What if Toby the Tram Engine was Jesus?
That's an interesting comparison, though Toby fits the role somewhat differently than Edward.
If Toby the Tram Engine were imagined as a Jesus-like figure, the emphasis would probably be less on being a wise elder mentor and more on being a humble servant who remains faithful despite being overlooked.
Humble Origins
When Toby is introduced in Toby the Tram Engine, he's an old-fashioned tram engine whose branch line is closing. Many people see him as outdated and no longer useful.
A symbolic interpretation might see this as paralleling the biblical theme of greatness appearing in humble and unexpected places.
Friend to the Ordinary
Toby spends most of his time serving small villages, carrying everyday passengers, and working alongside Henrietta. He isn't pulling prestigious expresses or showing off his strength.
In a Jesus-inspired role, Toby would likely focus on helping ordinary engines and railway workers rather than seeking attention from the "important" engines.
Gentle Teaching
Unlike Edward, who often gives direct advice, Toby tends to teach through quiet example.
He stays calm when:
Other engines are anxious.
New situations arise.
Engines underestimate him.
His message might be:
"You don't have to be the strongest engine to make a difference."
Welcoming the Outsider
Toby himself begins as something of an outsider on Sodor. Because of that, he often understands what it's like to feel different.
A Jesus-like Toby might be especially compassionate toward:
New engines.
Engines who have failed.
Engines who feel they don't belong.
Wisdom Hidden Behind Simplicity
Many engines initially assume Toby is old-fashioned or quaint. Yet time and again he proves dependable, knowledgeable, and courageous.
That echoes a recurring biblical theme: people overlooking wisdom because it comes in an unexpected form.
How the Other Engines Might See Him
Thomas would enjoy Toby's stories and learn from his experience.
Percy would trust him immediately.
James might initially dismiss him as old-fashioned.
Gordon could come to respect the quiet strength beneath Toby's modest appearance.
Edward vs. Toby as a Jesus Figure
If you were assigning symbolic roles:
Edward resembles Jesus as the compassionate teacher and moral guide.
Toby resembles Jesus as the humble servant who demonstrates goodness through everyday actions.
Edward often teaches with words.
Toby often teaches through example.
In many ways, Toby's greatest strength is that he never tries to be extraordinary. He simply does the right thing, day after day, and inspires others by his kindness, patience, and faithfulness. That's what would make him a compelling Jesus-like figure in a Railway Series allegory.