Recently, I stumbled upon this photo and feel dumb that I never connected that they would have been colleges from the same state. I know W. met LBJ as a boy, but I was wondering if you knew anything about LBJ's impression of HW? Long time fan, Anthony! I've been into presidential history since the first grade, and now, in my late 30s, I can say you are my favorite person to go to on the subject. Always keeping it fresh. Recently, bought and re-read your Presidents on Presidents for the 2nd time(I lost my old kindle account lol) and it is such a fun read. Keep up the good work!
Thank you! I really do appreciate it.
LBJ and George H.W. Bush didn't have a ton of interaction -- Bush's first term in the House of Representatives from Texas was during LBJ's final two years in the White House -- and they were obviously from opposing political parties.
However, they were both Texans and Bush was a rising star in Republican politics, and LBJ certainly took notice of him. Even though Bush had barely served a year in Congress at the time, Richard Nixon seriously considered choosing him as his running mate in 1968. And in 1970, Bush was trying to decide whether or not to give up his seat in the House and make a run for the U.S. Senate in Texas. Bush actually made the trip out the LBJ Ranch where Johnson had retired to after leaving the White House in 1969 to ask for LBJ's advice (despite being from opposing parties). That's when LBJ gave Bush the legendary quote that "The difference between the Senate and the House is the difference between chicken salad and chicken shit." Bush did make a bid for the Senate, but instead of facing Ralph Yarborough, who many felt he had a chance of defeating, Bush had to face Lloyd Bentsen, who he lost to pretty decisively.
While LBJ and George H.W. Bush didn't know each that well -- mainly because of the age difference and where they were at in their respective careers at that time -- LBJ did serve in the Senate (as Senate Majority Leader) with Bush's father, Senator Prescott Bush of Connecticut. And when asked in 2006 about his thoughts about LBJ by historian and longtime LBJ Library director Mark K. Updegrove, George H.W. Bush said:
"My view is that he was a good man -- very good to me. My father served in the Senate with him and knew him, I'm sure, far better than I did, and he respected Lyndon. And I [asked him], "Why do you respect Lyndon?" And he said, "His word is good. He would tell us, 'There's going to be a vote at 3:30 pm for this bill, and here's the way it's going to work. It's going to come up, and there's going to be this amendment, and it's going to be voted on...' And dad said you could put it in the bank. You could make your plans, do what you needed to do, and know exactly [what would happen.] Just the fact that a guy like my dad, from the other side of the aisle -- felt that way about him -- I've never forgotten that."
In Jon Meacham's masterful biography of George H.W. Bush, Destiny and Power: The American Odyssey of George Herbert Walker Bush (BOOK | KINDLE | AUDIO), he notes that Bush approached LBJ at a party in 1967 before the wedding of LBJ's daughter Lynda and told him, "Mr. President, I just want you to know that I may not agree with you but you can count on me to never attack you personally." LBJ responded: "George, Mrs. Johnson and I raise cattle and we have learned to look at the stock. We say, 'Who's the daddy?' We know you're all right."
But I think my favorite story about LBJ and George H.W. Bush -- and one that illustrates why I think LBJ might have had a soft spot for Bush despite being from different parties and different generations -- is told by George W. Bush in his 2014 book, 41: A Portrait of My Father (BOOK | KINDLE | AUDIO). Writing about LBJ's decision not to seek re-election in 1968, Richard Nixon's eventual victory over LBJ's Vice President Hubert H. Humphrey, and Nixon's inauguration on January 20, 1969, George W. Bush writes:
"An hour later, LBJ departed the nation's capital, where he had been a fixture since his election to Congress in 1937. He left with few friends.
Out of both respect and sympathy, Dad decided to go to Andrews Air Force Base to see off the former President. Amid the large crowd, a few other Congressmen showed up, including LBJ's longtime friend Jake Pickle, but Dad was the only Republican. When Lady Bird Johnson's press secretary, Liz Carpenter, noticed Dad standing in the crowd, she pointed him out to the outgoing President. LBJ walked over, shook his hand, and said, "George, I'm grateful that you're here. Come visit me and Lady Bird at the ranch sometime."
George W. Bush then notes that George H.W. Bush took LBJ up on the offer a few months later and tells the "chicken salad/chicken shit" story.
In Meacham's biography of George H.W. Bush, Destiny and Power, he goes into a little more detail about how touched LBJ was by Bush's gesture at Andrews Air Force Base as LBJ was leaving Washington:
"Bush also took time on Inauguration Day to drive to Andrews Air Force Base to bid farewell to President Johnson. It was cold -- the temperature was about twenty degrees -- and the ceremony was brief, with an army band playing "Auld Lang Syne" and the national anthem before 105 mm howitzers fired a twenty-one-gun salute.
Bush shook Johnson's hand. The congressman long remembered what he called the "poignancy of the moment" -- the leave-taking of a once-powerful President, once master of his domain, now deflated, driven from office by a war he could not win and by a nation that once loved him but now could hardly wait to see him go. After Bush, "wished him a safe journey," the former President "nodded, took a few steps down the ramp, then turned, looked at me, and said, "Thanks for coming."
Johnson also appreciated a report of a remark of Bush's from Joe B. Frantz, director of the LBJ Library's Oral History Project. As Frantz told the story to Johnson, he had asked Bush "why a prominent Republican such as he was seeing you off instead of being in the midst of Republican activities in the city. His reply was a nice tribute to you: 'He has been a fine President and invariably courteous and fair to me and my people, and I thought that I belonged here to show in a small way how much I have appreciated him. I wish I could do even more.'" From Bush's perspective, there might also be utility in Johnson's continuing warmth. Should Bush challenge the liberal senator Ralph Yarborough once more in 1970, it was just possible that Johnson might be quietly helpful -- or at least, as Bush and Nixon biographer Herbert S. Parmet observed, do no harm.
"Please know that I value your friendship, as I do your father's, and that I am glad you are one of us down here in Texas," Johnson wrote Bush on the last day of January [1969]. "When you are home sometime, come to see us."