Hi! I was wondering if I could ask you for advice about OSCE prep? I'm a final year medical student and one area I've noticed I've struggled with is time management during OSCE stations? Eg, I find that I take a history and by the time I have to do a management plan, the OSCE station time has finished. One area I also struggle with is how to structure a management plan of the level of a first day FY1. I'd be extremely grateful is you could give advice? Thank you in advance!
Hi anon! apologies I didn't see this in my inbox, I hope I'm not too late with this reply
My final year exams were MOSLERs so we had a little more time and they were split so we had a specific amount of time for the discussion afterwards and were told to move on, but we did have to manage a history and examination in the time so I hope these help
If your medical school publish the generic mark schemes for OSCEs look at them and look at what you have to cover and how many marks each part is. For example, there may be only one point to ask about medication and allergies, but more for digging into the history of presenting complaint, but it's important not to forget those small things as they can be easy marks to pick up with just one question.
Practice getting a balance of open and closed questions - if you're asking lots of closed questions you're taking lots of time up asking them, whereas something broader to cover more things lets you get more information with only one question. "Are you having any other symptoms" is better than "do you get x, y, z"
Practice with a timer, over and over. There's resources out there with cases so you don't get bored of the same things, but practice with someone, and only do the history part and try and get it down to less than the osce station time. Then you'll get a better sense of how long you're taking on the day and be able to move on through the questions.
In terms of a management plan I would think of it as bedside investigations, bloods, imaging and treatment and this will help you structure it - bedside are tests like urinalysis, peak flow, ECG - bloods - think about why you want them rather than just reeling off all you can think of - will the one you're asking for help with the treatment or diagnosis - imaging - again why are you getting it, justify why are you getting a chest XR for cardiac sounding chest pain? etc - treatment - this depends on what the case is, if it's an emergency case then using the ABCDE structure and treating what's wrong in each part is usually the best way to go, if it's more of a chronic disease then it's going to be disease specific, but don't forget more holistic things such as giving an asthma plan, or referring to a specialist nurse/physiotherapist
I don't think we had to describe management plan of a first day F1 in our exams, but if you want my advice generally for starting out as an F1 and how to make a management plan my advice would be:
If you're on a ward round the question you need to think is how does this person get home? It might not be that day, but what are we aiming for? they need to be off IV treatments onto oral, they need to be at a mobility and independence level that they can get home, and they need to have follow up organised if it is needed. So think: is this patient ready to step down to oral antibiotics? Do they need physio/occupational therapy?
Or alternatively - is the current treatment working? are their bloods getting better, do they feel better? if not, how can we change the management or do they need more investigations?
I know this all sounds really overwhelming and you won't be doing it on your own, and you won't cover everything when you first start but that's ok! You're there to learn and I would encourage you to make suggestions. It feels horrible if the consultant disagrees and even now 5 years in I don't like writing my management plan before the consultant has seen the patient because 'what if it's wrong' but often it's not 'wrong' just not quite what that particular consultant would do, and another consultant might do things completely differently (it's very frustrating)
Hope that's helpful with my hazy memory of exams at med school haha. If anyone else has advice then feel free to add! and good luck anon :)

















