything But." (NY Times, October 20, 2024)
Miserable comforters are ye all | On George Saunders' hollow new novel Vigil
George Saundersâ latest novel Vigil is told primarily from the perspective of a ghost, Jill âDollâ Blaine, a spirit who has resisted elevation to up there in order to remain on Earth, where she guides her dying âchargesâ into the afterlife.
Her latest (and perhaps last) charge is one K.J. Boone, an oil tycoon dying in the âslop roomâ of his least favorite house. Boone spent his career denyingâŠ
âDwight Garner, âOn the Centennial of Iris Murdochâs Birth, Remembering a 20th-Century Giantâ
Garner exaggerates Murdochâs loss of literary standing: sheâs in print from Penguin Classics, which might be a quick definition of âcanonical.â My recent piece on her short, strange 1961 novel, A Severed Head, even begins by considering it as a fashionable cult book. On the one hand, I gave it a mixed review. On the other hand, I recommend it most highly to anyone who wants a literately scandalous, even offensive (still!), reading experience:
I find a similar imbalance in A Severed Head as in Lolita, another novel of the era about mythical forbidden love that also (and somewhat contradictorily) makes an ethical point about the importance of treating other people as ends rather than means. Murdoch, like Nabokov, seems to want it both waysâscandal and morality, myth and realityâbut she produces only an intricately-composed, beautifully-written duck/rabbit illusion (itâs surreally immoral! itâs realistically moral!) rather than a work capacious enough to hold its contraries in sustaining tension.
Sterile, ostentatious and essentially plotless, âParadeâ is an antinovel, a little black box of a book. It fails the Hardwick Test. The sole burden of an antinovel, the critic Elizabeth Hardwick wrote, is that it must be consistently (âeach page, each paragraphâ) interesting.
â Dwight Garner, from "The Artist is Present (and Pretentious) in Rachel Cusk's Latest (new novel "Parade") (NY Times, June 10, 2024)
For Acker, the place was always here; the time was always now.
One: Literary careers are not handed out â theyâre earned, theyâre seized. Ackerâs work ethic was titanic. Work was her religion. She wrote eight hours a day, regardless of what had happened the night before and, given that Acker was impulsive, ferally attractive and sexually omnivorous, plenty tended to happen the night beforeâŠÂ For Acker, the place was always here; the time was always now.
â Dwight Garner, from âKathy Acker, Drawn to the Margins, Pushed Literatureâs Boundariesâ by Jason McBride (NY Times, November 21, 2022)
William Feaverâs âThe Lives of Lucian Freud: Fame, 1968-2011â completes a two-volume biography of the pioneering realist painter.
Family does intrude as Freudâs children, legitimate and illegitimate, begin to crawl from the woodwork. He had at least 14 offspring he acknowledged as his own. He called himself âone of the great absentee fathers of the age.â Soon there are grandchildren as well. Freud did not do much hugging, but his progeny could tap him for money.
Many got to know him by sitting for portraits. He painted his daughters naked. âThey make it all right for me to paint them,â he said. âMy naked daughters have nothing to be ashamed of.â
Freud had a mean word for everyone. He put the knife in white and it came out red. A typical comment in this volume, about an aunt, is: âShe was very nasty really, in a small sort of way. Her expertise was opening letters. Other peopleâs.â If he didnât like you, he cut you from his life like cancer. You can always tell a monster: He wears scarves indoors.
He had a mighty work ethic, and he turned out paintings until nearly the end. He lived in the imperative tense and barely slowed down. He stood in the center of his own self-importance. There wasnât a big gap, as there is in most lives, between being carefree and being carrion.