hippothebrave replied to your post: Tilion must have been freaked when some RANDOM...
my pet theory is that when the earth was rounded, the entire universe changed to a universe where a round earth would apply–one with the big ball of gas sun, moon made of rock, far away stars, etc
it also gives a delightfully terrible irony, in that finite beings get an infinite universe they can’t possibly explore, and infinite beings get a finite universe they can’t possibly leave :)
THAT SOUNDS LIKE A REALLY MEAN IRONY WHAT
Anyway omg this is really fun! like i mentioned i’m definitely very much in the camp of ‘it’s both at the same time’ with the whole reality is a reflection and filter/wave and particle thing as ghoul and gogol described it (also omg again guys thanks SO much for finally giving me a way to phrase it! it’s been bugging me for ages.) but this is also a very cool idea about like, how the real world as we perceive it today, if it was an explicitly different world, would look from the pov of people in a Primacy of Faerie pocket universe or w/e. though you could argue that like, there’s nothing saying endless space travel ISN’T allowed for elves....i mean, if earendil gets to....
hippothebrave replied to your post: Tilion must have been freaked when some RANDOM...
it would explain why Sam notices in Lothlorien that the moon isn’t changing phases, bc for the moon to have phases, whatever changes the universe has to have already happened, except not for elves
oh man i forgot about the moon phase thing in lothlorien -- though i thought the issue was more that they thought they hadn’t stayed a full month, not that the moon stayed still? but yeah exactly on the time passing differently there because lorien is like, in a time loop bringing along its own dimension of reality omg. then again I always assumed that the moon always DID have phases ever since it was created. though lol this also reminds me of how the hobbits seem to have a somewhat different idea about the Moon than the elves, both in thinking of the moon as a location and with the idea of the moon being a vessel and pulled by horses and driven by a person being framed as a goofy song (even if bilbo meant it), which seems also to play into a kind of ‘your mind makes it real’ ish thing, sort of. also reminds me of ‘and take the hidden paths that run/west of the moon, east of the sun’....like that’s very fictional-real-life...