(I saw your answer to neo, and something besides the point caught my attention.) Why do you like selling arms to the KSA?
If someone wants to buy arms, I think we should sell them.
I don’t feel threatened by Iran the way the Americans, Israelis, and Sunni Arabs do, but if the KSA feels threatened, I think we should sell them the arms they need to defend themselves.
The KSA wants to provide for its own defense. I think it’s worthwhile to defend the world’s largest oil reserves against threats from Iraq, Iran, Yemen, and domestic Islamists. I think it would be unfortunate if the KSA was overcome by those threats. And it would trouble me if they were cowed by them.
I know that arms are an imperfect defense against domestic opposition, and there’s some danger that the arms could be turned against us. But these are not sophisticated arms, and I believe the marginal risk to internal and regional stability from an insecure KSA is greater than the marginal risk from a better-armed opposition.
I also read the KSA as a status-quo power. I don’t think they’re going to invade anyone. I think arms sales reduce the chance of preemptive war by the KSA, nuclear proliferation to the KSA, direct conflict between the KSA and Iran, direct conflict between Israel and Iran, internal rebellion in the KSA, and realignment of the KSA away from the United States. And I think that’s a good thing.
I understand that KSA supports indirect wars against Iranian-aligned powers in the Middle East, and I understand that the forces it supports can be unsavory. But I don’t have a strong ideological opposition to Islamist states or to the KSA.
I do believe the KSA is worse than Iran, but I don’t think they’re worse than Iraq or Syria, and I don’t think the Syrian opposition is much worse than the Syrian government.
I also happen to think most attempts to force ideological change in the Middle East are misguided and counterproductive. I think this one would be too. I think the tension the KSA would feel without foreign support would accelerate both domestic and regional instability, and I think the ideological consequences would be negative.
I think that the KSA should have the capacity to defend itself against external and internal threats. And If the KSA wants that capacity, I’d prefer to have the NATO powers selling it, not Russia, Pakistan, or China.
I also just like arms in general. I think they’re neat.