Come for the Kevin Nowlan cover, stay for the great & awkward panel by Gary Groth, Gil Kane, Howard Chaykin, and Walter Simonson:
GROTH: Mainstream comics are juvenile trash, recycled pap. Artists should do better
KANE: The art’s where the value lies but the stories are still subliterate. It’s the publishers’ fault. They should do better
CHAYKIN: I fall in between you two
SIMONSON: I’m sitting right here, guys
For the record, I’m into what everyone’s saying. Groth as a critic (and competitor) posits diversity in style & ideas; that has played out over time. Kane as a self-critical artist demands the same values of his peers. Chaykin’s American Flagg! leads the charge of making quality product. Simonson had every right to sound as defensive as he did. He was just a dude making a living by writing & drawing THOR. The subject of values seemed too broad to tackle in an hour, especially with one panelist maybe feeling attacked.
All in all, file under: Essential Reading