hi! how do you see the issue with and the communication around the "violent settlers?" our country under the new government joined and made possible the eu sanctions (BRUSSELS, May 11 (Reuters) - European Union foreign ministers reached an agreement on Monday on new sanctions targeting violent Israeli settlers in the occupied West Bank, as well as leading Hamas figures...). the sources and commentary I find range across the full spectrum and I'm looking for some help to navigate this. thanks!
Some things I can puzzle out from 6,000 miles away with enough confidence that I can make some sense of it for an international audience in a way that doesn't seem to aggravate Israelis.
This isn't one of those things.
There's a terrible dearth of credible reporting on the topic in English and what little may exist is camouflaged by an extraordinary amount of propaganda.
So what can a sane anglophone do...but turn to Haviv Rettig Gur?
I don't think Haviv is perfect, but he's knowledgeable, smart, and has an incredible track record of intellectual honesty.
If he gets something wrong, he owns it immediately. He acknowledges areas of ignorance and defers to those with greater expertise without his ego getting in the way. He's a champion of nuance, he rails against those who dehumanize others, and he never hesitates to criticize the Israeli government.
So I find Haviv highly credible and I pay attention when he shares thoughts on complex topics.
Here's Haviv's own edit on this topic from recent interview. I've attempted to transcribe and added some links to the transcript.
Haviv: It's escalating. It's growing. It's part of a kind of lawlessness and incompetence that this government has produced.
We have a minister of police in Israel who is the most far-right political party you can be. I mean...there's no humans to the right of him in Israeli politics - this is [Itamar] Ben-Gvir.
...Crime is rising across the board. It's rising in Jewish communities. It's rising in Arab communities. It's rising everywhere.
And so we have a government that...they're not running the country...and specifically in a tiny sliver of the entire settlement movement, its most ideologically fervent 20% has a marginalized, ideologically extreme 1%...that has turned violent.
And not only is the army struggling to crack down - the political class, namely Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich, are doing everything possible to prevent any kind of crackdown on that violence.
Let me just say first of all as a caveat: not all the violence claimed to be Israeli extremist violence is actually Israeli extremist violence. We we're all operating in this fog of propaganda. And when you normalize all of that out...you're still left with a serious and rising extremist violence problem that you cannot pretend isn't there because it's there and they're not cracking down on it because I think there's this vision with Ben-Gvir and Smotrich.
...Ben-Gvir and Smotrich in this government have have enough votes to be able to topple Netanyahu if he doesn't do their bidding and he's given them free reign because he's off dealing with Iran.
And what they [Ben-Gvir, Smotrich, this 1% of the 20%]...are trying to do is pressure the very small numbers of Palestinians in the part of the West Bank controlled totally by Israel [Part C] to as much as possible move to parts controlled by ostensibly on paper at least by the PA [Parts A and B] and to expand Israeli control of certain areas that will prevent any possibility in the future of any kind of Palestinian state in those areas.
I think this is a terrible idea.
HOST: Does Ben Gavir tacitly support this happening?
HOST: And so what do we do with that?...will there be an adequate response so long as he is the commissioner of police?
Haviv: No, there won't be - he'll make sure of it and we will pay a price. We will deserve to pay a price when we screw up this badly.
HOST: The thing that I keep coming back to is...how do they not care about the international world's perception of them? It further isolates the country which could be a problem for future generations...
Haviv: My entire adult life I have had to listen to the Arab world tell me they want me dead...
...and it is difficult for an ordinary person, no matter how how much they try to be decent and open-minded and try to understand all these voices from where they come from and where they're going and where the potential is to make peace and move forward in a new path...
...it's awfully hard to listen to a lifetime of genocidal rhetoric against us and not think that they should all just go fuck themselves.
And that is the ordinary Israeli.
And so reigning in Ben-Gvir is an absolute necessity and it's terribly damaging to the country.
And Netanyahu is willing to pay that cost...is willing to have the country pay that cost for his own stability.
The whole interview is available here: