any chance we could get pete having the most horrendous fucking crush on the reader. just absolutely down bad and no idea what to do about it?
DownBad!Pete Dinunzio x Crush!GN!Reader
- Pete doesn’t crush. He obsesses.
- The moment he realizes he actually likes you, he short-circuited and denied it completely.
“No, I don’t like them. They’re just… not annoyin’. That’s different.”
- He gets defensive anytime someone teases him about you.
“What? No! They’re not even my type!”
- (You are his type. Exactly his type. He’s fucked.)
- He overcompensates by being even louder around you 😓
- Constant sarcasm, dumb jokes, fake insults. All a smokescreen for the fact that his heart is pounding so hard it makes him dizzy 😼
- He starts dressing better when he knows you’ll be around.
- Not good, but less crusty. The shirt has fewer stains 🤷
- When you talk to him, he tries to act chill but ends up saying something weird like:
“Yeah, that’s… that’s totally, uh… grotesque. I like that.”
- (You were talking about your cat.)
- If you mention horror movies, he latches onto the topic like it’s oxygen 😭
“Oh, you like horror? No way. Okay, name your top five. No, actually- top ten. I need’a see if you’re legit.”
- Secretly replays your conversations in his head, remembering every tiny detail 😛
- What you were wearing, what you laughed at, how you said his name. It’s embarrassing how much he remembers 🥹
- Starts showing up where you are “by coincidence.” He’ll act annoyed about it 😭
“Oh wow, you’re here too? Crazy. Guess I’ll… sit over there. Or whatever.”
- Then he plops down right next to you.
- He offers to let you borrow his horror VHS tapes, then spends an hour giving you a full history lesson on each one. If you actually borrow one, he’ll be ecstatic for days 😛
- If you compliment him (even slightly), his brain blue-screens. You could say “cool shirt,” and he’ll spend three days wondering if you meant it 😭
- Gets visibly mad when someone else flirts with you 😭
“They’re not even all that. Look at their shirt! How much you wanna bet they don’t even know five songs.”
- The jealousy doesn’t leak, no. It POURS out.
- He writes fake horror scripts in his notebook, but lately, the final survivor started looking suspiciously like you 😼
- He tells himself it’s “artistic inspiration,” but he’s fooling no one 🧍
- Pretends to be annoyed if you join his interests,
“You’re copyin’ me! ”
- While, he’s internally combusting because you watched his favorite movie :3
- The other guys in the club start to notice. And he gets INCREDIBLY defensive 😭
- When you laugh at his dumb jokes, it physically hurts him.
- He tries not to smile, but it sneaks out anyway, and he covers it with a cough or a snarky comment 😼
- Late at night, he’ll think about you and get so frustrated he throws a pillow across the room.
- He doesn’t know how to like someone without turning it into a crisis (i love him ☹️☹️)
- If you message him, he panics. Stares at the message for 10 minutes before answering something sarcastic that he immediately regrets. Then overthinks it for hours 😭
- The guys will be talking about something else entirely, and he’ll randomly bring you up.
“Yeah, [name] also watched it, said it was lame.”
- He acts like he’d hate a romantic movie, but if you suggested watching one, he’d pretend to complain the entire time while sitting closer than necessary 😭
- Pete doesn’t know how to flirt properly. His version of flirting is roasting you and then buying you a soda without explaining why 😛
The Confession (he doesn’t really confess):
- You’d known for weeks.
- The stammering, the weird avoidance, the way he’d start a sentence and then insult you halfway through for no absolute reason 😓
- It was all there.
- So when the two of you ended up at Joe’s, alone for once, while he yapped nonstop about the figurine he almost bought, you decided to just… shut him up 🤷
- You leaned forward and kissed him.
- It wasn’t long, just enough to make his rant cut off mid-word 😋
- His hands stopped moving, his mouth still half open like the sentence was still buffering.
- Eyes wide and glassy, blinking like he’d just been hit with a flashbang 😭😭
- You pulled back, waiting for the inevitable Pete reaction: yelling, flailing, a full dissertation about how you “can’t just do that!” asking if you’re “bad in the head”
- But nothing came.
- He just stared. Silent.
- Then, quietly, like he didn’t trust his own voice:
“…Do that again.”
- You blinked.
“What?”
“Just—just so I know it wasn’t, like, a… a brain glitch or something.”
- He was still frozen, still standing there, not daring to move, like he’ll die if he does.
- You laughed and leaned in again.
- This time, he kissed you back, hesitant, extremely clumsy, but real 😼
- When you pulled away, he just sat there, completely still, then muttered under his breath,
“I think I died and this is heaven..”
Here’s what would happen if he actually confessed though :3
GUYS I ACTUALLY WROTE 😨😨😨😨
I’ve been so tired and busy idk how to keep up with my writing, but I’ll do it for you guys!!
I’ll try to post more this month, but I can’t promise anything, hope you guys enjoy these 😼😼













