NOSTALGIA, MY MUSE: American Football - American Football
“You can’t miss what you forget.” What a concept.
The foursome from Urbana, Illinois who make up American Football vibrantly outshine their emo contemporaries by curating relatively spirited melodies instead of simply, and softly, contemplating their desolation. That’s not to say they’re not the best band to confide in when facing moments of despair. It takes the first forty-five seconds of album opener “Never Meant” to realize this. Even those who haven’t listened to much of the ‘90s emo, punk scene, it’s easy to detect a certain refinement and accessibility from American Football. The guitars effortlessly drift and find a way to gleam through all of the dreariness about which Mike Kinsella is singing.
There is a consistent contradiction occurring between the melody and the lyrical content in the lone self-titled release. Despite the majority of the tracks being played in a major key, the mournful dwelling that occurs makes the listener believe that what they’re hearing is not in celebration of a joyous occasion. This becomes most evident in “But The Regrets are Killing Me”: “Standing alone again / Distant and dissatisfied / These four years / And how we say goodbye to these four years / A long goodbye with mixed emotions / Just fragments of another life / I’m not dead yet / But the regrets are killing me.” These overly-dramatic phrases are backed by a minimalistic and repetitive riff that could easily be made into an uplifting number, but chooses to be more solemn.
The music video for “Never Meant” gives us an opportunity to see what brings about KInsella’s inspiration as a lyricist. Like most emo and slowcore bands of this time, nostalgia lies at the heart of it. The story follows the very predictable romantic relationship of a young couple. While the familiarity of the lyrics lends itself to many 20-somethings, it is the instrumental riffs that are the most emotive in the track, forcing even those who don’t admit to liking “guitar music” want to learn the instrument.
Shortly after the album opener, there is “Honestly” - the track you’ll be thinking about the night after listening through American Football. It’s the six-minute scorcher that’s almost entirely instrumental after two opening verses that reminisce about “teenage feelings and their meanings.” Supporting the lyrics is a twinkling guitar that is comparable to the two tracks that come before it. However, just before the two-minute marker, a power chord comes bursting through the guitar, shatters the melody, and takes on a life of it’s own through a monotonous journey that is interrupted by surprising shifts of the rise and fall.
“I’ll See You When We’re Both Not So Emotional” and eight-minute “Stay Home” is the essential pairing. It begins with an almost passive aggressive rant about human issues and transitioning to a state of contentment. American Football influenced more with the release of one album than other bands do with their entire discographies. They’re realists who see things for what they are, but still manage to help others ameliorate.
-Katie Cheyne














