Apologies for how long the first ask was cause I didn’t realize how much I’d written till you posted but! I’m back! with more potential hits for the In A Different Life AU:
I can imagine a moment where black sapphire might think smilk is returning, where he has the same manic laughter and wide grin on his face and he gets all excited and goes to see what made him regain his memories and— it’s a completely false alarm. All smilk had done was put on an act while chasing a small cookie around and is only swinging said cookie around as it squeals in delight and black sapphire is struck by how much it reminds him of candy apple and he doesn’t know why he’s so overcome with emotions and has to leave the scene distraught
When other cookies who knew shadowvanilla prior to their amnesia approach one of them with knowledge of who they are, they immediately assume that based off how these new cookies know who they are but they don’t know them, the newcomers must be friends/family of the other (ex when black sapphire and candy apple appear, shadow milk presumes they know about him because pv must’ve sent them letters talking about him; when white lily and the main cast appear, pv presumes smilk was bragging about him somewhere (as he is now prone to do without a reason to hold a grudge against pv) and know of him that way) and this greatly confuses everyone… but since shadowvanilla are so easy going and insistent about the whole thing it makes it hard for anyone to really object.
I can also imagine that since their memories are gone, they look at the soul jams on their outfits and realize this is maybe really important? And shouldn’t be worn on their person doing physical labor, and so they instead have them displayed side by side on the wall next to each other somewhere in their home and to everyone who knows them and has to walk in and see that, they find it a sickeningly romantic thing and are almost embarrassed just looking at it despite shadowvanilla’s nonchalance of it all
cries as i post this despite rlly wanting to draw something along to the image of black sapphire thinking shadow milk is back only to realize it was just a false alarm, then hit with candy apple memories UAGAGHHHHH
but i must bc this is wonderful and i love ur big asks u have left me eclipsery i promise, im sorry for sitting on this one it was simply too lovely