#phantom polls

[brendadaaedestler]

Somehow, it has been over a year since I've done one of my Phantom polls, and @meilas has been harassing me to bring these back. Well, thanks to a conversation with @rose-margaritas, inspiration has finally struck, and I return with a new poll!

Which Phantom would you like to spend a thunderstorm with?

Jeremy Stolle—takes you outside to slow dance in the rain

Jon Robyns—stands in the rain sobbing uncontrollably while you watch

Ben Crawford—watches the storm while "in no way trying to be sexy"

Ben Lewis—cries through reading poetry to you by the fireplace

James Gant—makes you tea and sits with you to watch the storm from the window

Cooper Grodin—will only do anything with his wife, glassprism

Thiago Arancam—locks you outside in the storm without an umbrella

Josh Piterman—the power's out, so he makes you a candlelit dinner

Hugh Panaro—spins around in the rain yelling "WHEEEEEE" at the top of his lungs

Luke McCall—curls up on the sofa with you with a soft blanket, tea, and books

Voting ended onJul 28, 2025

Reblog if you would like to see me create more polls! If you have any requests for another "Which Phantom Would You Like To" poll, go ahead and send me an ask or dm! I enjoy requests!

[brendadaaedestler]

It has been brought to my attention (yelled at me several times) that I haven't done a Phantom poll in a while, so thanks to @meilas, I have finally come back with another poll for you all!

Which Phantom would you like to take you on a picnic?

Earl Carpenter—takes you to a slightly muddy riverbank, though it's still nice

Saulo Vasconcelos—takes you to a big meadow with trees and lots of lavender

Ben Crawford—takes you on a picnic while "in no way trying to be sexy"

Laird Mackintosh—it's raining, so he instead puts together an indoor picnic

Cooper Grodin—only takes his wife, glassprism, on a picnic

Jeremy Stolle—prepares an elaborate meal and takes you to a flower garden

Ethan Freeman—takes you to a treehouse and makes peanut butter sandwiches and m

Thiago Arancam—tosses an empty basket at you and tells you to go away

Uwe Kröger—only made a salad, spends the whole picnic running away from bees

Gary Mauer—takes you to a picnic by a pond, you feed ducks your leftover bread

Voting ended onJun 2, 2024

Socks came up with a lot of these, so big thank you to them for their help!!

Reblog if you would like to see me create more polls! If you have a request for my next "Which Phantom Would You Like To" poll, please feel free to send me an ask or a dm! I have so much fun with poll requests! :D

**Ethan’s full description is “takes you to a treehouse and makes peanut butter sandwiches and milk.” It has been brought to my attention that the last bit got cut off.

[brendadaaedestler]

This is something entirely random that popped into my head, so I decided to make it a poll, because why not?

Which Phantom would you like to care for you while you’re sick?

Hugh Panaro—runs around screaming until he figures out how to help

Jeremy Stolle—brings you flowers and makes sure you’re comfortable

Ben Crawford—distracts you by being “not sexy”

Earl Carpenter—makes you breakfast in bed and composes you a song

Brad Little—immediately goes to kill whoever got you sick

Gary Mauer—makes you soup and gives you cuddles

Thiago Arancam—just stands there and stares at you as you die coughing

Ramin Karimloo—is super attentive but panics if your fever rises a single degree

Ben Lewis—cries the whole time and is convinced you’re dying

Josh Piterman—can only cook ramen noodles but will read you poetry all day

Voting ended onJun 26, 2023

Let me know if you want a part two, because I could only put 10 Phantoms! If you have suggestions, feel free to DM me the Phantom along with how you think he would comfort you while you’re sick.

[brendadaaedestler]

Alright, it’s been almost three months since my last Phantom poll, and that is absolutely way too long, so here’s my next one! This one was requested by @lieblingslok01! Thank you so much for requesting!!

Also, big thank you to @meilas for helping me come up with a few of these poll options!

Which Phantom would you like to take you on a vacation?

Josh Piterman—brings you to a mountain cabin getaway

Cooper Grodin—only takes his wife glassprism on vaca

Ben Crawford— takes you camping while “in no way trying to be sexy”

Peter Karrie—takes you to Niagara Falls to do the barrel challenge

Jeremy Stolle—takes you on a European tour

Thiago Arancam—tells you to go away (from him, just in general)

Hugh Panaro—takes you to Disney World

He Liangchen—brings you to his hometown to show you around

Gary Mauer—takes you on a Mediterranean cruise

Ben Lewis—takes you for a spa weekend to destress (he needs it more than you do)

Voting ended onNov 17, 2023

Reblog if you want to see more polls!

Requests for more “Which Phantom Would You Like To” polls are open, so feel free to shoot me a dm or to send me an ask with some requests!

[brendadaaedestler]

I am finally returning with my next poll! Terribly sorry for the long wait, but life has been busy.

This poll topic was requested by @eriksdreamery, so thank you, Aria! Also, big thank you to @meilas and @nerdywriter36 for helping me come up with some of the prompts!

Without further ado:

Which Phantom would you like to take you on a day out?

Jeremy Stolle—takes you to an art gallery

Thiago Arancam—tells you to go stand outside for a few hours

Ben Crawford—takes you out while “in no way trying to be sexy”

Gary Mauer—takes you on a picnic and a long walk in the park

Franc D’Ambrosio—takes you to Starbucks for coffee

Peter Karrie—takes you to a secret club

Ted Keegan—takes you out for a day of shopping

John Cudia—takes you rollerblading, only to fall on his face

Howard McGillin—takes you to the beach but hides under the umbrella all day

Adam Robert Lewis—takes you to an art class

Voting ended onAug 25, 2023

Don’t forget to reblog this if you would like to see more polls!!

As always, if you have a request for one of my “Which Phantom Would You Like To” polls, feel free to shoot me a dm anytime! I love it when you guys request polls!

[brendadaaedestler]

Since my last poll was very popular and I got a ton of requests, here is a part two!

Which Phantom would you like to care for you while you’re sick? (Part 2)

Franc D’Ambrosio—entertains you will silly voices and doodles

Ethan Freeman—spends all day by your side, wringing hands, weeping, and moaning

Michael Crawford—distracts you while you’re awake and softly sings to you

Peter Karrie—acts calm but starts sobbing if you make any noise of discomfort

Cooper Grodin—will take care of no one but his wife, glassprism

John Owen-Jones—sings you lullabies to put you to sleep

Laird Mackintosh—cares for you but sanitizes everything you touch

Gerard Butler—cares for you while shirtless to distract you with his chest

Paul A. Schaefer—spends all day with you, only to catch your cold

Saulo Vasconcelos—gives you a massage to help with your achiness

Voting ended onJul 3, 2023

Thank you to those of you who submitted your requests!

If you would like to see a part three, please dm me with the Phantom you would like to see added to the next poll as well as how you think he would care for you while you’re sick!

OR if you have an idea for another “Which Phantom Would You Like To” poll, let me know in my dms! I’m thinking about making this a poll series! (And I may even decide to write one shots based on the poll winners!)

[brendadaaedestler]

I am back with what is now my fifth Phantom poll! I really hope you guys are enjoying these as much as I’m enjoying creating them!

This topic is also curtesy of @forestscribe4! Thank you, Forest!

Which Phantom would you like to make you breakfast?

Earl Carpenter—cooks you a full English breakfast

Jeremy Stolle—makes homemade cinnamon buns and brioche french toast

Ben Crawford—cooks scrambled eggs while “in no way trying to be sexy”

Brad Little—tries making fried eggs and gets mad when he pops the yolks

James Hume—makes you a fabulous omelette with your favorite ingredients

Gary Mauer—cooks you a massive brunch buffet

Thiago Arancam—hands you a single egg, uncooked, still in the shell

Hugh Panaro—tries to make toast and accidentally burns down the kitchen

Ted Keegan—brings your favorite breakfast in bed with a rose on the tray

Paul A. Schaefer—takes you to McDonald’s, because he can’t cook

Voting ended onJul 25, 2023

Don’t forget to reblog this if you would like to see more polls!

Also, as always, if you have an idea for my next “Which Phantom Would You Like To” poll, please do not hesitate to dm me with your request!

[brendadaaedestler]

I’ve decided to do another “Which Phantom Would You Like To” poll! This topic is courtesy of @meilas! Thanks, Socks!

Which Phantom would you like to take you on a gondola ride across the underground lake?

Gary Mauer—is an excellent and informative tour guide

Hugh Panaro—tries to scare you with stories as he steers the boat around

Ben Crawford—steers the boat while “in no way trying to be sexy”

Jeremy Stolle—tries to make everything seem positive, even the negative aspects

Saulo Vasconcelos—is super gentle with you and often checks that you’re comfy

Howard McGillin—smooth at sailing but has to hide being anxious at your presence

Ted Keegan—smiles at you the entire time and is very fixated on you

Ethan Freeman—spends the whole time trying to stab fish with the boat pole

Earl Carpenter—is super anxious he’ll accidentally tip the boat and drown you

Thiago Arancam—stays silent the whole time and ignores your presence

Voting ended onJul 11, 2023

If you have ideas for other "Which Phantom Would You Like To" polls, please feel free to let me know in my dms! :D