Fire and Hemlock!! Aka the one with like a gazillion recommendations for other books 😂
seen from Japan

seen from Germany
seen from United States
seen from Jordan

seen from Russia

seen from United States

seen from United Kingdom
seen from South Korea
seen from Australia
seen from Poland

seen from Malaysia
seen from China

seen from United States

seen from United Kingdom
seen from United States
seen from Japan
seen from Australia

seen from United Kingdom
seen from Sweden
seen from Russia
Fire and Hemlock!! Aka the one with like a gazillion recommendations for other books 😂
I remembered you older and taller But you're younger and smaller So who's gonna call her and say That you're back again?
“The truth between two people always cuts two ways, she thought.”
Diana Wynne Jones, "Fire and Hemlock"
Repost my old fanart of Fire and Hemlock.
Since I've started thinking about rereading this again after reading DWJ's Reflection: on the magic of writing.
Fire and Hemlock - (1984) by Diana Wynne Jones
“The truth between two people always cuts two ways.”
It's winter here in the southern hemisphere, which means it's time for my annual reread of Fire and Hemlock. Strange thing to say, considering I never stopped reading this book in the first place.
I think there are some kinds of books that longs with you for years. The type of book you close after reading it for the first time, and don't know exacly how you feel. You think "that's a weird book", and when people ask if you liked it or not, you don't know very well how to respond. You find yourself thinking about the novel here and there, and coming back to it on weekends, just to reread that page which made you confused towards the end. The years pass, you come out of your teenagehood, and it is still one of your all time favorites, even if now you are an adult.
It's strange to notice how much i've changed since I was a teen, but still there are some questions from that time that remains the same. Just like Polly, I was a girl born from a broken family. We were both raised by our grandmothers, caught in the middle of parents fights, and too young to understand the neighbors’s pointing fingers. We both were a little helpless - but pround - trying to deal with things we couldn't always control. Even now, I see much of myself in her.
I understand that characters in books are not made for the reader to see themselves in them, but to relate to them, and I think both of these things happens between me and Polly. We are both searching for hope in fairytales, trusting too much in people, scarred in many ways, but also fighting to do the best for others. I see a strenght in Polly that I wish I could see in more novel's herroines. She is not violent, she doesn't need to take a sword to save her lover and herself, she doesn't have a bad temper. Instead, she is kind and clever, just a common girl with a touch of magic in her sight. I love the way her strenght resides in her resilience, in the way she endures things that are too harsh and unfair to bear, and still see wonders in the world.
I think Fire and Hemlock leaves me with mixed feelings every time. It's a confusing read, bittersweet, a little distressing, but heart crashing hopeful. You don't need a sword to be a hero, neither to defeat all the monsters that show up in your way. Be persistent to deal with them, and don't quit, no matter how many years you spend trapped in theirs claws. The fairy queen is deceitful, you can't fight her face to face, and win. You have to find a tangent path, open hand of important things some times, and let them go. You'll win in the end, not for your lover's sake, or anyone's else, but for your own.
And this is why i love this book so much.
Why everyone should read Fire and Hemlock by Diana Wynne Jones: an incomplete list
1. the Heroic Ideal
2. Polly Whittacker is the biggest bookworm and overall wonderful protagonist
3. Granny is THE most wonderful back-up parent for a kid with two shitty actual parents
4. multiple female friendships! close ones!
a. Polly grows out of and into her friendships. Nina was a great childhood friend, but Polly had more in common with Fiona as an older teen then college student, and both friendships were important to her life and growth!
5. Thomas Lynn
6. The way Tom:
a. heroically drives his horse-car
b. plays the cello
c. understands Polly
d. also understands Granny’s perspective
7. Polly’s emotional range! How her soft-heartedness leads her to be overly nice to undeserving people like David Bragge and Seb, and yet she can also stand up for herself to Seb and Mr. Leroy and Mr. Piper.
8. the entire Bristol scene, which went from a raw and emotional low point where Polly feels “bleached” to the lovely relief of meeting the Dumas quartet
9. who doesn’t love a good Tam Lin retelling?
10. Diana Wynne Jones actually wrote an essay called “The Heroic Ideal” about why she wrote Fire and Hemlock
11. the logic Polly and Tom learn to follow to outsmart Laurel and the Leroys
12. Tan Coul and Hero, and their friends Tan Thare, Tan Hanivar, and Tan Audel
13. how Tom sent Polly books from all around the country
14. how those books nearly always included heavy-handed hints about his situation that she never quite connected
a. how she was annoyed that he never said he was in trouble, but realized HE HAD MADE SURE SHE KNEW
15. the NOWHERE vases
16. their Tales From Nowhere
17. Mintchoc
18. “being a hero means ignoring how silly you feel”
19. the devastating effects of embarrassment
20. letters
21. overall how beautiful and clever Diana Wynne Jones’s words are
polytheistic
Hugo Awards conference; Santa Fe, 2070
“— incredible, just absolutely incredible.”
“Now what you have to understand, Midge, that this was the 1980s. Homosexuality was only decriminalized the decade prior —”
“But marriage legalized by the new century!”
“Yes, absolutely. However, there was still a pervasive prejudice — especially among the older generations (that is to say, Dr. Whittacker’s and Dr. Perks’ generation) — that would have made things increasingly difficult for them were they to be, to use the period term: ‘out.’”
“I feel I must point out that they were both professors at a university: which, as we know, tend to be a haven of liberal attitudes even amongst conservative eras.”
“Quite right, Jocelyn, but they were still female academics. There is precious little range for error or, shall we say, deviation amongst university staff. Especially for those desperately inching toward tenure.”
“May I remind the panel that there are ten minutes remaining before we move onto the next session of the day?”
“Thank you, Dr. Schaffer. I would like to bring up the possibility, as well, of a polyamorous relationship with Thomas Lynn—”
“— if they were —”
“— little evidence to suggest—”
“— desperate rumors by the media—”
“And the fact remains, Dr. Torres, that had they been loathe to publicly announce a lesbian relationship, a polyamorous admission would have been even more—”
“— three of them rented a seaside cottage together every summer for ten years—”
“I’m afraid, ladies and gentlemen and colleagues, that’s the five-minute warning. Please cede the floor to Dr. Uri, who will begin the closing remarks. There will be another open discussion on the personal lives of the posthumous honorees during the afternoon session. Now if you’d please all direct your attention—”
read on ao3