Speaking as part of an much older CDD system with a few members who have spiritual Kin beliefs, as a part whose been around long enough to watch the "kinning for fun" crowd successfully dismantle the Fictionkin community, I take issue with some of these new community terms. When the kin for fun kids demanded access into our community they didn't just join they literally took over, backed by ableism that dismissed our core beliefs as delusions; calling us freaks, mentally unhinged, disrespected the Neo pagan belief kin started as because to them it’s niche and small enough to disrespect. That's why I stand against "Otherpaw," "Fictionpaw," and any cutesy hobbyist version of what was once a deeply held spiritual and psychological identity.
There's nothing wrong with hobbies. Roleplaying as animals or exploring non-human experiences through costumes are absolutely fine activities. But when these hobbyists force themselves into our communities and adopt or create terms that too closely mirror our spiritual and psychological communities names, the outcome is always the same: the original demographic and definitions are lost and we get pushed out.
I’ve watched it happen with fictionkin. KFF kids successful warped the definition of kin, watered it down so badly that people think it just means "feeling connected to a character" they don’t even know that our community was started as a spiritual and psychological one. Being able to relate to character is exactly what good fiction does! That's a very normal fandom experience, not a kin identity. When the "kin for fun" crowd arrived, they declared our spiritual origins delusional, spewing ableism at anyone who disagreed. Psychological kin got the same treatment; we were all told to seek help and had been run off this very platform so now currently speaking we are minority to the KFF crowds.
As for therian and otherkin spaces? I keep my distance these days. The overlap with other communities I want nothing to do with is too much. Larping as animals and exploring non-humanity in costume is already founded as several communities larping, roleplaying, the furry fandom.
I'm all for self-exploration and identity work. But please respect that fictionkin, otherkin, therians and copelinks have genuine spiritual and psychological origins. We're often extremely vulnerable, stigmatized people with genuine real spiritual beliefs and valid coping mechanisms due to abuse of being ritualistically dehumanized . Respect our spiritual beliefs like you would any religion. Respect our psychological identities like you would mainstream diagnoses.Listen when we say our communities are being diluted and erased with ableist rhetoric. We are all not out here trying to be aggressively radical or gatekeeping. We are not all out here with intentions to squash your communities because we find them insulting for straw man reasons. If you’re younger you likely have absolutely no idea the amount of harassment, hate, witch hunts and generally normalized hatred we suffered toward our community from the hobbyist crowds who were backed up by other non kins and humans.
I'm not asking anyone to stop existing nor am I hating on hobbyists and kids having fun. I'm asking for new terms that are unmistakably separate from our communities. Taking words from spiritual or disorder-based groups and repackaging them as hobbies? It's incredibly insulting when many of the hobbyists are so incredibly ableist.
Coin your own terms so they are clearly distinguishable and cannot be mistaken for ours. Please, leave ours alone.










