Aight I feel the need to weigh in on P5X: It looks bad.
Y'all have a great night now.
Okay but seriously it's a Chinese mobile game using like 90% of the original game's assets, side characters and, I'mma call it before it happens, story beats.
I thiiiiiink the original art team is back for this and while all the leaked Not-Thieves look pretty and all but their outfits and personas look like the type of shit you'd see in a shitty Chinese mobile game, so I guess they're on the right track.
Also I know that P5 is an anime and fairly adherent to a lot of tropes therein but I always thought it felt a lot more grounded. Like most of the characters looked pretty and all and sometimes had coloured hair but it usually made sense (Ryuji dyed his hair, Ann's is natural, Yusuke is an artist and hella gay etc.) but the Not-Thieves look VERY anime and it kinda makes me feel like they'll be written as such, and so far the type of people reacting positively to their designs has kinda vindicated me in that regard.
So all said: P5R is still the best Persona game, do not dispute this, and I will not be taking anything that happens in X as canon in relation to 5.