Father Jud Duplenticy Smut Blurb
Pairing: Jud Duplenticy x Gender Neutral!Reader
Content Ahead: religious imagery (duh), reader confesses to lying, father Jud has to relieve them of their sins somehow, sexual acts in a church, father jud is a service switch ofc, written by an agnostic, “Child” is used in a “Child of God” manner, allusions to smut, reader has ambiguous genitalia
Synopsis: You call for a private meeting with Father Jud to confess a lie, little did you know there was more that needed to be confessed.
Word Count: 1.3k
Author’s Note: just a little blurb to get off my chest bc this man is consuming my every thought and we NEED more fics. lmk what you think :3 send requests and i will try my best to fulfill them <3! also please correct me and teach me if i get aspects of religion wrong!!! i try my best to be accurate and technical but it’s been years since i’ve practiced or gone to a church so help a guy out 🙏🏽
Part 2 can be read here
Image from this post by @custardhorse .
This blog is 18+ ONLY!!!! MDNI you WILL be blocked! Ageless blogs you risk being blocked too!
Father Jud is a pleaser, a giver, a service provider. His title of priesthood is one he wears daily— a servant and conduit of God and the gospel. Jud exists to serve his people who enter the double doors of his (inherited) chapel and sit in the pews to listen to His word. He exists to guide sinful souls to the path of God, so he sits in the confessional and listens to the words of the damned and attempt to guide them to salvation.
But it’s hard for Father Jud to remain unaffected by the confessions he hears. He hears so much constantly every time he wears his clerical collar— the darkest truths one can carry are spoken into his ears. He struggles daily to shoulder those truths while living; he has to do so in order to remain strong enough to carry out his acts of service, but sometimes he has a penitent confess in such a way he can’t help but want to do more than what’s expected in pastoral care. But how can he resist the need to protect his flock when he knows so much about them?
How can he resist you?
You, who is new to the town and new to the faith, as far as he knows. You have your questions and fundamental truths that the faith cannot change, which sets you far apart from the rest of the flock Father Jud has come to know and care for. He always wants to hear more from you, egging you into expanding on all of your thoughts and questions to understand you deeper. He claims it’s in order to serve you best, but you can’t help but second guess if there’s ulterior motives when noticing his eyes lingering at your lips when you speak, or your body when you stand up to leave. You’d be a liar if you said you didn’t stare at Father Jud in a similar manner. Honestly… you are a liar for saying the faith is what brought you through those cathedral doors. You entered this church with architectural interest, you just decided to stay when the way-too-attractive-to-be-a-priest showed you the sincere care and attention you’ve been deprived of for far too long.
You feared judgement from the other church goers if they learned your truth, so you’ve asked Father Jud for a private moment to confess your lie— your sin. You didn’t think your request would lead you to an empty church on a rainy night, however. Sitting in the front pew looking up at the tall cleric who’s looking down at you with big fluttering eyelashes and a giant cross in the background weighs heavy, but it’s the ideal circumstance to reveal the truth.
“So, what can I do for you, my Child?”
You gulp on air at the sudden break in silence, your hands instantly getting sweaty. Why are you getting so nervous? This is by far not the worst thing you’ve confessed to the man, but the unpredictability of his reaction is what scares you. So you speak your truth, “Please, forgive me, Father, for I have lied to you since the moment we met. I am not one of faith, at least not one as devoted as you. I came here because I wanted to see the inside of these church walls after admiring them from the outside for so long. I didn’t mean to start regular attending but when you greeted me and invited me in, I couldn’t say no. And so I kept coming back— for you.”
He hums in response, his hands clasped in front of him as he nods. He takes a moment to contemplate his words before questioning, “Why is it that you requested a private meeting with me?”
Your eyebrows furrow. Why is that the question he asks? You take a second before responding, “I… I just wanted to confess-“
He cuts you off, “No. You’ve confessed to me before during service hours with no problem. Why did you want to meet with me privately?”
Suddenly having the man of God stare down at you feels intimidating. You could tell him your fear of confessing within proximity of devoted churchgoers, but even you know that is only a partial truth. Why did you ask for a private meeting? Your thoughts start racing along with your heart as you break eye contact with the man in front of you.
Before you can get too lost in your own head, you see Father Jud step closer and kneel before you. A hand reaches to your knee and outer upper thigh. Your eyes instantly lock into the touch, to the big hand resting on you before traveling up the sleeved arm, up his collared neck adorned with the colored tattoo, to his face with his beautiful eyes staring back. Your heart begins to race along with your thoughts— there’s a kneeling priest before you and you feel your lower body begin to match the heat of his hand on you.
You begin to stutter quietly, “Father, I-” before getting cut off by Jud, “Lying is one of the most common sins, did you know? Your confession weighs little in comparison to others, but of course that’s not something you’re suppose to do either; much like how you’re not supposed to stare at a member of the clergy with lust during service.”
Blood rushes throughout your body as your heartbeat quickens. You feel Father Jud’s hand tighten around you as you two both stare into each other’s dilated eyes. You’re at a loss for words. So Father Jud continues, “I know the people of this church, this town. I know the face of a sinner when they carry their sin so heavily and so closely to the surface that it’s threatening to spill. I know the face of lust and want and need. Tell me, my Child, what is it that you need from me? Why is it that you called for this private meeting?”
Your hand lays on top of his, gripping softly, “Forgive me Father, for the lust and want ravage me. It needs- I need you.”
He smiles, “You have me, sweet sinner.” He caresses your knees and thighs with two hands now, “Now tell me, where do you need me? Show me.”
You stay still for a moment as you look into his eyes for any possible signs of doubt. But when you stare into his nearly black orbs, all you see is sincerity and lust, maybe even a need to service— one you’ve seen him wear often as he performs his heavenly duties. It feels wrong to undress in front of a cleric, but you’ve never seen a man on his knees if it wasn’t out of desperation or salvation.
You lift your hips for a brief moment to pull down your bottoms before sitting back on the pew, spreading your legs before him. Father Jud stares at the center mass between your legs, his eyes and tongue watering at the sight. He can’t help the tightening of his own pants as his hands comes into contact with your bare thighs. He massages your thighs lightly as he adjusts to the warmness without fabric in the way. His eyes are locked to what is between your legs— he bites his bottom lips as he watches wetness exude from between.
His heartbeat races in excitement and in shame. He knows he will have to pay penance for this later. He knows you are breaking his devotion to God, but how can he tell the difference between devoting to God and devoting to you? How can he differentiate the Heaven he reads and the one he sees right in front of him?
He inches closer to your throbbing warm center. He inhales your scent deeply, saving it in his memory, before exhaling heavily. You twitch at the feeling of his hot breath so close to where you needed him most, unable to hold back the whimper and buckle of your hips towards him. Father Jud lets out a low moan at your neediness.
Before showing you mercy, he looks up at the ceiling and does the sign of the cross as he quietly prays, “Bless me Father for I am about to sin.”
Part 2 can be read here
A/N: this was just supposed to be some quick headcannons but then i was like "oh i might as well just write a little blurb" since i got carried away but, wouldn't you guess it, i got carried away again soooooo i'm splitting this into 2 parts to at least get something out there for all those starving for Jud Duplenticy fics (me). sorry to leave y'all hanging! i'll add part 2's link here once it's done. part 2 will mainly be oral sex (both receiving) and should be out soon :3 i'll make it worth it i promise!













