There’s a “twenty-minute mark” in the new Star Wars films where I have a sudden epiphany. For Rogue One it was “Oh no, this is trouble”, for The Last Jedi it was: “I think I hate this movie”, and like clockwork, twenty minutes into Solo: A Star Wars Story I had another epiphany: “Star Wars is just different now”. I always thought I’d say that through gritted teeth, or that I would feel numb and sad, but I don’t. I don’t feel upset at what Star Wars has become because it is a fascinating problem to have in terms of over-saturation. Years ago when I found out that Disney acquired the rights to Star Wars and was going to start pumping them out at an alarming rate, my only hope was that the films would do a good job putting balance back into The Force and for the most part, it has and I should be grateful.
Solo, like Rogue One and the new Episodes, has a lot going for it. Fleshing out the Star Wars universe and giving us more to look at and new individuals to root for is a novel concept, but where all of these Star Wars Stories fail is the fact that they take place before the current continuity. It means that nothing matters and everyone is expendable unless you recognize their name. Take Solo for example: we know Lando, Chewie and Han are in this film. They make it out fine because we know we see them in Episodes 4-6, but who are all these other people? Like Rogue One, we know they’re not making it out because we never see these characters again. Another problem with “filling in the blanks” is that it causes throwaway lines to gain too much importance. It’s like in the Star Trek remakes when we see the Kobayashi Maru: we don’t need to see it happen, we just need to hear that it happened. The general rule of thumb of “show don’t tell” only works if it’s the first time you’re seeing it. Retroactively going back and making me watch how Han Solo managed to make the Kessel Run in twelve parsecs isn’t necessary. Seeing the exact hand of Sabacc that Solo played that lost Lando his Millennium Falcon in the first place, or seeing Chewbacca play Dejarik for the first time no longer feels like a bridge from old to new like in The Force Awakens, it just feels sloppy.
All of this aside, “Star Wars is different now”. The film felt very much for the whole family. The violence was toned down to an extent I didn’t expect to see from a story of the rise of a smuggler. There are a lot of allusions to death and the action picks up sparingly, but never in a way that gives a lot of stakes.
Who knows what Chris and Phil had planned for Solo that turned the film upside down and forced the directors to be removed, but I have a feeling it probably would’ve been tonally different enough to make Solo stand out a bit more from the crowd. If nothing else, the humour that L3 brought to the film was refreshing, and although tonally different and out of place, was acceptable being a “Star Wars Story” and not an episodic title. I want to explore different tones in the Star Wars universe and not everything needs to be a serious drag, but not knowing when to play one note or the other can be the downfall for a lot of these films, and consistently relying on retreading the stories of old characters is the fasted way for me to lose interest in Star Wars altogether.