I continue to be fascinated by this round of the Alpha Male Madness poll.
Yes, I have a huge celeb crush on Bob Morley. If I met him I’d probably turn bright red and then stutter and then run away and then cry.
That said, the first Outlander book came out in 1991 (when I was three). I probably started reading the series when I was thirteen. And I’ve awaited every new Diana Gabaldon title with white knuckled anticipation, ever since. When the Outlander TV show was announced, I flipped my shit. The whole fandom did. And it’s been better than I could have imagined. It sticks rigidly to the books, but seems to suffer no negative consequences for doing so. The script is amazing. The actors are amazing. They have consulted Diana every step of the way.
On the other hand, I’ve been a fan of the 100 for a several months now. A rabid fan, no doubt, but the material (both book and show) is new, the fandom is new, and I am relatively new to the fandom.
So as much as I love Bob Morley (desperately) I’ve been voting for Sam Heughan.
And all I can think about is what will happen if Sam Heughan wins the entire poll. Not just this round, but the next one, as well. Everyone who has been ignoring the Outlander fandom all this time will have to acknowledge us. Think of the “think pieces.” I want to read the Daily Dot think piece on why Outlander won. I want to read the Mary Sue think piece on why Outlander won. I can’t even tell you how much I want that. Or exactly why I want it.
The outlander fandom doesn’t look like many others. It’s largely older (huge generalization, but with truth to it) and it resides more significantly on Diana Gabaldon’s Facebook page than on tumblr or Twitter. It has an epic history. There are eight books in the main Outlander series, so far, and each book is hundreds of pages long. For decades, there have been “annual tea parties with the author” and convention appearances. However, as it’s an older historical fantasy series with a largely female audience, the series has never had the same traction in nerd culture that other series have. Its legacy is entwined with the history of the romance novel, though none of the books after the first are remotely romance novels. (EVERY time you see a romance novel with a highlander on the cover, you’re seeing the legacy of Outlander. Outlander started that trend in the early ‘90’s.) Its cross-genre appeal has been its biggest marketing stumbling block. Nonetheless, the fandom has quietly flourished. There are hundreds of thousands of us, and we’ve been at it for decades. Additionally, we’re a living fandom. The most recent book was released this past year, and the series isn’t close to finished yet, never mind the new and wonderful TV show.
But Outlander has been largely ignored by other fandoms and most of current fandom culture. Every time I see a post about this poll, it reads, “who is Sam Heughan” or “wtf is Outlander.”
Outlander is legion. And I just wanted you to know. Just like any fangirl wants to share their joy and passion for their favorite thing. I just wanted you all to know.













