FCB’s Blood Equality Campaign: Science Over Stigma
Harold Julian has been working with FCB on a series of portraits for the Blood Equality, an organization thats mission is to change the FDA ban of gay men donating blood. We wanted to know why agencies work on pro bono work and how they choose their causes.
ETC: Why do agencies do pro bono work?
FCB Health: Pro bono work is in our agency’s DNA, and there are essentially 3 reasons: 1: To attract and retain the best people. 2: It elevates our game and forces us to think smarter and more stealthily. 3: We are humans. And we are lucky. We should be doing pro bono. We need to do it.
How do ad agencies select pro bono accounts that they want to work on?
Great ideas come from all over. FCB Health also created a “WHAT IF” initiative to proactively seek these kinds of projects. Usually it’s a passion project from someone on the team. A client or category often sparks an idea. Something in our lives or in the news strikes a chord.
How did Blood Equality evolve, or how did the project come to be?
A passion project from a team (Cameron + Marissa) sparked the original “what if” idea. It’s blossomed since then.
Tell us what Blood Equality is all about.
All blood is not created equal. At least that’s the message that gay and bisexual men are getting. Believe it or not, today gay men are banned from donating blood… even to a mother, child, husband, brother, or friend one… and even in an emergency.
Each year we turn away more than 600,000 pints of blood. Recently, a lifetime ban gave way to a new policy: gay men must now remain celibate for 1 year before they’re allowed to donate. So much for progress.
Every pint of blood is carefully screened – and it's time to put an end to a policy based on stigma, not science. There is no such thing as “gay blood” and treating it as something inferior cannot be accepted.
Blood Equality was created to spark dialogue, encourage scientific discussion, and accelerate the process towards a more rational, less discriminatory policy.
What does your campaign want to accomplish?
Broaden awareness that a ban still exists, and accelerate the process to change the policy to one based on science, not stigma.
Has anyone whose taken part, or involved with Blood Mirror been effected by this discrimination or the FDA policy directly?
We all breathe the same air. Red blood courses through all of our veins. This policy effects all of us.
How large is the team of people that are assigned on this account at the agency? How large is the team if you consider everyone you’re partnering with?
It began as a small team, but has grown into a passionate tribe – at least a dozen at FCB Health, and 20+ including partners, notably GMHC. Everyone who believes in the mission can play a role.
With FCB Health being an ad agency specific to Healthcare and Pharmaceuticals, was there ever any fear that challenging the FDA mandate in this way would have repercussions to the ad agency at large?
It’s an interesting question, but we look at it this way: taking a respectful yet determined stance for a belief is something everyone should be entitled to.
The campaign partners with a few people and organizations, including Jordan Eagles and his fine art installation piece Blood Mirror. Can you tell us how the fine art piece and the ad campaign are linked? Can you tell us about the other partners you have for the campaign?
Our initial research turned up a range of people speaking out on the issue. Jordan’s work immediately caught our eye. It’s moving, human and powerful. We met him, and were instantly struck – and it was Jordan who suggested we partner and launch an FCB Health Artist-in-Residence program. We’re lucky to have his passion and his thinking to help guide the effort.
There is a questionnaire you must fill out before you donate blood. That questionnaire assumes that people are going to be honest. Do you have any insight on if the FDA has thought about the possibility of people being dishonest about their sexuality?
We can’t read minds, but we’re sure the fact that the questionnaire is based on “the honor system” was considered. It’s faulty, of course, on many levels. But the good news: we have screening processes in place to balance self-reporting weaknesses. Our opinion is that the question “are you a man who has had sex with a man?” is a remnant of antiquated thinking, and does not reflect today’s understanding of blood safety.
What were the steps you took, or are taking, to build the campaign?
The structure is in 2 parts: build broad awareness, and spark meaningful debate and discussion. Everything is being considered: from Film, television PSAs, amazing photography (thanks to the genius Harold Julian), social media everywhere, a “Selfie” tool to allow broad engagement, scientific panels, you name it.
How did you find the photographer?
It was kind of old school: an FCB Health agency producer has a relationship with an incredible photography producer/rep, they talk, and we discover the campaign strikes the same chord. Then we all agree to try to create something magical.
You have a lot of mediums for the campaign, digital, print, photo, etc. How was this the initial creative (Look/Feel) for the campaign developed?
The look and feel is all about the issue: deep crimsons and dark shadows. It’s the aesthetic of the issue. Jordan’s Blood Mirror work greatly influenced the campaign style overall. We feel it’s still evolving.
The first set of ads were released early in 2016 and more ads that are coming out later this year. How has the visibility increased to the cause since the web site and the creative has been released?
It’s early still. We’re pushing it all out there – but the focus now is on amplification. The issue deserves more attention. And more eyeballs are the way to spark dialogue and promote the kind of discourse that can change policy. June 14 is World Blood Donor Day – we’re gearing up to make it a true springboard for bigger/broader/better.
What is next for Blood Equality?
More film. More photography. More amazing things. More partnerships. More people with followings joining us. And, of course, more pressure to evolve the policy to something that treats every pint of donated blood with the respect it deserves.
What does the word “Fearless” mean to Blood Equality?
Being true. Being courageous. Being relentless.
Creative Director: Rich Levy, Mike Devlin
Copywriter: Marissa Kraft, Kit Tang, Ysabel Cacho, Emily Dias, Rebecca Miller, Casey Ross
Art Director: Cameron Pollard, Arnold Calderon, Olivia Acerra, Alex Lally, Thomas Kwak, Kari Bocassi
Production: Matt Hall, Ian Smith, Cassandra Bull, Grace Na
Art: Jordan Eagles (FCB Health Artist-in-Residence), Harold Julian (Photographer, ETC)
Art Production Partners: Joe Lombardo (Agent/Producer, ETC), Philip Pavliger (ETC), and Erica Chadwick (ETC)
Account & Strategy: Jill Rossi, Phoebe Restrepo, Joe Fisher, Connor Jones
Client: GMHC: Anthony Hayes, Kelsey Louie