Last summer I voted for Andy Burnham over Jeremy Corbyn, largely due to how opposed the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) were to Corbyn. My belief and that of others was that many MPs would undermine his leadership at any opportunity and given the chance would attempt to remove him completely, this belief turned out to be sadly true.
Despite the candidate I voted for coming second, I had no trouble supporting Jeremy Corbyn as leader of my party, a step many Labour MPs could not so easily take. With 59% of the first preference votes alone in an election with four candidates, he had and still has an overwhelming mandate from members and supporters. In the 9 months since he was elected, Corbyn has had a successful leadership (despite being undermined by MPs in his own party at every turn) with numerous Conservative U-turns, increased Labour Party membership and every by-election has been won.
However, this hasn’t stopped MPs who disagree with his politics from attempting to remove him as leader. The resignations from Corbyn’s Shadow Cabinet were clearly organised with approximately one every hour (with the exception of a football match) starting with Shadow Secretaries of State and ending with shadow junior ministers and PPSs. It is not just Blairites who are to blame for this coup, but also those at the centre of the PLP. Jeremy Corbyn’s Shadow Cabinet had been dominated by MPs who had supported Andy Burnham. Other than a few positions (e.g. Shadow Chancellor was and still is held by Jeremy Corbyn’s close friend and strong supporter John McDonnell) the top positions were not held by Corbyn supporters. MPs who had supported Corbyn were generally less experienced as frontbench spokespeople and/or MPs (e.g. Clive Lewis and Cat Smith) and so were given more junior positions. Not giving all of the top positions to his parliamentary supporters was also an attempt to unite the PLP against one of the most right wing Conservative Governments in history. However, for many Labour MPs, anything less than Corbyn’s resignation was too little.
The Shadow Cabinet resignations and the following vote of no confidence are evidence of how little respect those MPs have for the 59% who voted for Jeremy Corbyn and therefore democracy in the Labour Party. It is a kick in the teeth to the 251,417 people who voted for him.
I have been hugely disappointed in the actions of some Labour MPs but not surprised by others. My own local MP, who I have canvassed for, volunteered on street surgeries for and delivered thousands of local Labour Party newspapers for, also resigned as a shadow junior minister. Tom Watson who I supported for deputy leader and phone canvassed for has also put pressure on Jeremy Corbyn to resign. Watson only received 39% of the first preference votes while Corbyn received 59%, Corbyn has a much larger mandate than his deputy. Tom Watson has been a huge disappointment over recent weeks.
The one MP in particular who I have been pleasantly surprised by is Andy Burnham. Despite most of his supporters resigning and his own political disagreements with Corbyn, especially over foreign and defence policy, he stayed and put out a supportive statement. I can now declare that I am not ashamed in any way to say I voted for Andy Burnham, unfortunately the opposite is true with Tom Watson.
The one good outcome of the coup is the current Shadow Cabinet. Emily Thornberry as Shadow Foreign Secretary, Clive Lewis (a former soldier) as Shadow Defence Secretary, Andy McDonald as Shadow Transport Secretary, Kate Osamor as Shadow Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Dave Anderson as Shadow Secretary of State for Scotland, Richard Burgon as Shadow Justice Secretary, Cat Smith as Shadow Minister for voter engagement and youth affairs, Graham Morris as Shadow Communities Secretary, Paul Flynn as Shadow Welsh Secretary and Debbie Abrahams as Shadow Work and Pensions Secretary are all huge improvements. The new Shadow Cabinet will be far more supportive of Jeremy Corbyn and are also far more diverse with different backgrounds and regions represented – it looks much more like the voter base of the Labour Party.
If there is to be another leadership contest, Jeremy Corbyn now has a stronger and more supportive team around him. Whether a leadership contest is against Angela Eagle (who only came fourth in the deputy leadership contest 9 months ago), Owen Smith or any other potential candidate, I would be surprised if Jeremy Corbyn did not win again. The point of the coup was not to force a leadership contest but to bully and force a resignation, that has failed.
If there is another leadership election, Jeremy Corbyn will have my vote.