“Look Down” and “The Robbery,” London, 2000. Jason McCann as Enjolras, Nilkas Andersson as Marius, Barry James as Thénardier, Mandy Holliday as Mme. Thénardier, Joanna Ampil as Éponine, Simon Bowman as Jean Valjean, Zoë Curlett as Cosette, Paul F. Monoghan as Javert, unknown Gavroche.
Since the upper part of the stage is blocked from view, we can’t see Enjolras or Marius during their lines from the bridge in “Look Down.” Still, as a whole, the scene comes across just fine.
I don’t think I’ve ever seen another “Look Down” where the beggars and paupers treated each other so brutally. Not only do the old beggar woman and young prostitute have their fight, but a gang of urchins harass the old woman and try to steal her belongings the whole while, and then the pimp slaps the prostitute to the ground even though she didn’t start the conflict. And then we have Gavroche getting into a little fight with a beggar in the crowd during Marius and Enjolras’s lines, as well as two men shoving each other at the very beginning of the scene. It’s a disturbing showcase of how poverty can make people act like animals.
Gavroche is very good, both in voice and in attitude.
I remember that the fan reviews of this cast (which I read when I was barely older than Gavroche) often used to make fun of Jason McCann’s vibrato. It is heavy and a little throaty, but not really as bad as I was led to believe. He still has a good, solid voice for the role of Enjolras.
This staging adds a unique detail to the Éponine/Montparnasse interaction by having him give her a rose, only for her to toss it back after she elbows him in the ribs. Then we have him grabbing her again and trying to kiss her neck at the beginning of “The Robbery.” Minor details, but they could definitely spark some Montponine shipping! It’s also interesting on the final “Look Down” chorus, Thénardier yanks Éponine into his lap, to her evident discomfort – I’ve never seen that done before. I wonder, is he just playing the role of caring father to earn sympathy from the people they’re “begging” to, or does this blocking hint at father/daughter incest? The latter would make Thénardier an even darker figure than he is in the novel, let alone in most musical productions!
Joanna’s Éponine makes a good first impression, privately straightening her hair and clothes when she sees Marius, but promptly hiding her girlish insecurity and playing the brash, teasing street rat in front of him. Niklas’s Marius comes off well too, friendly and (when trying to interfere with the robbery) a bit hot-blooded, yet still dignified. Kudus to the way he stands fixated on Cosette after bumping into her, never taking his eyes off her even as she walks away, and then of course protecting her from Montparnasse while the rest of the gang attacks Valjean. (I love that moment in the Nunn/Caird staging!)
Not even Cosette is fully spared from this performance’s rough edge – I’ve never seen a performance onstage where Marius accidentally knocked her flat onto the ground!
Speaking of Zoë’s Cosette, she recognizes Mme. Thénardier! She draws back and hides behind Valjean before Thénardier says “Wait a bit...”! It’s nice to see a performance that doesn’t totally disconnect grown-up Cosette from her childhood. On a shallower note, I love her beautiful long curls too. London Cosette wigs in the early 2000s were so much prettier than US Cosette wigs at the time.
Barry’s Thénardier is excellent, as always, with the perfect balance between humor and slime. I like that he doesn’t cringe nervously away from Javert after “It was me what told you so,” the way most Thénardiers do, but goes on standing and subtly trying to bait Javert into making a deal with him, until his wife finally decides they should leave. Their repeated sycophantic bows and curtsies to Javert as they go are funny too.
Paul’s Javert is nicely sharp and stern, as in the other scenes of his I’ve shared. Very different from his TAC performance as the Bishop.
Overall, this is a scene well done!