something that has always got me about women in movies/tv and is one of the major reasons i get turned off of women in movies/tv (and i say this as someone who actively and voraciously seeks out movies/tv series about women) is when a woman onscreen is expressing emotion but theyre a little bit muted... and then you realise that the actor is concerned with looking pretty while they express this emotion. its that whole "always performing, always being perceived" thing where even when women are alone we* are aware of how we look while we do things. its that expectation of naked vulnerability onscreen, where an actor is meant to be exposing the deepest darkest emotions of a character but its layered underneath "do i look nice enough while im expressing this?" (or "does the director think i look nice enough while im expressing this?") i think the first time i realised that that was what was missing was when i watched the hunger games and saw jennifer lawrence brutally ugly-cry over rue, with spit coming out her mouth, her entire face pink and twisted into agony, and i was like oh -- shes really feeling those things. i think the alternative is also true, where men try to look masculine at all times, but it's not as insidious, because a lot of the time this is ascribed to an acting choice or a reserved character type but for women, its often just oh, shes pretty. its not an active choice for her to not be expressing those things. shes not allowed to be ugly.
and the worst part is that if this was really dug into and we really thought about what it means that a woman cant cry more than a few pretty, glassy tears, she cant laugh too big and joyous, she cant even eat onscreen because her image and the fact that she is pretty is more important than expressing her unique and authentic character, that would be a fascinating analysis and a fascinating depth to a character. but we dont get the privilege of that analysis, and it often feels jarring to read into because i often find that interpretation jarring against the character herself -- if shes alone, why wouldnt she ugly cry? shes open with her emotions in every other situation, why wouldnt she be open here? is she that obsessed with her image that she holds herself under such extreme restraint while alone? it often doesnt ring true and I cant give the benefit of the doubt.
i think its also a marketing thing for some media, which takes me out of the moment of the scene because its a huge reminder that people are watching this show/movie to see a pretty woman, the actor has a certain reputation to uphold and if she ugly cries, then she's not that any more. i personally want to see more ugly crying, i want to see more big expressive emotion, and i want to see women unapologetically being ugly onscreen.
*im nonbinary but I present as a woman