palia bachelors with an s/o who has a bed full of plushies | hassian, hodari, einar, nai'o, reth & jel x gn!reader | contains heavy 18+ content (except for einar) so mdni
Reth jokingly refers to them as your children, often saying he needs to 'move the children over' to make enough room to slide into the bed beside you. Other times, he has to get up and take the plushies out of the room before he feels comfortable enough to engage in any 'adult activities'.
"C'mon, sweet tooth, not in front of the children," he complains teasingly mid-kiss, eyes twinkling with that mischievous glint you both love and dread.
"They're literally full of cotton, Reth."
Reth gasps and clamps his hands over their plush ears. "Don't listen, kids, your [mommy/daddy] doesn't know what they're saying."
You have to remind yourself why you love this dorky chef so much on a nightly basis with his theatrical antics - but then your annoyance fades when he has your legs thrown over his shoulders, his tongue lapping at your soaked hole with more enthusiasm than when he's eating a bowl of soup.
Hodari is a little uncomfortable with all the plushies on the bed, even though you go out of your way to move them any time he spends the night at your house, he can still feel their beady eyes watching from the other corner of the room.
"I jus' don't understand why you gotta have a small army of these things, darlin'," he sighs one night. Both of you are already in bed and snuggled together, his hand absentmindedly stroking your hair.
You shrug in his arms. "I don't know, I think they're cute. Plus they're kind of like reminders of the different bugs I caught or animals I hunted. A few are even from times I teamed up with friends. They make me happy when I look at them."
Hodari doesn't complain about them again after that. If they make you happy, that's enough for him - even if they still give him the creeps and he has to put effort into pretending their little button eyes aren't watching as he rails you into the mattress so hard your cries and the sound of skin slapping echo throughout the house.
Nai'o thinks they're cute and you're even cuter for having so many, all neatly arranged on your bed. He even gifts you a few if he happens upon any. There's a Butterball plushie he made himself just for you that sits among the others and it makes him beam with pride and love each time he sees it.
He also has a guilty pleasure of making you bury your face in said plushies when he's taking you from behind, eyes rolling back in his head and hips slapping against your rear end as he whimpers and whines above you: "O-oh, babe, you feel - hah - feel so good, so good, babe."
After, he feels a little guilty and makes sure to apologise to them, especially Butterball, and then you, despite your continued assurances that you in fact do not mind at all.
Nai'o will then bury his face in your chest for the rest of the night and pointedly not look at any of the plushies without blushing.
Hassian thinks they are childish and voices his disapproval each time he spends the night, whether it's with a click of his tongue and a distasteful look or a passive comment on where he will sleep when there's clearly no available space on the bed.
But he tries to be respectful of your environment and doesn't toss them out onto the floor like he wants to, especially when the both of you are on your sides and he has you pressed up against him, your back to his front, his cock sliding in and out of your wet hole, creating lewd sounds that mix with your gasps and moans.
He fixes each plushie with a fierce glare as he takes you in his arms, wrapping an arm around your sternum and pulling you back into him as if he's laying claim to you, teeth bared in a silent snarl that says 'mine'.
A secret, ugly part of him wants to pump his cum all over the plushies in a primal display of dominance, marking his territory - or, even better, having you ruin them with your release that he is the bringer of. (But he never voices this aloud to you.)
Quite frankly, Jel is disappointed in your taste. These plushies add nothing to your decor and they only serve to push him out of your bed from the lack of space on it. He pouts and makes comments on how they must bear more importance to you than he does when you insist on having them on the bed with both of you.
Little abominations, all of them, especially when he's whining underneath you and splays his hands out to fist the sheets, accidently grabbing a plushie instead and briefly souring his ascent to ephemeral heights.
Will plead with you to move them elsewhere, anywhere - preferably the shipping bin outside your house - and gives you the saddest, wettest eyes until you cave.
Jel has never been happier than when he walks into your bedroom to see the plushies have finally been moved off the bed. Now he has all the space in the world for you both to explore each other's bodies and pleasure one another well into the night, with no risk of meeting the beady soulless eyes of a Rainbow-tipped butterfly plushie.
Einar does not understand plushies and your desire to have them until you explain that they are much to you like what shiny pebbles are to him. Then he understands completely and does not ask you to compromise their resting place. Rather, he is careful not to squish any when you ask him to cuddle in bed with you, a slightly difficult task given his height and stature, but when you ask him for closeness he finds he cannot deny you.
Humans are strange in their need for constant affection and touching but he finds he does not detest it entirely himself. It is somewhat soothing to have your warm body against his cold metal frame.
Einar makes a point to greet the plushies each time he meanders into your bedroom, gently patting each one on the head. He does the same thing to say goodbye the next morning before leaving for the lake.
Will keep an eye out for any plushies he might spot in the lake or accidently fish up himself. He is so proud to present you with one and see your entire being light up with joy, it makes his mechanical heart tick faster with what he has come to realise is the human term called love.
recently been playing palia on another account on ps5 and the lack of content for me to binge read inspired this.
also i'm sorry but i cannot physically write smut for einar, he's just too pure and i don't even understand how that would work anatomically. also, does he have a mechanical heart? idk but he does now.
let me know if i should include the bachelorettes! (and maybe ashura too hehe)
thanks for reading :3
- kat
[ mdni & palia bachelors banners are by me, the strawberries divider is by @strangergraphics & floral dividers by @diviniyae ]










