Took me a while but I think I got down a good set of websites offering to make custom fangs.
Where & How | List of Fangsmiths (US & UK)
Like how blacksmiths are the creators of metal wares, fangsmiths are the creators of...well, fangs. Whether it’s a pair of pointed caps shaped to fit snugly on your teeth, a little disguise to hide the human in you, or cosplay dentures, their craft is best fit for those who want to merge fantasy with reality as much as possible.
Quick note: though I’m listing fangsmiths & their websites down below, I refrained from listing fangsmiths without websites & the smiths who cater on,y toward groups in their local area. So essentially, businesses who can provide their craft by mail. Enjoy! (P.S.: If any of the information listed is incorrect, don’t be afraid to let me know! Same goes for any extra information I missed.)
Dental FX (UK)
Makes fang veneers. On the higher end of the price spectrum, but creates the most professional/realistic looking teeth out of any on this list (excusing HobbyFX).
Welcome to Absolute Dental FX ! Our website is currently under development we still have lots of products to add and informational pages too
Horror Fangs (Albuquerque, NM, USA)
Makes fang caps & veneers. For mail orders, DM him on his Twitter at @HorrorShowFangs or email him asking for the “HSJ Apocalypse Special”. Has (what I believe are) the 3rd lowest prices throughout this list.
Customized Fangsmith | Horror Show Jack Fang Smith | United States
Embrace Your Hunger (NYC, USA)
Makes fang caps. Apparently also makes fang veneers. Has the lowest prices throughout this entire list.
Ali's Savage Traits | Custom Fangs & Special Effects for the NYC tri-state area. Mail orders also available.
Father Sabastion (LA, CA, USA)
Makes fang caps. Local, however he’s known to travel. Mail-to-order fangs are currently sold out.
Homepage of the Master Fangsmith Father Sebastiaan
The Fangsmith (US)
Makes fang caps.
Dark Awakenings, founded in 1998 by Maven, was started as an alternative to the status quo of fang smiths. That holds true today
Custom Fangz (Belton, MS, USA)
Likely makes fang caps. Has an Etsy. Has (what I believe are) the 4th lowest prices throughout this list.
Custom Vampire Fangs Fit to Your Mouth. Not One size fits all. Design Your own fangs too. The most realistic fangs you can get. Vampire, Wer
Teeth by Dnash (Stratford, CT, USA)
Makes fang caps.
Teeth by Dnash custom vampire fangs, werewolf teeth, and dental effects » Teeth By Dnash, home of the finest quality custom vampire fangs, v
PsychicFangs (Downey, CA, USA)
Makes fang caps. Has an Etsy. Provides free shipping, free dental impressions, and a free lifetime repair guarantee.
Psykic Fangs makes high quality teeth and fangs. Each set is made completely from scratch and is completely custom.
Kaos Kustom Fangs (USA)
Makes fang caps. Has a one-time repair guarantee. Has the 2nd lowest prices throughout this list, but their website currently has many of their fangs on sale!
Weclome to the Kaos | kaoskustomfangs
HobbyFX (UK)
Makes veneer based fangs. Has an Etsy they’ve apparently been neglecting (check their recent reviews on Etsy, and you’ll know what I’m talking about).
Custom Made Character Teeth, Vampire Fangs and FX Prosthetic Makeup since 2010
Second Skin FX (Earls Colne, UK)
Primarily on Etsy as far as I know.