So i was recently watching this video from the stranger things costume department person (idk what role she had so i'll just say person 😂), and she was saying how most of her outfits for the characters protrayed their mental state, or part of their arc (like max wearing dark clothes when she's depressed).
Do you think the hsmtmts costume department does the same here? Would that somehow explain Nini's questionable outfits? If so, how would you analyze their clothes to fit their arcs?
I'd love to hear your thoughts on this!
hi! thank you so much for the ask- this was a lot of fun. at some point i do still plan on eventually making some posts about character wardrobe, but idk when that'll happen, so this is a cool opportunity to do a little taste of that for y'all!
so... i think costume departments can definitely do different things with wardrobe, whether that's intentional color schemes for different things, matching like- their storyline, showing growth and confidence through more bright colored or bold choices, maintaining a consistent look for the characters (probably one of the most important goals of a costume department), etc.
while i don't think nini's outfits are necessarily a part of the whole like- mental state thing... (she's actually one of the most consistent characters as far as wardrobe is concerned. her staples are florals (particularly in season 1, but she does a few times in season 2, or at least once lol), tops with collars, hair ribbons, and sweaters, also layering to a certain extent (in 1.01 it's not a skirt with flowers on it- it's a dress under her sweater under her pink jacket with the collar-like design). she's also almost always in more soft / not necessarily muted but sometimes muted colors- the one exception being the outfit with the hot pink sweater in 2.06. i'll say she does wear somewhat more intense colors in season 1, like the red sweater she wears with the while stripe, her other red sweater/crewneck, or maybe even if we're talking her blue sweater with the yellow stripe (but i mean... it's not that bright, it's a deeper blue), but those aren't quite so bold when taken in tangent with the whole... hiding in a sweater thing, and for the red ones- the fact that it's east high colors and she's playing at being mr. popular waterpolo captain ej caswell's girlfriend... yeah. i'd be shocked if they weren't doing it on purpose. fun fact, other than in the finale, nini and ricky seem to be better with one another when she's not in red in season 1 for the most part. (i'm probably forgetting an episode or something, but i remember thinking about this a long while back).
i'll add that in episode 1, for her audition, she wears a little grey east high sweatshirt, her lucky sweatshirt, and the nervous little nini hiding in a sweatshirt compared to the girl in the red dress in the fantasy... yeah that was intentional. she's falling back where ej puts his whole self forward in the troy jersey. another thing- like yes yac is a boarding school so it makes sense they have like- uniform policies (though clearly not an actual uniform per se), look at how DARK nini's clothes are there, yac is repressive, so everything is dark and definitely a bit gloomier than the (admittedly still sorta dark, bc cinematography choices for season 2 were certainly made...) lighting at east and at slices. also though- she still has her little ribbon in her hair. she still has that little detail of something that makes her clearly nini. clearly different from all this. she doesn't fit there.
now for an example of someone who we definitely absolutely do see their mental state in their wardrobe specifically (at least the once)- ricky "i'm in pajamas at school and my parents are getting a divorce" bowen. i'm blanking on what episode (or episodes) this is- but he shows up to school in his pajamas in season 1. and he's not doing so well at the time. example number 2142 of ricky not being totally well mentally. signs of depression include not "taking care of" your appearance, i know we talk about ricky having anxiety but imo i'd add depression to the list. now we can blame this on mike's mental state as well i suppose- maybe he's not doing laundry because he's not doing well with the divorce. but i mean- ricky's old enough to do his own laundry- he for sure at least knows how.
also when they put him in that slc pride shirt from nini's moms- it's pretty big on him, it makes 6'1 joshua bassett look smaller, more fragile, when ricky, in those scenes, is definitely pretty darn fragile... like yeah- it's not his shirt, but it's a costume choice for his character.
but yeah- i think wardrobe/costume departments have a lot of things they try to keep in mind when dressing their characters. and putting a character in dark clothes to show they're in a darker state is a choice that can be made fairly often i'd say in tv/film. it's a very helpful visual for viewers, and that's the goal. the goal is to assist the other departments in conveying what they're trying to convey.
a lot of their choices will definitely be meaningful- olivia rose keegan talked about in an interview (in terms of how different it was doing this show vs. working on a soap like days of our lives), how neat it was how much attention to detail their was because of the time that they had to work on things. she recounted sitting there for like three hours on the first day just talking about what they thought would be right for lily's hair- a luxury they never ever had on days. like they spent that long on a recurring character- working out how it would make sense for lily to wear her hair this season.
this is to say- costume, makeup, hair- it all is done with intention. they care about telling a coherent story, and using a visual- like costume for example- is a great way to help tell it. anything that adds to the full picture is a part of telling that story. i'm not saying every single piece means something, but everything a character wears was picked out for a reason, even if that reason is- this feels like something character would definitely wear.
one thing i find amusing- how much the like- l'amour, love, paris, french words in general, etc. shirts occur on this show. miss jenn even wears a crewneck that says "merci" on it in the season 3 trailer haha, so i was reminded of it in that moment. i feel like maybe that imagery is coming back into style lately but- it feels like it was a thing that was in so long ago at the same time?