So something that’s been nagging at me for a while...
Wish Hook and Original Hook... Are the same person. (For the sake of this post I’m going to refer to them as Rogers and Jones to save time.)
Like, yes, they’re alternatives but they’re still the SAME person. Their lives took different directions but they do the same thing, they act how the other would act. Note: I’m not saying they’re clones of one another. Not any more at least cause their lives took different directions, so they will make different decisions and will act a different way to an extent.
I just don’t get people saying stuff like, they prefer Rogers because he’s a better man than Jones. Like... I guess he kind of is, but only because he’s been offered more opportunities to be a better man than Jones was. Like, people point out the White Elephant as an example but I’m pretty sure Jones would have done the same thing if the opportunity presented itself to him. I just don’t understand the people who hate Jones but love Rogers? And then there are those who hate Rogers but love Jones. And just so we’re clear, liking and disliking is not what I’m talking about. I’m talking about the people who hate with venom and love with their entire souls. I don’t understand being so passionately for one but so passionately against the other.
I’m not saying don’t have your favs. I mean I much prefer Rogers but that is because I prefer his story and his relationship with others. But, if it’s about the ships (CaptainSwan or KnightRook) or their story, just come out and say it already. There’s nothing wrong with liking a character purely because of the way his story was told.
Again, because I’m not sure if I’m making this clear; I’m specifically talking about hating/loving one because of their choices or personality - because the other would have made the exact same choice and acted the exact same way if they were in that situation.










