Summary: when Eddie needs a place to live and so Steve let’s him crash at his apartment. But Eddie comes to find out that Steve has a girlfriend, no one had known about. And Eddie is just about to get a glimpse of how much he wishes he was Steve… or you he doesn’t really- (6.7k)
WARNINGS: Clinginess, size kink(not really), very shy y/n(at first), social anxiety mentions, fighting, angst (kinda?), hurt/comfort, fingering, squirting, vanilla!Steve, Vanilla!Reader (until Eddie changes her mind), dacryphilia, pet names(?) (sweet girl, sweetheart, baby, etc), Eddie says ‘little’ to reader a lot but it doesn’t mean anything it’s just something i think fits his character, this might be bad so sorry in advance. I ended up really not liking this… :( (the pictures shown are not meant to be what the reader (or Eddie and Steve) looks like, just the vibe of the story!!)
PAIRING: Steve Harrington x SHY!FemReader x Eddie Munson
part two
Eddie was glad he was able to crash at Steve’s, rather than living in Wayne’s trailer. Don’t get him wrong, he loved his dear uncle but sometimes Eddie wanted his own space. Even if he doesn’t necessarily have his own space with Steve, at least it’s someone his age.
But what he was not expecting was when your little figure walked right out of Steve’s room, in only a t-shirt. You yawned rubbing your eyes before you took notice of Eddie’s presence, which was him sitting at the kitchen island eating cereal.
You stopped in your tracks, staring at him with wide eyes, before you ran off back to Steve’s room. Eddie stared at the closed door for a minute, before he got up to get the phone.
‘Hello, this is-“
‘Why didn’t you tell me about the girl.’ Eddie demanded, cutting Steve off.
‘Oh. um y/n you mean?’ he asked, Eddie let out a frustrated sigh.
‘Well fucking hell Steve, i didn’t even get to know her name she walked out here, mind you in only a t-shirt and once she noticed me she scurried on back to your room.’ Eddie said, Steve almost laughed but kept his composure.
‘She’s just a shy girl, i told her that i was having someone live in the apartment for a while. As for you i’m sorry i didn’t tell you, no one else really knows about her’ Steve says, Eddie furrows his brows.
‘Is she your girlfriend?’ Eddie asks confusion deep in his voice. Steve sighs, leaning against the counter.
‘yeah, but she’s shy so- she didn’t really want anyone to know’ Steve explains, Eddie hums.
‘Well she looked terrified of me.’
‘Everyone is terrified of you Ed’s look in the mirror man’ Steve laughed, Eddie grumbled saying his goodbyes before hanging up.
Eddie took his seat back on the stool, finishing his now soggy cereal.
-
You hadn’t come out at all that day, that is until you heard the jingles of Steve’s keys and then the front door opening. You sit up, getting out of the bed. You open the door peeking out of it, seeing Steve close the door behind him and putting his keys on the kitchen counter.
He spots you and you smile sweetly, he walks over to you walking into the room. Eddie had been watching the whole thing from the couch.
-
‘Have you even eaten today sweet girl?’ he asked, a little frustrated that you let your social anxiety take over.
‘Um… no. I got scared!’ you whine, he lets out a sigh shaking his head.
‘Eddie is no one you should be scared of’ he explains getting out of his work clothes, changing into a pair of sweats and a t-shirt.
‘You sure’ you whisper, he nods walking over to you and giving you a kiss to the forehead.
‘Come on, you gotta at least be civil to him and say hi.’ Steve says giving you a pair of his boxers, you pout but put them on anyways.
You walk behind Steve as he opens the door, staying behind him. You can sense the presence of another human, and you don’t like it.
‘Say hi’ Steve says, to which you then make yourself visible to the other one whispering a small hi as you look down at your feet.
‘Hi there, would have introduced myself this morning if you hadn’t run off.’ Eddie jokes making you relax a little at his soft laugh.
‘Sorry, i’m y/n’ you whisper, taking a chance at looking at the other man.
‘No worries, i’m Eddie’ he said smiling, his heart absolutely melted at your soft aura.
‘Nice to meet you’ you say avoiding eye contact. Eddie grins looking over at Steve mouthing ‘real shy huh?’ Steve just grins back nodding.
‘Nice to meet you too’ Eddie laughs slightly, you burn up taking note that there is another person staring at you other than Steve.
You make thin line with your lips humming a small ‘mhm’, walking back into Steve’s room. Eddie watched as you shut the door, and he just laughed.
‘Well god dammit Steven, you didn’t tell me she was that shy.’ Eddie said in amusement, Steve rolled his eyes at the name.
‘i told you, she’s just very antisocial she’ll warm up to you’ Steve explained walking to the kitchen to make you something to eat.
-
The next morning wasn’t so bad, you had not been scared to walk out of Steve’s room to make something to eat. But you still avoided eye contact with Eddie.
He talked to you and you would talk back, and you surprisingly found the company comforting. Steve had work what felt like all the time, so you’d be at his apartment alone. Having someone to talk to gave you a sort of comfort.
‘When did you two start dating?’ Eddie asked as you placed your food on a plate.
‘um… about 5months ago’ you whispered, Eddie hums.
‘Yeah, no one knows. I don’t like people that much’ you mumble, Eddie chuckles making you almost loose your breath. It’s a sound that Steve makes sometimes, and it makes your stomach flutter.
Eddie had tried to engage in you, per Steve’s request.
‘just try and talk to her please, she just needs an extra push’
‘you’d make good friends with El, she’s a quiet little thing like you’ Eddie says and for some reason you blushed.
‘Yeah that’s what Stevie tells me’ You hadn’t even realized you let the name you call him slip, if Eddie had noticed he had no point in showing it.
You place your plate down next to Eddie and happily eat.
-
As the days went on you began to be more comfortable around Eddie.
Eddie had explained he was leaving to go visit his uncle, and Steve took that chance. He knew you were dying on the inside, because he had told you that you had to hold off on the sex for a while. You guys already didn’t have much sex, so you were going on about 3 weeks without sex.
So when he got you on the couch, kissing down your pretty neck you relished in it.
You were sex deprived?
So when Steve was taking things slow you practically cried. Pouting at him, saying how you’ve been good and waited.
‘Yes, and i’m so proud of you baby’ he replied.
Steve was the soft type, surprisingly.
-
You were so close, pleading him. So far down into your own mind that you hadn’t heard the front door. Quite frankly neither did Steve, and when Eddie walked in he got a glimpse of just what he wanted.
‘Steve!’ it was a cry out from you that had Eddie freezing in his spot. He stared for a good minute, watching the way Steve’s face contorted with pleasure.
He grew hard in his pants, before either of you could see him he walked back out. Rushing to his van.
He slammed the door, sitting in his seat. Running his hands through his hair. It was running through his mind.
You laying there, all needy and submissive to Steve as he helped you- god.
‘FUCK!’ Eddie hit his wheel, he’s fucked. He leaned down to the wheel thinking for a moment.
He started his van driving off.
-
‘And i just stood there Robin.’ Eddie said, Robin sighed as she listened to him.
‘Who were you attracted to?’ she asked suddenly, Eddie paused looking at her.
‘I- her obviously i mean-‘ he stopped himself when Robin gave him a look.
‘Why are you looking at me like that.’ he stated, she sat down next to him.
‘because i don’t believe you.’ she said, Eddie raised an eyebrow.
‘Wha-‘
‘You walked in on Steve having sex with some one, and you watched. What if it was Jonathan? Do you think he would stand there and watch Steve fuck someone?’ She asked, Eddie froze.
‘Who were you attracted to Eddie.’ she asked again, Eddie swallowed thickly leaning back into the couch.
‘Both of them.’ he said.
-
Later that night you were nearly asleep when you heard the sound of keys, and the door opening. You felt Steve pull out of the bed and opening the bedroom door. Then there was faint talking, your bedroom door making it muffled.
‘Where were you?’ Steve asked, Eddie just gave a raised eyebrow.
‘my uncles. i told you-‘
‘yeah you told me you’d be back by 10’ Steve cut him off, Eddie gave a confused look.
‘I’m sorry? i didn’t know i was on a curfew’ Steve rolled his eyes.
‘I’m just saying you could have called to say you were staying later or something.’ Steve said, Eddie has been through too much and now Steve is showing that stupid motherly friend side of him and it’s not helping.
‘Ok sorry’ he mumbled walking to the kitchen to get water, he went over it with Robin. How to tell Steve, but he just couldn’t bring himself to do it.
‘You scared y/n you know’ Steve mumbled, Eddie froze at this. He shut the door, water bottle in hand.
‘Well- i- sorry i didn’t mean to’ he said walking off to the couch.
You were sitting at the door listening to them.
‘Why are you acting like that?’ Steve says, Eddie stops and looks back at him.
‘like what?’ Eddie asks, Steve just stares at him a moment longer.
‘i don’t know- weird’ Steve asks, Eddie lets out a bitter laugh that makes your stomach drop.
‘i thought i was already weird’ Eddie says, Steve just rolls his eyes.
‘Okay whatever, i’m not gonna try talking to you if you’re acting like that’ Steve says, Eddie ignores him.
You hear Steve’s footsteps and you jump up from the floor backing away. He walks in and notices you frantic look.
‘Were you listening?’ he asks, you nod shyly.
‘Sorry, i don’t know what’s up with him’ Steve mumbles, he just kinda stands there.
‘Maybe he just- needs to sleep, we all need sleep sometimes’ you mumble, Steve gives you a small smile kissing you on the forehead.
‘yeah’ he whispered.
-
It got harder and harder for Eddie to keep his composure around you. To you he was more sweet but to Steve… he just plain out ignored him.
It irritated Steve enormously. He hadn’t figured out why Eddie had been so different around him, it’s almost like he was scared of Steve.
One day you had been asleep in Steve’s room when Eddie walked in. Steve writing something down about rent. When he saw Eddie he got up, moving towards him.
‘Ok ed’s, what is your deal?’ Steve asked in a hushed tone, trying not to wake you up.
‘What do you mean?’ Eddie asked confused.
‘You know what i fucking mean. You’ve been avoiding me like the plague!’ Steve says.
It tipped Steve off, Eddie was his- friend. Eddie was his friend who wasn’t paying attention to him.
‘I- i’ve just been busy’ Eddie says, Steve doesn’t buy it, not one fucking bit.
‘Yeah fucking right! Y/n said you’ve been perfectly normal to her?!’ Eddie freezes at that.
‘Listen it’s just- complicated…’ Eddie tried to reason but Steve is not pleased.
‘GEEZ EDS LET ME HELP YOU OR SOMETHING?! YOU’RE AVOIDING ME AND ITS DRIVING ME UP THE WALL!’ Steve hadn’t meant to shout, but it was hard not to when he felt like what he did.
‘Where’s y/n?’ Eddie asked looking around, Steve just stared at him.
‘She’s sleeping.’ he said blankly.
‘Do you like my girlfriend?’ he accused, Eddie looked stunned.
Steve had thought about it a few times, scared it was true.
‘What? where- where is this coming from.’ Eddie protested.
‘DO YOU LIKE MY GIRLFRIEND?’ Steve shouted again, Eddie was pulled back.
‘I- Steve listen…’
Steve hated this feeling. He was infuriated. But it wasn’t because Eddie liked his girlfriend, it was because Eddie he didn’t like him. His eyes burned and he hadn’t realized tears had grown.
Steve’s head went into a spiral, had he liked Eddie? No. He liked his girlfriend, god he loved her.
‘I walked in on you guys the other day when i said i was going to Wayne’s- i came back a little early i didn’t think- i hadn’t thought and i walked in on you two on the couch-‘ Eddie slowly explained, Steve just stood there in shock.
‘I just… um my mind went a little crazy and i just froze. I ran off to Robins and i told her about it, she kept on asking me who i was attracted to- and i- i just couldn’t set my mind um,’ Eddie didn’t know how to say it.
‘You like both of us.’ Steve said, breathing uneven. Eddie’s head snapped up in alarm.
They both stayed silent, scared to be the first one to talk. Eddie swallowed thickly, Trying to gather his thoughts.
‘Yeah’ he mumbled, his hands went wet.
There was nothing else to say, they both felt frozen.
Eddie knew deep down that he never really cared who he ended up with. But Steve had grown up with entitled parents who thought they were better than everyone else.
He remembers a night where his mother complained about her cousin, who had ran off and dated a boy.
‘He’s disgusting’
He remembered the dis-taste in her voice, the venom. When he met Robin he immediately felt a pang in his heart, Robin was just being herself, she wasn’t disgusting.
Steve always tried his best to please his mom, his father never really gave him the time of day. So if he were able to please his mom then he felt like he had it all. The feeling of pleasing his mom was like winning the Nobel Prize.
But he realized that not everyone wins the Nobel Prize. And not everyone can achieve that, and that’s okay. Because in the end of the day we are all just humans trying to live, so why does it matter that he likes Eddie?
Why does his mom think he’s anything less than herself, why does she think Robin doesn’t deserve to be loved. That’s how he knew that he never really needed to please his mom, he shouldn’t have even tried. Because she was the one that was less than a human, she was the one going against someone who was just trying to love.
‘Idotoo’ Steve hadn’t realized it slipped until Eddie looked up at him in shock.
His feet looked quite interesting in the moment, but they had been blurred by the stupid water in his eyes.
‘What?’ Eddie asked, unsure he heard correctly.
‘I do too, um… you and y/n’ he mumbled looking back up at Eddie, tear streaked cheeks. Eddie just stared in shock, why was he crying?
‘Is that- is that even allowed’ Steve says letting out a nervous huff.
‘Robin said it was’ Eddie shrugged, and Steve actually felt like he could smile. He felt okay, he supposed in the moment.
‘Yeah Robin thinks it’s okay to put ketchup on eggs.’ Steve states softly, rubbing his nose and sniffing.
‘Yeah so we should trust her eh?’ Eddie says, Steve rolls his eyes.
‘You too?’ he asks in disbelief, Eddie shrugs.
‘Sorry man’
Steve hadn’t realized Eddie got any closer until he felt arms wrap around him. He stood frozen for a little until he finally let himself be himself, wrapping his arms around Eddie letting out small sobs.
He just felt okay, like he could destroy the world and bring all back together. He felt like he could actually breath.
He laid out everything to Eddie, about his mother, his father and how for so long he felt like a disappointment. But now he really didn’t care, because people like his parents can never truly be pleased.
And they thought that now they feel content in their feelings, why not make it fun?
Mess with you
-
It was the next morning Steve was already off to work, you began to walk out to the kitchen when you stopped in your tracks, Eddie was on the couch. With only boxers on.
You just stared, why? why was he so confidently spread out in the open in ONLY his boxers?!?
You just ignored it walking into the kitchen beginning to make your breakfast.
-
Eddie had been more touchy, not to the point where it made you uncomfortable but just to the point where is made you blush and want to cower.
But something that really made you blush was when he called you sweet girl, it was something you’ve only ever been called by Steve.
But it felt wrong, blushing around him. It felt so wrong, but you couldn’t help it.
-
Steve came home, dropping his keys on the counter before coming to his room.
You looked up from reading your book, he waved the movie he had in hand grinning like the cat who’s got the milk.
You sit straight up, movie nights were your favorite. And since Steve worked at family video it happened quite often, he always got discounts on new movies they got in stock.
‘What movie is it!?’ you sprint from the bed, book long forgotten. He brings down the case to show you.
‘Raising Arizona?’ you question grabbing it and looking at it. Steve shrugged, getting out of his work clothes and into new ones.
He urges you out the door, you yelp turn towards him.
‘Idontgotanypantson’ you mumble, Steve looks down at you with a questioned look.
‘Sorry baby, what?’ he leaned down to hear you, he genuinely seemed like he didn’t hear you but you never knew with Steve.
‘i don’t have any pants on Steve.’ you state, trying to make it to where Eddie couldn’t hear. Steve just grins, perfect.
‘That’s alright,’ he says
‘wait what-‘
‘Hey Eddie!’ Steve calls out to Eddie who’s laying on the couch, to which Eddie looks up from the paper he was drawing on.
You go wide eyed squealing as you tried to turn around, only to be met with Steve solid figure. He turns you back around.
‘You don’t mind if sweet girl is only in her undies do ya?’ Steve asks, this makes you flush from head to toe.
‘Nope not at all’ Eddie says laughing, why were they joking!?
‘Good because poor baby girl here is just so comfortable in only her undies’ Steve said, you close you’re eyes in embarrassment.
this is not happening right now.
this is not happening right now.
this is not happening right now.
this is not happening right now.
You reluctantly let Steve lead you to the couch, when you made it to the couch your blush had appeared much more to Eddie.
‘I don’t think she liked you ratting her out Steven’ Eddie said grinning, and the name surprised you because it seemed so foreign.
‘She’ll get over it, right’ Steve says leaning down to look at you, you glare at him but just nod.
Steve urges you to sit, a little close to Eddie but it’s okay, you’re okay. He puts in the VHS, and presses play.
When he sits back on the couch, he pulls you closer to him until you’re on his lap. You felt watched, you didn’t like it.
But once the movie went on, you all sat comfortably. Three blankets spread across. Maybe an hour or so into the movie, you were already passed out.
‘She never makes it through movies’ Steve says grinning as he picked you up. You shift slightly in his hold before relaxing.
He brought you to the room, making sure you were comfortable and tucked in before he felt.
‘Do you think she’ll ever end up liking both of us?’ Eddie asked as soon as Steve closed the door.
‘She already does, she just thinks she’s cheating on me if she does anything with you’ Steve says, Eddie gets up from the couch walking to the kitchen.
‘So how are we supposed to make her think it’s not’ Eddie says, Steve walks over to the island sitting down.
‘I could talk to her, maybe if i say she’s aloud to i’m not sure’ Steve says.
-
‘PRINCESS!’ you were in the kitchen when Steve called you to his room, you turn around from your food and walk to the room.
‘Yeah’ you ask, he waved you over and you raise your eyebrow. You shut the door behind you walking over to him.
‘I gotta talk to you’ he says softly, you were becoming scared. He grabbed your waist pulling you down onto his lap.
‘Should i be scared’ you mumble, he grinned and just shook his head.
‘no of course not, unless you got something to tell me’ he laughs, you just shake you head no.
‘Ok so,’ he slaps his hand down on your thigh as he begins his talk.
‘I’ve noticed, that you get lonely when i’m at work. Locking yourself in my room, and don’t even lie i get told’ Steve says, you blush at that.
‘Well yeah i don’t really have anything to do while you’re gone’ you whisper looking down drawing circles on his jean covered thigh.
‘Which is why i’m making you a deal’ You look up at him in question.
‘a deal?’
‘Yes. I talked to Ed’s, and we both were talking about how devastating it must be, i mean i’m gone lots. So what i’m allowing you to do is when you miss me or need something you can go to Ed’s’ He explains slowly, you just stare at him in shock.
‘Wait… like anything?’ you ask, Steve nods.
‘Wouldn’t that be cheating?’ you mumble, Steve shakes his head no.
‘not if i’ve told you i’m okay with it, and i know it’s happening’ he says, you just sit there confused.
‘Why would you let me do things with Eddie? i’m doing quite fine being lonely’ you say, scared it was a test.
‘Sweet girl, i’m just saying you can you don’t have to’ he explains.
‘i know… i’m just confused’ you say softly, Steve just smiles.
‘Just know if you get… i don’t know needy? then you can go to Ed’s for help’ he said, you just stared at him.
‘really?’ Steve could hear the hint of excitement under what was a voice that you used to try and hide your real feelings.
‘Yeah, i feel bad that you don’t have someone to keep you busy’ he said, you just stare at him in thought.
‘I mean, i keep myself quite busy’ you say looking around realizing you had things left out from throughout the days.
‘I know you do. But like i said, you can you don’t have to’ he said, you just couldn’t wrap your head around it.
You knew he was giving you permission, you understand that. But what you didn’t understand was why he was giving it to you. Why would he want a different boy touching his girlfriend, having sex with his girlfriend. It didn’t make sense, but he said you could and you would.
Even though it felt so wrong, you just couldn’t help but like both the boys. Of course you leaned more to Steve, but if he started letting you do things with Eddie you knew you wouldn’t be able to stop.
-
Steve had left to work, and you felt scared to leave the room. You didn’t know if it would be the same between you and Eddie. Now that his friend told him it was okay to have sex with his girlfriend.
You finally exit the room to get some water, Eddie was at the island eating cereal.
‘Hey’ you whispered softly, Eddie looks up from his cereal bowl and smiles.
‘Hello’ he says, you grab out things to make your food.
The first two days were just awkward to say the least, but one night it broke.
‘Look sweet girl, i’m sorry i don’t want me to go either. But if i don’t my mother will make sure to make my life a living hell, i’ll only be gone two nights. You have ed’s’ He says, you sigh.
You knew you were clingy, especially with Steve. But it’s not your fault when he treated you so well and spoiled you. He gave into your clinginess.
-
Steve had moved outside of Hawkins after what had happened, he hated that town. It made his skin crawl. So when his mom asked him to come back and spend some time with family that was coming down it made his stomach drop.
He honestly just wished to cut off all cords with his mom, but he couldn’t bring himself to do it. It was harder than what it sounded like.
-
You laid in his bed, not able to go to sleep. You were spoiled, you slept each night in Steve’s arms ever since you got together.
You shuffled a bit in the bed before letting out a small whine. You huffed sitting up, walking to the bathroom. When you came back out you grabbed the small blanket that was on top of the big one, wrapping it around you and walking out the door.
Eddie was laid on the couch, peacefully asleep. You knew neither of them cared but it still made you feel guilty sleeping with another guy. Steve had told you over the past few days, he consisted on it actually. So you tried to calm yourself down, but before you could your feet were already bringing you to the couch.
You just wanted a good nights sleep, that’s all. You stood next to the couch for a moment, taking a deep breath. Looking back at the bedroom door, you almost just left back to the room until you heard Eddie move.
You looked back and he was half awake rubbing his eyes, looking up at you with squinted eyes. You just kinda stand there till you get embarrassed and mumble out words.
‘What?’ he asks sitting up on the couch, you play with the ends of the blanket nervously.
‘I can’t go to sleep’ you say keeping your eyes on the blanket. Eddie just eyes you, still half awake. Before it all registers in his brain, remembering Steve was gone and you were all alone in the bed.
He clears his throat scooting back on the couch, lifting up the blanket that was laid on him. Your heart stutters and you quickly join him before your mind second guess’ it.
And you actually felt comfortable, even though you hated Steve’s couch. Eddie brought the blanket back down onto both of you, pulling you closer so you weren’t hanging off the edge.
And your eyes start to drift off, the smell of Eddie surrounding you in the best way.
But you froze when Eddie began to do something Steve always did to help you sleep. He began to slowly rub his thumb back and forth over your hip.
It was some what like a turning page in your head, showing that Eddie and Steve weren’t that different. They both made you feel safe, they both gave you butterflies. And most of all they both made you feel loved.
You never knew you could feel loved by two people at the same time. It felt freeing, and it felt so good.
‘Steve told me, your guys’ deal’ you whispered, Eddie froze a bit.
‘Yeah?’ Eddie asked voice rough, you slightly nod.
‘I’ve never felt this way before’ you mumble, Eddie pulls his eyebrows together.
‘What do you mean sweet girl’ Eddie asked cautiously.
‘Loved, Steve made me feel loved just by himself but now you both make me feel loved.’ You say, Eddie stays silent for a moment.
‘That’s because we do love you y/n.’ he whispered, and it sounded surreal. It didn’t sound right in your ears.
To be wanted by Steve was a huge thing, but to be wanted by two people was hard to grasp.
‘You love me?’ you ask, Eddie hums.
‘Steve knows?’ you ask, Eddie sighs nodding.
‘Do you love us?’ Eddie asks before telling you, you think for a moment.
‘Yeah… yeah i guess i do, but i didn’t know i was allowed to’ you say, Eddie turns you to him.
‘Here’s the thing sweetheart, me and Steve also love each other. So, we all love each other.’ He explains, and it just makes sense. It was right, you loved both of them and they both loved you and each other.
‘I like that’ you say smiling, Eddie gives back a soft smile.
‘Me too’ he whispered, you stare at him hunger shown in your eyes.
‘am i allowed to kiss you’ you ask, Eddie chuckles at you.
And he answers by leaning down and giving you a kiss, you melt into him. He begins to get on top of you, pulling back to let you catch your breath before going back.
It felt so right, his hands on your hips while his soft lips guided yours. When he began to kiss down to your jawline, then your neck. You grabbed handfuls of his hair, whining.
Eddie grinned, pushing your head back so he could get access to that one spot Steve had told him about.
‘If you just get that one spot, she won’t be able to make coherent words’
When he sucked on it you gasped, your hips bucking.
Steve and you didn’t have sex very often, and when you did it was soft.
So when Eddie begin to bite and roughly hold your hips down, you gave a pout.
‘Why you pouting, hm?’ he asks, you grunt trying to move your hips.
‘You are being very impatient right now, Steve didn’t teach you how to behave?’ Eddie asks, you paw at his chest with a frustrated whine.
‘What?’ you ask breathlessly, the feeling of his mouth still lingering on your neck.
‘You get everything you want from Steve? He fuck you when you ask, and he lets you tell him what to do?’ Eddie says, you nod with a confused face.
‘So what i’m hearing is you are a spoiled thing’ he says grinning, you shake your head.
‘i’m not spoiled’ you protest, Eddie just laughs at you.
‘no? then why don’t you be a good girl and be patient, yeah?’ he says, and your insides twist at the tone of his voice. You nod your head.
His hands slid under your shirt making you shiver. You moan when his hands come over your bare breasts.
Eddie noticed how reactive you were to everything he was doing. It led him to think you didn’t get this as much as you should have. You’re eyes were blown wide, just wanting to please him.
‘Stevie doesn’t fuck you enough does he?’ He cooed, you whine shaking your head.
‘You poor thing’ he says with sarcastic sympathy, you pout.
He helps you take off your shirt, throwing it to the side. His fingers hook into the waist band of your pajama shorts, he leaves them there for a second to give you time to change your mind. You just lift your hips up in answer, he chuckles at you pulling down your shorts.
‘fuck, your soaking your little panties’ Eddie grinned when you blushed. You turn your head in embarrassment, he turns your head to meet his eyes. You hated making eye contact it killed you inside.
‘Got you embarrassed hm?’ he says, you roll your eyes trying to hide the fact that you were very much indeed embarrassed.
‘Oh? so you’ve got attitude’ he says, turning your chin roughly. Your eyes were so blown wide it made you even more harder to resist.
You shake your head, he just narrows his eyes.
‘You’d think you would be grateful, i’m being so nice to you sweet girl. I can be mean.’ He says making your eyes go wide.
mean?
‘Steve doesn’t get rough with you? does he baby you?’ Eddie says, slowly discarding your underwear.
You didn’t answer too distracted by his fingers being everywhere but where you wanted them.
‘You know, i wouldn’t buy you for the vanilla type,’ Eddie says, finger pressing into your entrance making you moan.
When his finger is fully seated in you, you grab hands full of his hair.
‘You don’t love the idea of me fucking you so hard to the point where you can’t even say your own name, you don’t want me to be mean to you while i give you pleasure?’ he says, you shake your head no but your insides tell you yes when you clench around his finger.
When his finger begins a pace you mewl, pushing your hips down. He then adds a second finger making you gasp.
Sure you’ve gotten way bigger, but just the way he was being rough had your mind spiraling.
‘Oh but you do like it rough, don’t ya princess?’ he asks, you don’t answer trying to stand your ground. You hated it when you weren’t right, especially about your own self.
He just laughs at you, because he knew he was right. He felt your pussy clench down on his fingers, he knew you liked it.
Soon his two fingers were pounding into you, and it felt so foreign. Steve was the one to take your virginity, and ever since all you’ve known is soft sex. So for Eddie to show you such roughness made you question why Steve has never done it, because quite frankly it felt so good.
The continuous hits of his fingers into you were making you go crazy. Your hips bucked up as you whine throwing your hands down to claw your hands into the couch.
‘i- i eddieeee’ you whine loosing your breath when he hits a particular spot.
‘ohmygod’ you try to keep your composure but you couldn’t, he was relentless.
‘Ah! just what i was looking for’ he grins, leaning down to kiss on your neck.
‘This is mean!’ you protest, he just laughs hot air fanning your neck.
‘You can tell me to stop, do you want me to stop?’ he says, you groan shaking your head.
‘Than shut up and be a good girl for me yeah?’ he says, and when your body shivers it gives him all the answers he needs.
You hadn’t even realized the tear that rolled down your cheek till he kissed it away. But you weren’t sad… just overwhelmed. The pleasure drew you so far you felt like you were floating.
And when he landed his thumb on your clit, you exploded. Eyes rolling back as you saw stars, thighs shaking. And small sobs erupting from you as you bask in the feelings you just went through.
When your brain was finally brought back to life you looked down and your eyes go wide.
did you pee?!?
You look up at Eddie in fear, he just pulls you up carrying you. You wince when he sits you on the bathroom counter.
‘Sorry baby’ it was so distant but it made you fuzzy on the inside nonetheless.
You meet his eyes your dazed stare making him smile. You gasp when you felt a warm rag drag up your folds. You were picked back up, and taken into Steve’s room. When you got in Eddie placed you down on the bed, walking off.
‘Where are you going!’ him walking you off snaps you out of your daze.
‘I’m just going to get you some clothes sweet girl’ he says, you sigh laying back down.
When he comes back he helps you put on one of Steve’s shirts and a pair of panties. You sigh when you get under the cold sheets, you grab his hand pulling him down with you. He laughs a little getting under the sheets with you.
Instead of it being awkward, this time you snuggle into him liking the warmth and comfort he radiated. He smiles to himself bringing you close, his arm wrapped tightly around you.
When his hand trails up under your shirt and starts to rub your back, his short nails grazing against your skin you melt into him.
‘Good night’ you whisper, he mumbles it back kissing your cheek.
And somehow, you end up falling asleep just as good as you would if it was Steve.
-
You woke up to the jingles of keys and the opening of the front door, but you were too lost in sleep to care.
But when you felt the dip of the bed and someone slid into it, the soft smell of cologne and lavender your senses were alarmed. You smile when kisses were laid on your cheek. You softly laugh when he begins to attack you with kisses.
‘What are doing home early, i thought you were staying for two nights’ you say, he rolls his eyes.
‘Yeah but you know me, i could never stay that long with my family and how they are’ he said annoyance filled in his voice. It wasn’t until then did you notice there wasn’t another body in the bed.
You turn to see the bed empty, you turn back to Steve and he laughs at you.
‘He’s in the kitchen, he told me all about last night eh?’ he grinned pulling you to lay on his lap. You blush looking away.
‘And he also told me,’ Steve begin sitting up with his back to the headboard, pulling you up with him.
‘That sweet girl, likes it rough’ Steve said it like he was a little kid saying a bad word. You giggle, and you make a mental note to cringe at yourself later. But you can’t help it, the two boys made you feel so giddy.
‘You are a dirty dirty girl’ Steve says edging on your embarrassment. You can’t stand looking in his eyes, nuzzling your face into his neck. He laughs rubbing up and down your back.
‘How come you didn’t tell me?’ he says, you groan more sounding like a whine.
‘because i didn’t even know!’ you say, looking up from his neck.
The door opened and you make a grunt when Eddie piled on top of both you and Steve. He laughs at the both of you, kissing your cheek as a sorry and tapping Steve’s head since his lips couldn’t get to him.
‘My little vanilla babies, have no idea how to have fun’ Eddie says grinning.
‘It’s all Steve’s fault!’ you say laughing when he gasps.
‘How is it my fault?!’ Steve says in defense.
‘I was a virgin when i got with you! you’re the only person i’ve ever been with, so you made me vanilla’ you say, using the word Eddie used even though you had no fucking idea what it meant.
‘ohhh yup, i think princess has point Harrington’ Eddie says, his dimples out.
‘The only reason i went Vanilla on you was because i was scared i was gonna hurt you, and you seemed to like it so i kept doing it’ Steve protests, Eddie rolls his eyes.
‘Boooo, lame excuse. If you just do it right, you can never hurt her. She’s a very strong little lady’ Eddie says, you smile looking back at Steve who was over you two.
‘You two have only been together for one night and you’re already ganging up on me?! what is this! i declare justice’ Steve says, you just laugh laying back down on his chest.
‘It’s okay Stevie, Eddie will just have to teach you right ed’s?’ And for the first time the nickname Steve has always called him slips out your mouth. It makes Eddie so giddy he nearly explodes.
‘Yeah, i sure can.’ he said proudly.
‘How about we start right now yeah? wanna be our prop sweet girl’ Eddie says getting up, you go wide eyed. You’ve never gotten two orgasms within 2 days, let alone within the span of 7 hours.
‘Oh my Ed’s what have you done to my princess, she has a look of terror’ Steve says, Eddie shakes his head.
‘No no no, that is not a look of terror. That is a look of pure joy and excitement, Stevie’ Eddie says, Steve looks back at you and your smirking.
‘What have you done to my precious baby’ Steve says, Eddie shoves his shoulder back into the bed.
‘Our precious baby’ Eddie corrects, and it makes your stomach churn.
Oh boy were you excited.
—
Okay so i will make a part two, if you guys want. Because i know i stole away the smut from you but i feel like i’ve been holding off this story from you guys for way too long! I need to post it! So i hope you enjoyed, lots of love!
-Ky