polycobra au where all of them have wings??
like having wings is not a Normal Thing at all and each of them think they’re the only winged person on the face of the earth and they all keep it hidden (ryland and alex know about each other’s wings bc they’ve known each other so long but that’s it)
but then one day nate accidentally forgets to put a shirt back on when he gets out of the shower and everyone just stares at him and he’s like ????? until he realizes his wings are out and he’s like FUCK ok look i can explain and suddenly everyone else is taking their shirts off too and showing off their wings
they all have a Moment for like 5 minutes and then ryland says it must be destiny or something and then gabe ruins the moment by saying birds of a feather really do flock together
from then on they all p much always have their wings out when they’re not onstage and they discover all the joys of living with fellow winged people (warm feathery cuddle piles, seeing who can knock over the most stuff with a single wing flap, grooming each other’s wings, etc)
after the split gabe, nate, and victoria are holding auditions for new members and one of the interview questions they have is “do you have wings” and most of the people trying out think it’s a joke but when they ask halvo he’s just like “haha shit how’d you know” and when they ask andy he gets suspiciously nervous about it but refuses to say anything. eventually nate gets fed up and shows off his own wings and then andy finally admits he has them too. gabe hires both of them then and there on principle
also: each of them having really different wing patterns/colors? like gabe has a flamingo or some kind of parrot from the amazon, ryland has bluejay’s wings and alex has a cardinal’s, nate’s are just brown and grey and really fluffy, victoria has a snowy owl’s, idk about halvo and andy but andy’s would probably be something unassuming like a robin or a sparrow