💚 but also?? I need to know about this?? Ages ago I saw someone on reddit say Andy would adore Elphaba and they initially thought her witch costume in season 7 was supposed to be an Elphaba nod and like I love this and I want your thoughts Please
"I feel the need to warn you that every time I've gone to see a Broadway show, something bad happens."
Andy's eyes widened a little bit and honestly, CJ couldn't blame her. It was a pretty ridiculous way to begin a conversation.
"I know that sounds fake, but in 8th grade my school choir took a trip to New York and saw Annie, and the line for the bathroom was so long that I got separated from the group, and the bus for the hotel left without me, and--"
"You were in choir?" Andy asked, apparently seizing on that little factoid instead of the point of CJ's story.
She nodded, her voice brisk. "Yes, for two years, I was an alto."
"Nice," Andy responded. She raised her hand, then pointed to herself. "Second soprano."
"You got the fun parts, then. The melody."
"Not as much as the first sopranos did."
"Andy, I'm not a singer, I just took choir because I couldn't find another elective that fit my schedule. The point is, I got nearly left behind and had to run like an idiot down 42nd Street, waving my arms over my head to get the bus driver's attention," CJ said, her tone turning exasperated. "In college, I went to see a preview performance and got my purse stolen, and--"
An image of Simon's face flashed through her mind, and she looked down. And the last time I went to a show on Broadway, someone I cared about ended up getting killed and I swear to God, if that happens again--
There was a pause, and CJ swore she could feel the moment realization settled in for Andy. She felt a gentle hand on her arm and when Andy spoke again, her voice was quiet, soothing. "Hey. Hey, it's okay. It's okay, CJ. If you don't want to go, it's okay--I can go by myself, I don't mind. It's just that the daughter of one of my big donors is in the ensemble, so she got me tickets and I have an extra, and it's supposed to be good, and--"
"I'll go."
Andy blinked. "Hmm?"
"I--I'll go. I don't want you to have to go by yourself."
-------------------------
SO this idea just kind of hit me out of nowhere, because of course Wicked: For Good is coming out and I was thinking about the Broadway show and how it came out right in the middle of the West Wing's run, so possibly characters might have seen it/heard of it. I first listened to it around 2006, and being as I was in middle school and didn't realize I was bi, I...did not get the shipping of Elphaba and Glinda, at all, until MUCH later. So then I started thinking about CJ and Andy, how they might react to the show, and CJ possibly being a little traumatized after her last dramatic experience, and Andy's gaydar being more honed than mine, (and maybe CJ's too) because at least one or both of them is going to be like "so this is...pretty gay, right?" It's VERY rough in my head right now and doesn't have much of a plot other than that, but that's the general idea.
I DO think Andy in particular will love the show. I think she'll think it's politically relevant, catchy, with a good message and amazing production value and she'll probably leave comparing the Wizard to a handful of Congressmen she works with. And I'm almost wondering if anyone in Congress or in her district has ever made an off-color, mocking joke about her being the Wicked Witch of the West, and her embracing that, reclaiming that in a way.