The Mixtape Close Ups
These may be the closest shots in recent memory for SPN:
Now, I mentioned before that the closer a shot is, the more importance is generally given to it. (this isn’t always true but it’s a solid film language expectation in western dialogue scenes and SPN follows it pretty consistently. It’s how dialogue is often given dynamics, especially when there isn’t much blocking).
This is right after Dean gives the mixtape back to Cas. But he’s framed this way through the entire mixtape section of the scene except when he gives the mixtape back which invokes it’s own symbolism and closeup insert. That means anytime he’s cropped like this, be it speaking or reacting, it is meant to be dramatic and important.
Comedy is a wide shot, drama is a closeup. They (according to western film language) intend a ton of drama and weight from this part of the scene. Looking back at previous scenes, even between Cas and Dean, how many of them have been this close? Dean is very affected by what is happening and this really drove home to me what the mixtape meant to him.(not that it really needs much more, really. But if you wanted more, here it is.)
An interesting thing about this is how these extreme closeups are (generally) made. There is a decent chance they didn’t actually have a camera that close to him, and either had it a reasonable but still close distance out and zoomed in, or the scaling was done in post. It’s probably a mix of both.
Editing programs allow the editor to take a piece of footage and scale it up or down so it looks zoomed in or out, file size allowing. That’s probably how they achieved this shot without having the camera take up a bunch of space: A zoom with the camera, and an edit.
Either way, someone wanted it, and by someone I mean probably the director, but certainly the editor and producer(show runners) for I dunno, some reason.










