(my letter for the Peaky Blinders Exchange)
Dear Peaky Blinders Author,
AAAAAAAAAAAH! First Peaky Blinders Exchange ever and I’m wildly excited!
This letter is long because I write all my Dear Creator letters the way I like to read them, and I love reading juicy letters. That said, feel free to go your own way and write whatever you want as long as it includes one of these pairings! I don’t want you to feel boxed in, and surprises can be fun. This letter is just meant to help give you some ideas if you have no idea where you wanna go. I appreciate all the time & thought you put into this. <3
Do Not Want: incest, rape/dubcon/noncon/underage sex shown (implied in the past is okay), hard kinks, detailed torture, a/b/o, cannibalism, vampires and werewolves, eating disorders
A battle, fight, or confrontation
A character who has run out of fucks to give
Forced to work together because of a common goal/common enemy
“I thought you were hurt/dead”
Ladies white knighting their significant others/crushes
Loyalty/conflicting loyalties
Pining (especially if it’s mutual but they don’t know it yet)
Despite its rarity, I’ve requested this relationship in literally four different exchanges, and I will continue to request this pairing in every possible exchange until I either receive fic for it or die. That’s just how I feel about it.
Esme Shelby is a gorgeous, no-holds-barred, sharp-tongued, quick-eyed storm of a woman and I love her now and forever. And frankly, every move she’s made so far is impeccable. She told Tommy not to expand to London, and she was right; the ensuing fights rained down massive amounts of trauma on the family and Tommy barely escaped with his life by the grace of Winston Churchill being a scheming bastard. She figured out that Polly was being scammed and told Tommy; without her, Michael and Polly would never have been reunited. When Michael got arrested, her first thought was not panic or rage but business: getting soldiers from Queen Mary Lee at the Black Patch. Esme was always a badass, but never was given the spotlight to shine. And I’m fully aware that this is a Controversial Take™, but she had actual chemistry with Tommy, my vicious aching restless wounded fighter. He’s always looking for the next challenge in business, and in life, he likes people who challenge him. Esme challenges him and then some. She’s ride or die. I think they could be an incredible power couple. Words can’t describe how much I love the tension in the air between the two of them. And yes, I know, in canon that tension is mostly borne of conflict, but fuck it, this is fic. What if there was more to it than that?
I will forever desire fic that’s an arranged marriage AU for the two of them. I could read 50 different fics about that.
What if John was still in love with Lizzie and Esme fell for Tommy? Listen: she called him Thomas at a family meeting, and Polly went: Thomas? And I went: HM.
AU where Esme is the daughter of Queen Mary Lee of the Black Patch and she’s sent to Birmingham to negotiate business with Tommy.
For this pairing, literally any kind of hurt/comfort fic would be...absolutely PRIME.
Esme Can Ride Better Than Tommy Can. Just Facts.
Grace Burgess/Lizzie Stark
I invented this ship, and I will go down with it if necessary. It caters to more tropes than my romantic heart can handle. Height difference! Undercover agent falls in love! Rags to riches! Two quiet, fierce women with dark pasts doing whatever they have to do to survive & keep the people they love alive. I think of Grace, who is a deeply observant woman doing her best to go unnoticed, seeing the true Lizzie, who is doing her best to be seen but constantly being dismissed as just a sex worker and a laughingstock. I think of Lizzie, who has borne more than any woman should ever have to bear, hoping for love and acceptance and never getting it, finding both of those things in a blonde, tiny, unexpected package. How surprised she might be if someone finally fucking stood up for her. How Grace, with her spy training, and Lizzie, with her deep Birmingham knowledge, could function as a formidable power couple. Oh, I could go on about them for days. There’s so much potential there.
In s1, Grace falls for Lizzie instead of Tommy, and protects him to spare Lizzie the pain since she knows that Lizzie has a complicated relationship with the Shelby brothers. She never expects anything from Lizzie, but Lizzie surprises her.
Tommy dies in s3 instead of Grace, and during the timeline of s4, Grace and Lizzie fall in love.
Grace and Lizzie face some kind of enemy down together, or get vengeance on one of their enemies. Campbell is one idea; Tommy is another. Or maybe it’s an original character. Doesn’t matter, as long as it’s satisfying.
A slice of life, something domestic, established. Just talking about how their lives have become integrated, who usually does the dishes, whether or not they’ve met each other’s families, that sort of thing.
Lizzie Said Fuck The Police! Grace Said...
May Carleton/Alfie Solomons
Still waters run deep. After years of mourning her husband, under surveillance at all times by her own servants, I think certain restraints just broke inside May. She looked around, saw a beautiful man who was also the most dangerous man in the whole city, thought, “hm, I’ll take him” and then just fucking took him. SHE DID THAT. On the other hand, Alfie Solomons is sheer fun: the swagger, the contrast between affability and violence, the pride in his Jewish identity, the rambling. My favorite moment of his is the time that he called Tommy out for having double standards about his son’s kidnapping. That was so insightful. Alfie knows perfectly well who he is as a killer criminal, and he faces that unflinchingly. Imagine: May’s fuck-it attitude meeting Alfie’s fuck-it attitude. Couple of the fucking century.
(I know their characters have never interacted in the show, but their actors are married happily in real life and acted together in Wuthering Heights, so I’ve seen the chemistry with my own two eyes and I know it is there. GOD, it is THERE.)
Alfie was a captain in May’s husband’s battalion. After the war, he contacts her, and they’re both surprised that despite her grief and his trauma, they find a real connection.
Alfie very politely takes May as a hostage in some sort of showdown with Tommy; May escapes of her own accord, but there’s a hell of a lot of flirting.
May and Alfie run into each other during s4, visiting Tommy. They both go, “...interesting…” and soon after that, “oh, what the hell, let’s do it” because Alfie’s dying and May’s feeling liberated after having just gotten over Tommy
Literally any kind of first meeting that includes the vibe of “May’s fuck-it attitude meeting Alfie’s fuck-it attitude”
Alfie Doesn’t Like Horses Very Much. May’s Reaction?