for the fandom ask thing: i want to know your thoughts on both shetland and lewis. but that is maybe too much? maybe just pick one or pick which fandom you want to answer each question for?
when it comes to talking about shetland and lewis there really is no such thing as “too much”, pri 💕 thank you for asking!
the first character i ever fell in love with: jimmy perez
a character that i used to love/like, but now do not: billy’s dog, but that’s bc he isn’t there anymore? 😭
a ship that i used to love/like, but now do not: when it comes to shetland, i’m more of a one-ship-only-kinda-girl
my ultimate favorite character™: ah, that has to be jimmy again, just because he’s such a kind person. i love his quietness and his empathy for people, his compassion, his optimism and positive outlook on humanity that he guards so fiercely against the despair and violence he sees in his job, and his reluctance to give up on anybody, his moral integrity and his desire to treat people fairly and without prejudice. and i also love the sad things about him, his struggle to overcome his grief and (re-)connect with people. and i like that eventhough he admits himself that he is not always good at sharing his emotions, he still allows himself to be open and vulnerable with a selected few (mostly cassie and duncan) and he tries his best to be a good dad. (having said that, duncan has really grown on me as well. and i have a lot of feelings about him)
prettiest character: tosh (typical case of “do i want to be her? or do her?” she has some good flannels 👌) also duncan keeps getting hotter each season, which is doing things to both jimmy and me 💦
my most hated character: it’s a tough call between alice and olivia, but i think i have to go with olivia just bc (apart from all the other shitty things she’s done) she was really cruel to jmmy and never apologised
my OTP: i don’t know if anybody has noticed… but that’d be jimmy/duncan
my NOTP: jimmy/any forced love interest he falls in love with after 5 seconds
favorite episode: from the free-standing episodes i think i like red bones and raven black the best; and i also really love the final episode of s4 (which has some really good jimmy and duncan scenes; what can i say, i am a simple woman)
saddest death: thomas malone; oh boy, his death destroyed me
favorite season: i just re-watched s3 and that was a really good season, but overall i think i love s4 the most, both in terms of plot/case and the character moments
least favorite season: for now, i think i’ll have to say s5 bc even though it was still a pretty great season, i didn’t like it as much as ones before. but it gave us some great jimmy and duncan moments so idek 🤷♀️ i def have to watch it again without the one week break between the episodes, maybe i’ll like it a bit better then
character that everyone else in the fandom loves, but i hate: from what i’ve read, nobody loves neither alice nor olivia, so i think i’m in good/plentiful company with my dislike there
my ‘you’re piece of trash, but you’re still a fave’ fave: i think the closest we get to having a “piece of trash” on this show is duncan bc he is involved in some dodgy shit and also doesn’t have the best record in terms of fidelity… but i still love him so much and he is so much more than his flaws and fuck-ups and i’m glad that the show portrays his other sides as well
my ‘beautiful cinnamon roll who deserves better than this’ fave: tosh! and sandy! oh god, i need to know what happens to sandy, can the bbc just renew the show already?!
my ‘this ship is wrong, nasty, and makes me want to cleanse my soul, but i still love it’ ship: again, this show is too pure for me to have a nasty ship? or maybe i’m just not watching it right haha
my ‘they’re kind of cute, and i lowkey ship them, but i’m not too invested’ ship: tosh/donnie, cassie/the baby police officer
the first character i ever fell in love with: james hathaway (to no one’s surprise…)
a character that i used to love/like, but now do not: i seldomly change my mind when it comes to liking/disliking a character, and if i do, it’s more likely that i grow to love them? at least that’s what happened with jean innocent for me. i used to feel a bit indifferent about her in the beginning when she was mostly the annoying boss figure who made robbie and james do things they didn’t like, but i ended up really liking her.
a ship that i used to love/like, but now do not: i’ve only ever loved one ship in this fandom…
my ultimate favorite character™: james hathaway; he is fascinating and at the same time i’ve rarely related to a character more. and he’s an excellent character to project all my issues on, like the internalised homophobia thing. or the faith thing. or that thing where he never seems to properly fit in anywhere bc he finds it difficult to connect with people. in summary: he really ticks all my boxes.
prettiest character: james hathaway
my most hated character: everyone in “old, unhappy, far off things” (except james and robbie, maybe. oh, and i guess the girl in the coma and her sister are okay, too. all the other characters are trash)
my NOTP: robbie/laura; james/scarlet; i’m also not too keen on the whole ot3 business
favorite episode: wild justice
saddest death: will’s death was definitely the one that had the biggest impact on both james and me (though that applies to many of the more personal episodes, they tend to make me much sadder than the “regular” cases)
favorite season: it’s a tie between s2 and s6, i think? it’s really difficult to say bc most seasons have at least one episode that i absolutely adore and another one that i don’t like that much. s1 was really good as well…
least favorite season: i’ve just realised that i really need to re-watch the later seasons bc i don’t remember that much about them? so i’m just gonna go with s7 for this category
character that everyone else in the fandom loves, but i hate: well, hate is a strong word, but i couldn’t care less about laura
my ‘you’re piece of trash, but you’re still a fave’ fave: both robbie and james have their trashy moments
my ‘beautiful cinnamon roll who deserves better than this’ fave: again, both robbie and james. what can i say, they both are beautiful trash cinnamon rolls.
my ‘this ship is wrong, nasty, and makes me want to cleanse my soul, but i still love it’ ship: hmm, i don’t think i have a nasty ship in lewis, either? i think i’m just not that into nasty ships? i just prefer angst, i guess, and that also makes me want to cleanse my soul at times, haha
my ‘they’re kind of cute, and i lowkey ship them, but i’m not too invested’ ship: james/father francis (totally “lowkey”…. yeah *coughs*)