Ok guys lets be fr Elwin has to be Sophie's dad
i remember vaguely that Sophie was yelling at Mr Forkle this one time about how she deserves to know who her parents are, and Elwin was there and he nodded along and said "Yeah, I agree wholeheartedly" and looked at Mr Forkle and I forget how it was worded but I remember he looked at Forkle in a way that made me go, "Oh. He's her dad."
idk its a very weak statement BUT if i reread the books im sure i'll have more arguments















