Mr. D's Pizzeria, Steaks, & Subs - New Jersey Ave in Wildwood, NJ
Post #2 in my Wildwood Za 2022 Series is a place that Paul has actually gone to (and recommended to me!) before. And, as should be no surprise, it delivered. Mr. D's is quite possibly the runner-up to Mack's for best Wildwood slice. First off, this might be the best value you're going to get in Wildwood. $2.72 for a slice that's wide enough to be almost two slices! Considering most places are charging a minimum of $3 for a normal-sized plain, that's a steal. It also was a tasty slice with great cheese and a nice balance of sauce underneath. Honestly the only thing holding it back for me was that the crust got a little too dry and crackly when they heated it up. I was waiting a while for it though and it was SUPER hot, so I have a feeling they forgot about my slice and left it in the oven too long.
I'm giving Mr. D's the benefit of the doubt with this one though and give it a wholehearted recommendation. On top of being the best value you'll get for Wildwood pizza, it's much easier to stop in for a quick slice than trekking up to the boardwalk. I'm sure I'll find my way back next year for a round 2 that will hopefully trump round 1. Maybe I'll even get a pepperoni....
