My (23M) friend (26F) constantly gives unsolicited advice, how do I tell her to stop kindly?
She’s a good friend, she’s generally very nice to have around. But these last few months, I’ve been noticing a pattern that bothers me (and other people): if anyone talks to her about a situation in their life, she will try to put herself in a « teacher » position, like she knows something they surely don’t.
It’s a bit hard to explain but let me give short examples: a mutual friend complained about his boss treating him badly, and she replied « I’ll write you an email with every law article that says what he’s doing is illegal, I know my law very well, I can scare him. » which seems like a nice thing to do, but it bothered our friend because she didn’t ask If he needed her help, she assumed he did, and that he had no idea how the law works and couldn’t write that email himself. (she doesn’t have a law degree or anything either)
Another example, I was trying to read a handwritten letter and couldn’t decipher a few words, so I asked her if she could read it. She helped me find them, I said « thanks ! » and she then proceeded to give me the definition of each word (all common, by the way). Which, again, is a small thing and could come from a good place, but I don’t like that she assumed I didn’t know what the words meant. It just makes me feel like she thinks other people always know less than her.
She also hates when someone knows more than her because she can’t do this: she was talking to me the other day about a popular political figure from the 80s in my country (again, didn’t ask if I knew him, just started the conversation with « I just discovered this guy, let me let you about him »), but I am much more involved in politics than she is, the guy in question is very popular in my party and also some of the info she gave me was wrong lol. So I just said « Thanks, I already know about him though, I’m glad you discovered him he’s great » and kindly corrected her wrong information. She texted me the next morning that it made her feel very bad and that I could’ve just thanked her for the info instead of « showing off that I already knew him ».
These are just a few situations but honestly she does this all the time, it’s almost impossible to have a conversation without her giving unsolicited advise or explaining obvious things like she’s teaching other people.
I don’t know if what I’m saying makes sense, but it’s really been bugging me and I want to tell her because I’m not sure she knows she’s doing this. I just don’t know how to say it nicely, I don’t want to make her feel bad but I do want her to stop, lol. And also please do tell me if you think I’m being petty for no reason, I understand it’s also a possibility.
Leave examples THAT AREN'T ABOUT YOU out of it, even if the other person has verbally confirmed it bothers them. You cannot and should not attempt to speak for other people.
Since you have tried politely correcting her and just letting things go, and she becomes confrontational over it, I will provide a potential example script to start with (though I think that trying to talk about this on a case-by-case basis might be less overwhelming).
Practice your I- statements and focus on how it makes you feel rather than trying to objectively state that she's speaking wrong. Try to make it a conversation rather than a lecture.
"Hey, this is hard to say, but I want to say it because I really value your friendship, and I'd like to try and understand where this comes from so we can work through it. Have you noticed that you have a tendency to need to be the smartest person in the room?"
(Her: Huh? No? What do you mean???)
"It really confuses me because you are genuinely a smart and awesome person, and I value your opinion. Sometimes it feels like you don't value my opinion, though, like when you were talking to me about [politics guy] and were upset that I had some information that contradicted what you'd learned. Misinformation is really easy to come across. I hadn't pointed it out to shame you, but rather because that's an important part of a back-and-forth conversation between two adults who respect each other. I love when you share your knowledge with me, but I'd like for there to be room for me to do the same with you. What kind of things do you want out of a friendship with me?"
But I will tell you that I have a friend like this, and at the end of the day, I just had to pull back from the friendship. She is a "small doses" person. It's a shame she's so insecure and unwilling to do anything to overcome that, but hey. I have my own flaws. I'm sure I did a ton of shit that annoyed and upset her, too. I'm just the one that became overwhelmed and decided to back away first.