klyaksa1 replied to your post “kylostahp: like idk call me crazy or whatever but something about...”
OTOH, Bodhi is transporting remains of the Holy Temple of the religion that his people followed. The closest analogy that I can come up with is a Jew being contracted to transport shredded Torah scrolls. So the guilt he feels may well be far greater then it should be based on his actions alone. And as for sending him to Saw - Galen trusted Saw enough to send his child to him, why wouldn't he trust him with Bodhi's information?
I can see in-narrative justification for it, sure, and how the nature of his job would eat at Bodhi. But to say that collaborating for survival is the same whether you’re driving the supply truck or designing the superweapon is overlooking a fuckload of power differential.
And it’s still got this uncomfortable superstructure over it-- and partly it’s the whole movie, where the only way we could get all these great characters of color in the main Star Wars universe was to have them die to further the plot, PLUS how they couldn’t have their own motivations, we had to paste on a white girl and her poppa just so there’d be something people could have emotions about, because these dudes of color aren’t sympathetic-- that’s definitely a factor.
But it does come down to an older, more powerful white dude using a younger, vulnerable, powerless person of color to enable him to assuage his own guilt. And sure, Erso didn’t send Bodhi directly to his death, but you can’t tell me the Rebellion’s survival rates were very good. And he had to know how paranoid Saw was, how not-eager Rook’s reception was likely to be, and from Rook’s reactions, he clearly did not pass any hint of this along. Bodhi expected they’d listen to him instead of torturing him, and was entirely wrong. Maybe Saw’s gotten crazier as the years have gone by and Erso doesn’t know that, but there’s no way Erso didn’t at least suspect that it might go down like that. Rook was completely unprepared.
(It’s just about the only data we have about their interactions, so it’s significant.)
I’m not saying you can’t explore this in healthy ways, and I’ve already read a few pretty great fics where the Galen/Bodhi relationship is explored in various ways-- most of them sort of desperately sad, but ultimately coming from a place of good intentions. It can be told as a beautiful story, or at least a bittersweet one. You can totally read Galen Erso’s resistance as poignant and effective, and all that. (Clearly, the creators mean for you to.)
(I’m trying to provide links, but AO3 is down for me, so I can’t access my history. Ugh.)
I’m just saying, @kylostahp is totally justified in hungering for a story that explores just how badwrong that dynamic absolutely could have been. And I haven’t seen any, yet.
This goes back, sort of, to the ever-present Discourse about villains-- on a fundamental level, sometimes the most interesting thing you can get about examining a source work is looking at who they tell you to root for, and thinking about why maybe there’s more to it than that. It’s not like anybody’s seriously saying “planet-killing genocidal maniacs are the real heroes”, because for fuck’s sake, but there’s a healthy element of “you’re telling me this person’s a hero but not showing me, and in my experience there are an awful lot of people who are on the right side but aren’t actually good people.”
(If you’ve never been involved in a well-intentioned movement that was brutally hamstrung by some deeply toxic people who plausibly thought they meant well but in practice were fucking disastertrash and sometimes actually evil, then you are extremely fortunate.)
I tend not to write the stories like that, but I do believe deep in my heart that a large part of the beauty of transformative works is to refuse to hear the story that the creator wants you to, and instead look at the story the creator is actually telling.
(That’s not how my brain works, which is why I tend not to write those stories-- I don’t pick up on that stuff on my own-- but those are the stories I think are really important to tell, sometimes.)