New Life for a Carnegie Library
On December 1, 2018, Cleveland residents will reclaim a beloved neighborhood institution when Cleveland Public Library’s South Branch officially reopens and resumes library services after years of restoration efforts.
The Library decided to build the South Branch in 1907. It was the eighth branch in the system built by gifts from Andrew Carnegie. While other branches were built in brick, South Branch was notably constructed of rough-hewn gray ashlar stone. The architecture was described in the Library’s 1911 Annual Report as English Gothic with a Tudor interior. In correspondence between architects Whitfield & King and Head Librarian William Howard Brett, Hoghton Tower in Lancashire, England was cited as the inspiration for the library. The availability of limestone building material influenced the techniques of English stone masons.
The city of Cleveland was also in the midst of a City Beautiful Movement at the time. In a 1908 letter to Whitfield, Brett wrote:
“I am exceedingly desirous that this building should be definitely a correct example of the Tudor architecture. I believe that to have a public building which could be pointed out as an example of this style would be of value to the city.”
Whitfield & King designed many academic and public libraries prior to this commission. Some examples of their work include:
Carnegie Library, Laramie, WY (1903) - now a government building Jennings Carnegie Public Library, Jennings, LA (1907) Carnegie Library, Hickman, KY (1908) - now a museum Anne Wallace Branch-Carnegie Library of Atlanta, GA (1980) - now a bank Carnegie Library of Barnesville, GA (1909) - now a private home Wissahickon Branch-Philadelphia Free Library, PA (1909) - burned down c.1969 Eaton Hall, Tufts University, MA (1908) - now classrooms and a computer lab Thirty-Sixth Street Branch Library, Minneapolis, MN (1916)
South Branch is located on the corners of Scranton and Clark Avenues. The location was central to a residential neighborhood and within reach of several public and parish schools. The neighborhood in 1911 was largely German, Bohemian and American born. By 1924, older families had moved out and more immigrant families moved in. Twenty-one different nationalities were represented in the branch’s register.
Thank you to Ann Marie Wieland, Cleveland Public Library Archivist for her invaluable research!















