I have just had my eyes opened; Iāve never really looked at Phantom with my shipping goggles on.
Please, PLEASE tell me about your rarepair otp.
(answering this a few days late, sorry!)
(in reference to my tags on this post)
haha, i'm glad to infect another person! xD now, i admit that it's been years since i read susan kay's phantom book, which is the version that does the most exploring of erik and nadir's relationship (nadir being the man referred to as 'the persian' and 'the daroga' in leroux's book), so i'm sure there's a LOT i've forgotten or that i may be misremembering.
but i think it's really interesting, as nadir is literally erik's only real friend, the only person who truly knows him and has known him for actual decades. nadir saw erik at, arguably, his worst in mazandaran, when his entire job was to creatively kill people, but he also saw erik's compassion and humanity in how erik loved nadir's son and helped to ease his passing when he was terminally ill.
then, when nadir's wife has died, he moves from persia to paris just to install himself as erik's conscience, to bitch at him about his bad choices and try to badger him into making better choices... which sounds something like a marriage to me, lmao.
i can't remember whether nadir ever saw erik without his mask - i want to say yes, but i can't recall - but he's certainly the last person alive who knows the most of erik's dark past, who's seen the worst of him, and he still cares. maybe erik is the only real friend he has too, the only person left who understands him after he lost his family.
don't get me wrong, i like erik and christine and the sweeping gothic romance of it, but i also like the idea of, in the aftermath of christine leaving, erik picking up the pieces with nadir's help and realizing that this person has been there all along, this person who sees him and genuinely cares for him. and maybe it's not grand opera arias or any other dramatic gestures, but it's real and it's steady and it's good. they're old and exhausted and deeply damaged by life, but they have each other, and personally, i think that's just as romantic.
it also doesn't hurt that i like to headcanon nadir as oded fehr (ardeth bay from the mummy). š