so, season 2 promos come out, yeah? everyone is excited about the pearls. oh my god, did stede give him those as an apology present? does ed get those for himself? what's the story there? and season 2 comes out, we don't actually see the story play out on screen.
and so my theory is that the pearls are like the wedding cake toppers. ed saw them during a raid and decided "this is a gift for myself. this is a way for me to express who i am, even though i feel very trapped right now in the blackbeard persona."
but i also think it's interesting to note that ed's pearls are freshwater (iirc). so something distinctly not of the ocean. and from the surface, people think "oh yeah, pearls. makes sense for a guy who wants to live on the sea to have those." until you look closer at them. and it's like, ed says that he wants to be an impossible bird and never land. but right around his neck is a sign that he does.
and also like. on a personal level, as a guy that got themself pearl necklace recently. like... it's a nice object. it makes you feel pretty and desirable. like, it's one of those wardrobe staples ppl have, like "the little black dress." people who dress femme tend to own at least one set of pearls, plastic or no. and like, allowing myself to have those was a big step.
also of note freshwater pearls (which is what i have, what i think ed has) are much cheaper than saltwater pearls. why? because they can be produced very quickly, and they usually come out misshapen. (there's actually a whole market for Weirdly Shaped pearls because of it.) and it's possible that it's more of a costuming budget thing than an deliberate choice. but i like to think that it is.
and even if it isn't, saltwater pearls are precious, pricy gemstones. ed could make a lot of money selling those if they are saltwater, but he chooses to keep them for himself.
either way, i see the pearls as a story of ed enacting agency. of saying "i want to feel pretty, i want to give myself something nice."
and honestly? that's awesome. i'm glad he didn't wait for another man to Bestow That Upon Him. because while ed absolutely deserves to be given nice things, he also deserves to be kind to himself. and what is season 2 but not about ed's journey in learning to be kind to himself, despite everything?