(you're) my favorite song
a firstprince new york subway meet-cute based on the prompt: strangers on a train stranded together
alex is no stranger to weird things one might see on the train. he's made many a list on his notes app in fact, including one lone child-sized mitten (eerie), two rats fighting over another rat on an unused platform (kind of moving actually), and then there was that time he saw a guy casually shooting up at west 4th.
it's not that alex doesn't notice these things. today on his work commute for example there's a man chasing a live crab down the train car, and a woman clipping her toenails in the corner. there's a really hot guy who just sat down and carefully put a tote bag in his lap next to alex.
it's just that alex is kind of busy right now, and his sister was kind of a genius when she bought him noise-canceling headphones and said, "i don't know, listen to an audiobook or something so at least you can say michelle obama made you late to work instead of—what did you call it?"
"west side story, ratatouille edition," says alex. "keep up."
anyway the audiobooks have been hit or miss (michelle's was a hit of course), but he's really enjoying this one now, a novel that's read by the author, who's warm-voiced and wry and sounds like he's kind of hot despite also being british.
still, alex won't be distracted from his usual train duties. he tips the ukelele guy and buys an overpriced candy bar from the mom with the baby strapped to her back, refusing any change.
he's about to press play again but a very excellent barbershop quartet has just stepped on—alex loves these guys—and he's pulling out another bill when he feels something cold and wet on his arm.
"god, i'm so sorry," says the man next to him, then, sternly, "david, please."
what the—? alex likes kids but he draws the line at them licking his elbow. he takes a deep breath and then looks down into the eyes of—oh. a very cute beagle peering out of a tote bag at him.
"he's terribly excited to have made his escape from the vet," says the hot owner of david the dog, "and i guess you smell—" the man blushes for some reason "—nice. to him. i mean."
"oh, everything good?" says alex. "at the vet's?"
david's hot dad looks surprised but happy to be asked. "yes. all good, thank you."
alex lets his headphones slide from his ears as they talk. this guy is super cute. so is his dog. alex is trying to figure out why the guy's voice sounds so familiar when the train abruptly comes to a stop. the conductor says something garbled about some delay. alex isn't really paying attention.
"what're you listening to?" asks the man. alex is struck with a sudden idea on how to pass the time and also maybe even get the guy's number.
"let's trade," he suggests, gesturing at the man's airpods. if he thinks it's strange, he doesn't show it, only shrugging and handing them over.
it takes a second for alex to place that the guy's been listening to an episode of the daily podcast. it takes another few seconds to recognize the sound of alex's own voice being interviewed, as he talks about his refugee work as a civil rights lawyer.
alex turns to stare at the guy as he listens intently to the audiobook play. did he know? that it was alex? is that why he's blushing so hard right now?
then the guy pulls off alex's headphones and says, "err. i'm afraid i've read this one already."
oh. maybe that's why he's embarrassed. "it's amazing, right?" alex asks. "this fox guy is fucking incredible."
the man pauses. even his ears have turned pink. then he says, "thank you."
alex stares for a moment. then he holds up an airpod and asks very casually, "so—henry fox—what do you think of the podcast so far?"
"christ, where to begin?" henry asks, suddenly fervent. "i mean, i've followed mr. claremont-diaz's work for some time now, and i think he's bloody brilliant. i'm sort of enamored with the man, to be honest." he visibly reins himself in. "anyway—sorry, it's nice to meet you, err…?"
"alex," says alex. "claremont. diaz."
"oh," says henry, breathless. "fuck. hi."
alex scoots closer, which david gets very excited about. "here." alex gives one airpod back to henry, holding onto the other. "play me your favorite song next."
henry raises an eyebrow. "and if i just start this episode over?"
alex shakes his head. he's smiling.
(anyway, alex is late to work again. yes, he blames henry. no, it's definitely not going to be the last time he does.)