𝐏𝐔𝐍𝐈𝐒𝐇𝐌𝐄𝐍𝐓 | elijah mikaelson x reader x katherine pierce
summary: when elijah and katherine return from their trip to find you, their girlfriend, breaking the one rule they set in place, they decide a punishment is in order.
⤷ requested by anon
warnings: 18+ mdni. smut, f. masturbation (pillow riding), oral (m. receiving), degradation, mean katherine & elijah, dumbification, clit slapping, a lil tit slapping, cuckolding (?), reader is referred to as "pet", bondage, 1 instance of google translated bulgarian, er hopefully that's it
wc: 1.8k words
author's note: kalijah might be the sexiest couple alive
The chimes of the clock tower rung through Mystic Falls, indicating it was now 6:00 p.m in the evening. You shifted uncomfortably from where you laid on the bed, trying but failing to read a book. Dressed in nothing but Elijah's dress shirt, it was becoming increasingly difficult to ignore the growing ache in between your legs. Especially not when you could smell Katherine's perfume on the pillows, in the sheets.
You shifted your position, letting out a whimper when your wet heat made contact with the sheets, granting you the slightest amount of friction. You glanced at the clock on the wall. 6:05 pm. Elijah and Katherine weren't due until 7:00 pm — more than enough time to get yourself off and clean up the evidence from in between your legs.
You mulled with the idea in your head — on one hand, the pair had enforced a strict rule — you weren't allowed to touch yourself. On the other, they had left nearly a week ago, kissing you hastily as they raced off to battle the werewolves of New Orleans.
You made up your mind, dipping your fingers into your mouth, wetting them with your tongue. You began the journey down, tweaking your nipples as you unbuttoned the blue shirt, letting it droop off a shoulder. You shuddered as your fingers finally made contact with your sopping cunt, gathering up the slick from your slit before plunging inside.
You were quick to grab a pillow and straddle it, moving your hips in slow rolls. Your head fell back, a moan echoing through the room. You picked up your pace, rutting faster and faster. Your orgasm was building fast, bolts of electricity hitting the tips of your fingers. If you weren't so caught up in your own pleasure, you would've heard the surefire sound of the front door opening. Or Katherine's boots rhythmically tapping down the hallway. Or the low hint of Elijah's voice as the doorknob squeaked open.
"Well, well, well." drawled out Elijah. "What do we have here?"
Your movements stilled completely as you squeaked, throwing the pillow to the side, clamping your legs together. But the damage was done, and you looked up to see two, very pissed of vampires.
"I-I thought you were coming at seven!" you stuttered out.
"That much is obvious," said Katherine coldly. "Otherwise you wouldn't have been caught like a bitch in heat."
Elijah's eyes were raking over your body as he adjusted his tie. "We decided to make haste. Figured we had left you alone, aching and wanting for far too long."
"Imagine our surprise," continued Katherine. "To see you grinding down on a pillow. Fucking slut."
You tried to protest, but Elijah stopped you. "I hope you aren't calling us liars."
Katherine walked forward, reaching into the bedside drawer as she pulled out silk ties. Your eyes widened, realizing what was in store for you. "No — Katherine!"
"If you want to act like a whore, you'll get treated like one too. Now, shut up."
Her and Elijah made quick work of you, tying your hands and legs to each bedpost, spreading you out wide, and rendering you immobile. You turned your face to Elijah, looking up at him through your eyelashes with your best doe eyes. "Please, 'lijah, m'sorry!"
He shoved two fingers into your mouth without warning. "Thought she told you to keep your mouth shut? Another peep out of you and I'll shove my cock into your mouth and fuck your throat for hours. Understood?"
"She'd like that," chuckled Katherine, trailing a finger down your body. You were reactive as always, twitching, goosebumps rising as she circled your breasts. "Stupid brat just wants us to use her, isn't that right?"
A choked groan erupted from you when Katherine, without warning, plunged two fingers into your soaking cunt. She pulled them out, licking one clean.
"How does our little slut taste?" asked Elijah, pants considerably tighter.
"Like sin itself."
Elijah wrapped his mouth around Katherine's other finger, not failing to notice how desperate you looked. "This is your punishment, y/n. You're going to watch us. Watch me pound into Katherine's tight little pussy, watch Katherine gag on my cock, watch us cum over and over before you even think about touching yourself again."
Katherine captured Elijah's lips in a passionate kiss, their tongues battling as she lifted her hands to slip off his suit jacket. Without breaking apart, they unbuttoned each others tops. You could've drooled as you saw what Katherine was wearing underneath — a lacy lingerie set, accentuating her slender body.
"Velikolepno, Katerina." murmured Elijah, slipping into Bulgarian as he took his place behind her. He started kissing down her neck, nipping and sucking as his large hands came up to cup her tits. As he tweaked and rolled her nipples, Katherine never broke eye contact with you, winking as her perfectly painted lips parted in a breathy moan.
You swallowed hard, struggling against your bonds uselessly. Elijah's hand slipped passed the gusset of Katherine's panties, his voice husky. "She's soaked. Fucking dripping. Who is this for, Katerina?"
Katherine's breathing was significantly shallower and Elijah's fingers plunged in and out of her. "For her. Was imagining all the ways we could take her. Bend her over my lap, vibrator to her cunt, your cock inside her."
Elijah shook his head in disappointment at you. "Shouldn't have broken the rules, pet."
They switched spots suddenly, Katherine dropping to her knees in front of Elijah, palming at him through his dress pants. He unbuckled his belt painstakingly slow, but the minute it was done, Katherine reached into his pants and pulled out his cock.
You practically drooled at the sight, watching as pre-cum oozed out, onto Katherine's waiting tongue. She made a great show of swallowing it. "Delicious, as always." She kitten-licked Elijah's slit, then a long stripe up the vein running on the underside.
"Don't tease, minx." grunted Elijah, holding onto the bed for support.
"Only putting on a show for our whore." said Katherine gleefully. "Bet you'd love to be in my spot, isn't that right, y/n? Sucking Elijah's fat cock, feeling him sit heavy on your tongue? A cockwhore through and through."
Your hips bucked into the air as Elijah pushed his member into Katherine's mouth. She slurped it with expert precision, hollowing her cheeks as she looked up at him — he always did appreciate eye contact. Before Elijah could come, he pulled out and bent Katherine over the bed in one movement. He kicked apart her legs, pulled her panties to the side and speared her.
Katherine moaned loudly, her voice starting to slur. "Feels s'good, fucking love your cock, 'lijah."
He grabbed her by the curls, forcing her to look face to face with your soaking cunt. You whimpered; Katherine was close enough to you that you could feel her hot pants on your pussy, causing you to clench around nothing. She seemed satisfied as her eyes rolled to the back of her head. "She's soaked, Elijah, dripping and making a mess all over the sheets."
Elijah was pistoning in and out of Katherine at a brutal pace. "She's such a stupid slut. Mindless really, her brain's always clouded by us." He snaked a hand down, drawing tight circles on Katherine's clit. "You're squeezing me so tight, Katerina, your perfect little pussy's sucking me in."
"Gonna come," said Katherine. "Want to feel you fill me up, want to feel your hot sticky cum all over my pink pussy."
Elijah came with a roar as Katherine clamped down on him, thrusting slowly as they worked through their highs together. You had tears streaming down your face, left entirely untouched and unpleasured.
"Aw, poor baby," cooed Katherine, her eyebrows furrowed. "Is someone feeling a little left out? A little needy?"
You nodded eagerly. Elijah's hand came down onto your clit with a resounding slap, and you humped the air, aching for more stimulation. Katherine did the same to your tits, squeezing and slapping them until they were red and utterly abused.
"Please," you whined. "Please, I need more."
Elijah and Katherine exchanged a quick look, a silent agreement passing between them as they undid your ties. They took their places at the head of the bed, lazily leaning back as you looked at them with wide eyes, legs tucked underneath you.
"You want to cum?" asked Elijah. "Beg. Beg like the useless little whore you are, and maybe we'll consider it."
"Please let me cum," you pleaded. "It hurts, hurts so bad."
"You call that begging?" scoffed Katherine. Her leg came up, heels still on, resting on your forehead. "Sounded more like a request."
"I'll do whatever you want." you said desperately. "I'll ride your fingers — your thighs — your shoes — anything!"
"Our shoes?" asked Elijah amusedly. "You really are a greedy harlot. Here's the deal. You make us both come with your mouth, and we'll reward you."
You didn't waste a single second as you lunged forward. Elijah held your hands behind your back. "Mouth only."
You took him into your mouth at once, gagging loudly but not letting up. Katherine's hand came to cradle the back of your neck, guiding you up and down. She pushed you down suddenly, forcing you to breathe through your nose as Elijah's coarse happy trail tickled you. He groaned. "Juuust like that. This is what you were made for, isn't it?"
You pulled off him with a pop, eyes glazed over. "Yes sir, made for sucking your cock, made for you two to use me whenever you want."
"Is that so?" asked Katherine, a wicked glint in her eye. She pulled you by the hair, all but pushing your face in between her legs. "Lick."
You ate her out like a woman starved, alternating between broad strokes up her slit and smaller shapes on her clit. Your tongue moved in and out at a rapid pace, lapping up at her juices. She was already sensitive from her previous orgasm, and it wasn't long before she came.
When Elijah pulled you back to him, slapping your face with his cock, you moaned shamelessly. Elijah was all but thrusting into your mouth, and your tongue lolled out, letting him use your mouth as a fleshlight. He pulled out suddenly, eyes dark as he held you by your throat. He was jerking off now, and you watched in amazement ropes of white spurted out, painting your face.
"Beautiful," he exhaled. "Our beautiful, beautiful slut."
Katherine hauled you forward as your thighs bracketed hers, finally rewarding you with sweet kiss, rubbing Elijah's release into your face. "Learned your lesson?"
Elijah chortled as you nodded. "Good. Because now it's your turn."
