EVERYTHING HAS CHANGED finale
reader x gator // brothers best friend?
cw: light smut
chapter 3 chapter 4📍
You turn twenty-four in April and nobody makes a big deal out of it.
Your dad makes the good breakfast. Real eggs, not the toast-and-concentrate Tuesday version. Coffee that’s actually strong.
Rook gives you a card he clearly bought that morning based on the fact that it still has the price sticker on the back, which you peel off and put on his forehead. He’s eating and he doesn’t notice for twenty minutes. It’s a good morning. A quiet one.
Gator comes by in the afternoon.
He doesn’t have anything with him — no gas station cake, you’re twenty-four, that’s not what this is anymore.
He just comes through the back door and drops into his chair and says “happy birthday” like it’s a normal thing to say, low and easy, like it’s not something he’s said to you every year since you were seven years old.
“Thanks,” you say.
“You doing anything tonight?”
“This.” You gesture around at the kitchen. “This is the thing.”
He looks around the kitchen. Rook is outside. Your dad is somewhere in the house. “Wild,” he says.
“I know how to live.”
He almost smiles. He reaches into his jacket pocket and puts something on the table and slides it across.
A folded piece of paper.
You look at it.
Look at him.
He’s looking at the table.
You unfold it.
It’s a drawing.
A bad one, deliberately bad, the kind he’s always done — a stick figure in cowboy boots standing next to what might be a truck or might be a building, and underneath in his messy handwriting: 24. still shorter than me. happy birthday kid.
You look at it for a second.
“I’m not that much shorter than you,” you say.
“You’re significantly shorter than me.”
“The boots add two inches.”
“Boots are on the figure.” Deadpan.
“Still shorter.”
You fold it back up. “I’m keeping this,” you say.
“I figured.”
You put it in your pocket and you don’t look at him because if you look at him right now you’ll do something you can’t take back. It’s your birthday, you’re in your dad’s kitchen and the timing is completely wrong.
The timing is always wrong.
You look at the table instead.
“Thank you,” you say. Quiet.
He doesn’t say it’s nothing or don’t mention it. He just says “yeah” in the low way he says things when he means them.
It’s enough and it’s not enough at all.
May turns into June and the ranch gets worse.
You feel it the way you’ve always felt it, something in the quality of the light over the Tillman fields, the silence that falls wrong.
Roy’s truck in and out all day. Gator still comes by, still sits at the table, but he’s wound tight in the way he gets when he’s keeping something at volume and has been for too long.
One Wednesday night in June it’s the worst it’s ever been.
You watch from your window as Gator crosses the yard to the fence line and stands there.
You know that posture.
You’ve known it for years— the particular stillness that means Roy has been bad and Gator is trying to hold himself together without anyone watching.
He doesn’t know you’re watching.
You pull your boots on.
You’ve never crossed on a bad night.
You’ve stood on your side of the fence for years, watching, staying and definitely not crossing, because crossing felt like something— like a declaration. Like you’re admitting something you haven’t been ready to admit.
But tonight, you cross.
The grass is wet. Your boots are loud as you walk across the fence line. Across the Tillman yard.
Gators at the far fence looking at the dark pasture when he hears you coming.
He doesn’t turn around.
But his shoulders change, some of the tension goes out of them, just slightly, the way it does when something you’ve been holding gets lighter.
You come and stand next to him.
You don’t say anything.
You look at the same dark pasture, you stand there and that’s all.
After a while he says: “He’s selling the north pasture to pay for his campaign.”
“The grazing land?” you ask.
“Yeah.”
“Gator,”
“It’s his ranch.” Flat. The thing he always says when he needs something to be simple. “It’s his call.”
“I know it’s his call.” You turn toward him. “That’s not what I’m talking about.”
He looks at you. The exhaustion in his face hits you somewhere low and hard.
“What do you want me to say?” he asks.
“That it’s killing you. That you’re tired. That you’ve been holding all of it at arm’s length for so long you’ve forgotten what it feels like to put it down.” You hold his gaze. “You don’t have to be fine for me. You’ve never had to do that with me.”
He looks away. Jaw working.
“I knew you before all of this,” you say. Quieter now. “Before the badge, before Roy started calling you his right hand, before you learned to stand like that.” You pause. “I knew you when you were twelve years old and you couldn’t sleep in a thunderstorm. So you sat on my porch steps and flinched at the close strikes while pretended you didn’t.”
He goes very still.
“I’m not asking you to be someone else,” you say. “I’m not asking you to stop being Roy’s deputy or stop loving this land or stop being everything you’ve made yourself into. I’m just—” You stop. Try again. “I’m telling you that I see what’s underneath it. I’ve always seen it. And you don’t have to keep it at a distance from me.”
The night is quiet.
Somewhere past the tree line something moves.
A truck on the road a mile out.
“Since when?” he asks. Low and careful.
It’s the same question from October, the one he asked after the four years conversation.
Except this time it means something different. This time it means:
Since when do you see all of it?
Since when were you standing here?
Since when?
You think about a comb. A birthday candle half-melted from being lit and relit. Porch steps in a storm. The left side of a pair of crutches. A note about milk in the back of a drawer.
“A while,” you finally say.
He turns and looks at you then, really looks. In a way he doesn’t always, the way he has to decide to.
He looks at you in the dark and you let him and you look back.
It’s the most seen you’ve felt in as long as you can remember.
“I’m Roy Tillman’s son,” he says. Like a warning. Like you don’t know.
“I know who your dad is.”
“It’s not— that’s not nothing. What that means. Who that makes me.”
“I know what it means.” You don’t look away. “I also know who you are. And those aren’t the same thing.” A beat. “You’ve been both your whole life and I’ve been watching your whole life. I’m telling you I know the difference.”
He’s quiet for a long time.
“I should’ve said something,” he says finally. “Years ago. A long time ago.” He says it like it costs him. Like he’s been keeping that one at volume too. “But I didn’t know if you — I didn’t want to assume. Didn’t want to make it something you had to deal with on top of everything.”
“Gator,”
“You were young. And then you were in school. And then you came back and I kept thinking- I kept waiting for the right—” He stops. Shakes his head. “There was never a right time.”
“There’s not going to be a right time,” you say. “There never was.”
He looks at you. The corner of his mouth does something that isn’t quite a smile and isn’t quite anything else.
“How long?” you ask. “Since when? For you.”
He holds your gaze for a long moment.
“You moved the remote,” he says.
You blink. “What?”
“First time. When you were seven.” He says it simply, like it’s obvious, like it’s always been obvious. “Saturday morning. You just.. reached out and moved it to my side. Didn’t say anything, didn’t make it a thing. Just did it.” He looks at you. “I noticed.”
Your chest does the thing.
The thing it’s been doing for twenty years.
“I’ve always noticed,” he says. “Every time. I’ve been noticing since before I knew what I was noticing.” A pause. “The drawer, too.”
Your eyes widen. “You know about the drawer?”
“I’ve always known about the drawer.”
“How?”
“Because I left the notes on purpose.” He says it like it’s simple. Like this isn’t the thing that reorders everything. “Every one of them. I knew where they’d end up.”
You stare at him.
“You left them on purpose?”
“Yeah.”
“For twenty years?”
“Yeah.”
“Gator.” You can hear your own voice, something broken open in it, something that’s been closed a long time. “That’s… you should’ve said something.”
“I was waiting for you.” Not an accusation. A fact, plain and steady. “It had to be you. When you were ready.” He looks at the pasture, then back at you. “You crossed the fence tonight.”
You did.
You crossed the fence on a bad night because you were done staying on your side of it.
Because you’ve been done for a while and tonight finally proved it.
“I’m ready,” you say.
“I know,” he says.
His hand comes up and cups the side of your face, his thumb at your jaw, and you grab the front of his jacket.
The kiss is slightly off-angle because you both move at once, and it’s nothing like the movies, it’s nothing like anything, it’s just the most ordinary extraordinary thing.
His other hand finds your waist.
You press closer.
When you pull back you’re still holding his jacket.
“I always had the drawer full of notes,” you say. “About milk. And my brother owing you money. And bad drawings. Since the very first one i’ve kept them.”
“I know,” he says.
“I kept all of them.”
“I know you did.” He looks at you. There’s a soft thing in his face that you’ve never seen before and never want to stop seeing. “That’s why I kept leaving them.”
You’re very good at hiding it from Rook.
Three weeks of careful timing and late nights and leaving separately.
You’ve had twenty-four years of practice not saying things about Gator and it turns out that training transfers.
Rook is perceptive about most things.
He is not perceptive about this.
He has never once been perceptive about this, which you’ve always found equal parts convenient and baffling.
Three weeks. You make it three weeks.
The morning it happens is a Saturday in July.
That Saturday morning you’re in Gator’s room, door locked, supposed to have another two hours before Rook gets back.
You’re straddling Gator on his bed, shirt already on the floor.
His hands are rough and sure on your bare skin, thumbs dragging over your nipples until you shiver.
“Been thinking about this all week,” he mutters against your throat, sucking a mark just below your collarbone. “You in my bed. Wearing nothing but those damn shorts.”
You rock your hips down against the hard line of him through his jeans. “Then stop talking and take them off.”
He flips you onto your back in one smooth motion, making you laugh breathlessly.
His mouth trails down your chest, teeth and tongue teasing until you’re arching off the bed.
When he finally gets your shorts and underwear down, he doesn’t tease. He spreads your thighs and puts his mouth on you like a man starving.
“Gator! fuck-/” Your fingers twist in his freshly washed hair as his tongue works you open, two thick fingers sliding inside you, curling just right.
He groans against your slick skin, the vibration shooting straight through you.
“You taste so fucking good,” he growls, looking up at you with dark eyes. “Been dying to get my mouth on you.”
You come hard the first time, thighs clamped around his head, biting your arm to stay quiet. He doesn’t stop, just works you through it until you’re shaking, then climbs up your body and kisses you filthy so you can taste yourself on his tongue.
You shove his jeans down, wrap your hand around him, it’s hot, heavy, already leaking.
“Want you inside me, Gator.”
“Yeah?” He nips your jaw. “You sure?”
“Now.”
He grabs a condom from the nightstand, rolls it on, and pushes into you in one slow, steady thrust.
You both moan at the stretch.
He’s thick, and the fullness makes your toes curl.
“Shit,” he breathes, forehead pressed to yours. “You feel… fuck, you’re perfect.”
He starts moving, deep, rolling thrusts that hit just right every time.
You wrap your legs around his waist, nails digging into his back.
The bed creaks quietly. Sweat slick between you.
He kisses you messy and desperate, muttering curses and your name against your mouth.
“Right there. Don’t stop,” you gasp.
“Not stopping,” he promises, snapping his hips harder. “Not ever.”
You come again with his thumb on your clit and his cock buried deep.
He follows right after, groaning your name like a prayer as he spills into the condom, hips stuttering.
You’re still tangled together, catching your breath and trading lazy kisses, when footsteps sound in the hall.
No knock.
The door swings open.
The four seconds that follow are the worst four seconds Stark County has ever produced.
Rook stands there, frozen. His eyes flick from you— naked, flushed, legs still around Gator— to Gator— pants around his ankles, condom still on— and back again.
“Jesus Christ,” Rook mutters. He looks at the ceiling. “I forgot my… yeah. Okay.”
He closes the door.
The silence that follows is deafening.
“Fuck,” Gator says, dropping his face into the crook of your neck.
You stare at the ceiling, heart still racing for entirely different reasons now. “That was… not how I wanted him to find out.”
“How bad is it you think?” you mumble.
Gator is looking at the door. “Don’t know yet.”
You sit up. “I should talk to him first. He’s my brother.”
Gator looks at you and nods, because he understands the order of things.
You find Rook at the lake.
Of course you do.
You’ve known since you were nine years old that Rook goes to water when he doesn’t know what to do with something.
He’s on the end of the dock with his feet hanging off and he hears you coming and doesn’t turn around.
You sit next to him. Let your feet hang off too. The lake is flat and a murky green.
“How long?” he asks.
“Officially? Three weeks.”
“And unofficially.”
You look at the water. “A while.”
He makes a sound. Picks up a piece of a rock and throws it in. “It’s weird.”
“I know.”
“It’s really weird.”
“I know, Rook.”
“He’s my best friend.”
“I know he is.”
He looks at the water for a long time. You let him look.
“Does he make you happy?” he asks finally.
You think about a drawer full of notes left on purpose.
You think about how he’s always known about the drawer.
You think about twenty years of Thursdays and gas station coffee and the long way home.
You think about someone who noticed you moving the remote when you were seven years old and never once forgot about it.
“Yeah,” you say. “He does.”
Rook nods slow. “He better not screw it up.”
“He won’t.”
“I’m just saying.”
“I know.”
He’s quiet.
Then: “You moved the remote for him for like twenty years.”
You look at him. “You noticed that?”
“Everyone noticed that.” He throws another rock. “I just didn’t want to know yet.”
You sit with that.
“Rook?” you mumble.
“Hm?”
“I’m sorry we didn’t tell you.”
“Yeah.” A long pause. “I know.” He exhales. “Give me a week.”
“Take what you need.”
He nods.
You sit on the dock together. The lake is flat and the afternoon is warm.
Something that has been in a drawer for twenty years is finally out where it can breathe.
The conversation between Rook and Gator happens without you.
You get pieces of it after, the way you get pieces of things, sideways, over days.
You find out it was long.
You find out Gator was straight with him, the full truth, no diplomacy.
You find out Gator said: I know who she is. I’ve always known.
You find out that’s what settled it.
Of course it is.
A few weeks and things come back to level.
One Saturday morning you come downstairs, Gator’s at the table with dry cereal and Rook is arguing about something before he’s even sat down. Gator’s giving it right back.
You pour your coffee and sit across from him.
You reach out and move the remote to his side.
Same as always.
Same as the first time, when you were seven years old and didn’t know what you were doing.
Rook says “Why does he always get the remote?”
Gator says “seniority”
You say “that’s not how seniority works”
Rook says “how does it work then”
The whole things stupid, and it’s exactly the same it’s always been.
You look at Gator over your coffee.
He’s already looking at you.
The corner of his mouth twitches up.
You look back at your coffee.
This, you think.
This right here.
The last Saturday in August, all three of you on the dock.
The afternoon is warm and going golden.
The water is green and cold below the boards and the Tillman property spreads out behind you.
You should know what’s coming.
You always know what’s coming.
Rook says: “One!”
You spin. “Don’t you dare.”
“Two!” Gator’s already grinning.
The grin he’s had since he was fourteen.
The one you know better than anything.
“I swear to God, Gator Tillman!”
You go in boots and all.
The water is cold enough to stop your heart.
You go under and come back up. They’re both losing it on the dock, Rook bent over, Gator sitting down on the boards, laughing too hard to stay standing.
You grab the ladder. You haul yourself up.
You stand on the dock dripping and furious and twenty-four years old.
You look at Gator Tillman sitting on the dock of his family’s property crying laughing at you, same as he’s done since you were nine years old, and you think: I have been so gone on this man for so long.
“I hate you,” you say.
“No you don’t,” he says.
Same as always. He’s always known the answer.
You grab the front of his shirt and kiss him.
It’s still half-pissed and half-relieved.
It tastes like summer.
His hands settle on your wet waist and pull you in.
When you pull back you look him dead in the eye.
“I love you,” you say. “You absolute nightmare.”
Something in his face goes quiet and soft and certain all at once.
He brushes the wet hair off your forehead with the same hands that braided your hair when you were six years old.
“Love you too,” he says.
Like it’s simple.
Like it’s always been simple, just waiting for the right dock, the right August, the right moment to finally say it out loud.
“Always have.”
Rook stands up behind you. “I’m going to the house,” he announces. “I saw nothing. I know nothing. I’m at the house.”
He leaves.
Gator looks at you.
You look at him.
The afternoon is gold. The fields go flat and wide. The lake is behind you. Stark County goes on in every direction the way it always has. The way it always will.
“Stay tonight?” he asks.
“Yeah,” you say. “I’m not going anywhere.”
You never were.
taglist: @steviaorsugar @kristywidget97 @skkeletonns @valentine-night @stoneyggirl2 @mrmountebankk @scaramou @kurtsw7rld96 @keerygirlie98 @snoopyharrington @delphinemix @myloveeee2536 @fetushrrygf @0862967 @madaboutjoe @djopotions @haydensheartt @soggycerealtbh
(tags are glitching so sorry if your not tagged!)
