why do you hate pt, are you insane? do you have problems
Ok so like I don't hate hate pt, I don't have enough brainpower to allocate to giving much of a shit but frankly I hate how the fandom treats it and bemoans what could've been while ignoring the good parts of 4 out of 8 of the games. There's so many horror games out there that do what PT did 1000 times better bc they're actually games and not just demos, and imo pt isn't scary it's just a collection of contextless hallways and events and jumpscares and it's fine for a demo honestly it's a good demo but with nothing else? I'm not that impressed by it anymore.
Also, I really have doubts it would've been any good bc a) Konami wasn't gonna spend money to make it, especially not with that level of quality. They just werent
And b) while I've only briefly played any mgs games, from what I've heard i don't think Kojima's writing would've suited a silent Hill game (assuming he even wrote anything or was going to, we'll never know) also attaching a well known name to something doesn't mean it'll be good.
Besides that, every other silent Hill game did most if not all the concepts PT did but better bc yknow...they're actually fully complete games. Which is fine, bc pt is a demo, but it's not ingenious or anything. And if silent Hill 1-downpour didn't do it than a different horror game has absolutely done it. I also despise how so many ppl compare every game now to pt (or they did I think it's died down but man I heard ppl comparing re7 to pt when they're nothing alike bc re7 has..what a hallway??)
All in all, it was a charming little novelty demo that probably still makes people a little sad for the days when you might've hoped for an HD silent Hill, and i applaud everyone spending time to recreate it from scratch its very impressive. But I kinda wish ppl would let it go yknow?












