(Authors note: This story is unfinished, and I am not sure if I should continue. If you want me to continue, please send me a message/ask in the OurWordCraft ask box addressed to "L.S." Thanks for reading.)
Kasey was still shivering when she met Jonah, Matthew, and Sophia at the basketball court behind school. It had finally stopped raining that afternoon. The sky was gray like slush and thin clouds drifted over the mountains. Sophia's hands were deep in her pockets of her coat, watching as Matthew chased a muddy basketball as it slammed from the hoop onto the concrete. Jonah was trying to snatch the ball from him.
"I thought you weren't coming." Jonah finally said, a smug look on his face. "you're a bit late. What made you decide to come?"
"I'm here to prove you wrong." Kasey answered. The cold seeped into her skin and instantly made her uncomfortable.
Jonah just shrugged and picked up the ball again. Matthew and Jonah played basketball while Sophia tried to talk to Kasey about something normal. Kasey mumbled a few quiet "yeah's" and "right's" until Sophia stopped talking all together.
Megan finally appeared fifteen minutes later, crossing the field towards the woods. Jonah motioned them to follow. "It's about time. We'll wait until she gets farther enough away, and we'll go in right after."
"And she goes to the woods every day?" Sophia asked.
"Yep." Jonah said. "It's too hard to go in after her without being seen, but if we follow her and stay out of sight, we'll find out exactly where she's going."
Matthew rolled his eyes. "Yeah, whatever. Let's just get this over with."
They walked through the field and approached the woods. The trails were muddy and the ground was strewn with soggy brown leaves and sticks. The telephone wires that were crisscrossed over the town, trapping them in a wire cage, disappeared as they walked through the thick tangle of trees. Their shoes crunched on leaves or sank into the wet mud.
In the distance, they spotted Megan. They made sure not to be seen as Megan swam into their vision only to vanish behind two trees and appear again two minutes later. She never stopped walking.
They followed her until she stopped abruptly. They all froze into place. Kasey and Matthew hurried and crouched below a fallen tree trunk while Sophia and Jonah sat on their hands and knees in the dirt. Their breathing quickened and they waited. Kasey could hear Megan's footsteps stomping down the trail. Her hands brushed against the rough bark, shaking as she waited for Megan to catch them. Her breathing felt like it was being dragged out of her, her face bright red.
Megan stopped and turned around, only to see a squirrel darting up one of the spindly forest trees. A moment passed and she continued walking. Kasey breathed in a sigh of relief, and they all stood up to follow again. It seemed like Megan was luring them deeper and deeper into the woods until the trees blurred together.
They reached the cabin some time later. It looked like someone had built it themselves. It was a squat, sad-looking wood house with a caved in orange roof. Megan had to duck down to enter through the front door. When they were sure she wasn't watching, they began to walk towards it.
"What do we do know?" Kasey asked Jonah.
Jonah pointed at the house. "We'll look in the window."
Kasey hesitated at first, but she took several steps towards the cabin until she reached the window. The others made sure not to make any noise. They all crowded by the round window, peering inside. The cabin was poorly lit except for the glow of a pale yellow lamp that sat on the floor.
Inside, there was a red rug, old chairs, stacks of newspapers, and a pair of old running shoes in the corner. Megan sat on the floor next to a large trunk with thick leather straps. Her hands were shaking furiously, but the rest of her body was dead still.
"What is she doing?" Matthew whispered. Kasey looked closer inside until her breath fogged on the glass.
Megan's hand shook even more and then she collapsed, her body slumping to the floor. That was when Kasey ran inside.
She thought she was having a seizure. Kasey sat on the floor of the dusty cabin and held Megan's head up, which is what her dad taught her to do when he had seizures. She made sure she wouldn't hurt herself as her body seized and flailed.
Jonah and the others entered the cabin last.
"We need to perform an exorcism on her." Jonah declared.
"An exorcism? Are you kidding me? She's sick, not possessed." Kasey argued, still holding Megan.
Sophia looked like she was about to cry, holding her brother tightly in the doorway. Matthew's face was white.
Jonah tried to approach Megan, but Kasey yelled at him.
"You are not going near her!" Kasey said.
He remained undeterred. "I will send you back to hell, demon!"
The cabin door slammed shut behind them, and all the windows crashed down and locked into place. Sophia cried out in surprise.
"You can try." A voice said. It took Kasey a second to realize that the person speaking was Megan, her eyes, now bright green, were shining as bright as ever.
Megan grinned, standing up and shoving Kasey onto the trunk with inhuman strength. Her back slammed against the wood, the sharp edge digging into her back. She fell to the ground and groaned in pain. The others, including Jonah, raced to the door, which no amount of strength could open. Sophia began to sob, sinking to the ground. Megan's head whipped around at her.
"Don't cry." Megan spat at her, looking down at Sophia with disgust. "We haven't even started yet."
Sophia let out a small choking noise, and Megan began to step towards her. Her angry eyes burned like cigarettes.
"No! Megan!" Kasey called out.
The boys stood frozen in the doorway, paralyzed with fear.
Megan's face twisted in glee as she turned to face Kasey. "Not to worry, Kase. This will be over quickly. I'm going to kill them, and then I'm going to kill you."
She lifted her hands up, and muttered something Kasey couldn't hear. Suddenly, Kasey's insides burned and a painful itch ripped through her body, like a hot fire poker scraping her skin. The smell of her own burning flesh made her gag. The pain became excruciating, someone was laughing-
Kasey weakly called out Megan's name, screaming it, until she felt herself growing dizzy. The world around her shifted and blurred. She still heard Sophia screaming as she blacked out, and Megan's face as she stood above her, her footsteps echoing in her ears.
"My name isn't Megan." It said. "I'm Abigail."
They called her a witch. That horrible, ugly word had been scrawled on her parents' barn and spewed from the lips of Abigail's classmates. It seemed like everyone knew about her and the things that she did when no one watched. They accused her of conjuring spirits and putting curses on her enemies using ancient magic. She wasn't evil, not at first.
It started when they killed her cat. It was a Sunday afternoon when Abigail heard loud cursing from the backyard, thrashing, and then the strangled hiss of Truman, her cat, that echoed through the house. She looked around for her parents and her older brother, Isaiah, but they hadn't returned from the store.
Abigail ran outside, where she saw Zeke and Jonathan Harris, two brothers who lived down the road. They were Abigail's usual tormentors, the ones who called her a sinner and a witch. She was sure they were the ones who scrawled "WITCH" in black on the side of their barn, but had no evidence. Zeke's hands were stained with something red and sticky. Abigail remembered Truman's hissing and the curses.
"What have you done this time?" Abigail said cautiously, stepping towards them.
Zeke, the oldest brother, had the most blood on him. It stained the knees of his dirty jeans, splattered on his white shirt. His arm was behind his back.
They wouldn't answer her.
"I said, what have you done?" Abigail said angrily. The fear and anger that she felt boiled like hot water under her skin. Jonathan was smiling like he had a secret, looking to the grass, which Abigail noticed was smeared with blood. That's when she saw her cat, Truman, laying on the ground between Abigail and the Harris brothers, stretched out like he wanted to be petted. His fur was matted with blood and his throat had been slit.
"No!" Abigail sobbed. She realized that behind Zeke Harris' back was a small pocketknife.
She had never wanted to hit anyone so hard in her life. Jonathan grabbed her and held her hands behind her back. She tried everything she could to escape, but Jonathan just held her down tighter.
"I am so sorry, Abigail. It was feral. It needed to be put down." Zeke said. He gave her an evil grin.
"You are a liar!" she yelled at him. She fought out of Jonathan's grasp, hoping to get a good swipe at him, but Zeke only stepped back towards Truman's body.
"Truman had never hurt anyone!" Abigail cried. She laid down next to the cat's bloodied corpse, stroking his fur and sobbing. The word "witch" burned in her mind. When they stopped spitting and cursing, they began laughing at her, soaked in her cat's blood and crying over his body.
They were still laughing when she snapped their necks.
She didn't even have to get up to do it.
After they found the bodies, Abigail told Isaiah about what they did. She was already a sobbing, red-faced mess, but the constable assumed that she had been horrified to discover the mutilated bodies of the Harris brothers, and she was still traumatized from it. When they finished supper and her parents left for bed, she told her brother what she had done.
Isaiah's face glowed in the lamplight, and they sat in the attic to talk in private. Abigail even showed him Truman's corpse, which she had carried with her in a basket, kept comfortable in a pile of blankets. She planned on burying him under one of their juniper trees in the front of the house, but first she needed to show him what Zeke and Jonathan did.
"What did you do to them?" Isaiah asked. His face held no emotion.
Abigail began to cry again. "I did not mean to hurt them. They slit Truman's throat, they killed him. I had to do something."
"Their necks had been snapped, they were killed instantly. Was that you?" Isaiah asked slowly, almost looking betrayed.
"They slit Truman's throat and laughed! They threw dirt in my face and called me a witch. I did not mean to hurt them, but I was so mad." Abigail pleaded. "please do not be angry with me."
"How did you do it? Jonathan and Zeke Harris are two years older than you, they're bigger than you."
Abigail put her head down. "I try to control it, but it always goes wrong. I hurt people."
"What they say about you is it true?" Isaiah asked sadly. "You're a, a witch?"
In the darkness of the attic, Abigail could see his face crumple in grief, his shoulders slumping. What quickly appeared as sadness and disappointment morphed into red-hot anger on his face. He didn't go into his rages unless he was bleary-eyed and drunk, but other times he became violent for no reason at all. She was scared of these times.
Isaiah stood up, and Abigail pleaded with him. "I do not want to be a witch! I have tried to hard to hide what I am but nothing can stop it. I am powerless to put an end to this curse. Please forgive me!"
She begged for his forgiveness until her voice gave out. But he didn't listen. When his fist connected with her cheek, the blow knocked her to the ground. A cruel laugh escaped Isaiah's lips, something Abigail had never heard before. Darkness consumed her, she couldn't see, she thought she had gone blind-
He beat her until she stopped crying, stopped begging. Abigail wanted to hit him back. But if she unleashed her powers, she would kill him. She would let him kick and curse and hit her until he was done, and then she would be forgiven.
When he stopped, Abigail was laying on the floor, crying weakly. Isaiah stood over her, his face still red-hot and mean. His lips were turned into a disgusted scowl, like she was a dirty rat scavenging for food under the floorboards. He picked her up, and she was too weak to move. Abigail thought he was going to take her downstairs, but he turned to the family's old trunk at the back of the room.
Isaiah carried her to the trunk and opened it. Abigail realized what was happening and tried desperately to scratch or kick him, unleash her power, but she was bloody and weak. He shoved her inside, where there was barely any room for her whole body. Her shoulders were hunched, her legs pulled up to her chest.
"It is not up to me to punish you anymore. It is up to God." Isaiah said, slamming the trunk closed. He was going to leave her to die.
"Isaiah!" Abigail screamed. She gathered her strength and pounded on the lid of the trunk with both hands, until her fists ached. Her face was purple-ish and black from all the bruises, the marks from his fists that cloud her face like shadows. The trunk shook as she tried to escape, the air being sucked out of her. Her lip was split open and it bled, stinging her face when she screamed.
She wasn't evil, not at first.