Here I'll leave my brief analysis of what really happened in the cult...and what happened to the twins. During my time following the story of Kuroshitsuji, I've noticed that no one has truly understood what happened in the cult chapter. Ciel's past has been revealed and explained in various ways. Neither the panels nor the manga have tried to convey anything through the twins' story, even though it's been 9 years since we learned about Ociel's past! Nobody really understands it. Or she has analyzed it in a detailed, raw way; Yana Toboso usually works and moves through symbolic scenes, metaphors, that make the audience understand what happened during all that Mes, despite everything, there is still much to be done by the narrative and logical thinking of others, but I have seen deplorable, morbid theories and descriptions. Lacking all ethics and human logic, we all, from one moment to the next, let ourselves be guided by... "The twins were abused and hurt in the same way; they were victims of all kinds of mistreatment, and Ociel suffered more than Rciel!"But did they really suffer in the same way?Never. Why do you think Ociel is alive? Because Sebastian saved him? HAHAHA, Rciel was Ociel's human shield who at least prevented him from suffering the same physical abuse that he himself abused.It is presented to us from the beginning vom How a weak, asthmatic child needs care...If he had suffered the magnitude of abuse you describe, he wouldn't have lasted a month; he would have died within three days due to his asthma. A 10-year-old child is incapable of enduring daily abuse.Without remaining in a pre-death state, or in the case of him having died within days, and Rciel being the one who would have remained alive at least for those days, Rciel from the beginning attracted the unfortunate attention From the captors from day one... as such
Although in the end on the day of the "invocation" much"But both twins look the same." No, they look the same and they didn't have the same physical capabilities. I repeat (Yana Toboso uses symbolism) not graphic cruelty. As the author, she's not going to...Rciel is in a deplorable and disturbing state to behold because her manga and narrative are classified as "shonen" and published in G-Fantasy magazine, therefore she wasn't going to show it in a brutal way.And the realistic state of the twins is frivolous, much less that of RCiel.But you only have to pay attention to the twins' expressions and attitudes during those days to really observe and analyze who was completely broken, and that was Rciel, Ociel, despite being in a brutally traumatic state, his emotions were still those of a child who was still afraid, who still at least felt that he could escape with his brother, who still His emotions were real, and that's the most telling point of all...It marks a gap between someone who was still afraid and someone who no longer felt anything... Rciel's state is a total pre-death; he is trying to at least remain emotionally stable for his brother, but We only need to look at the smallest details, even the most unnecessary ones, which define who was the human shield for whom during that dark month.
Below I will leave you a report of what really happened in the sect And what is truly real and certain in the Kuroshitsuji manga, is how they suffered and what they endured.File 1:
OCiel Phantomhive
Here I'll leave my brief analysis of what really happened in the cult...and what happened to the twins.
-Constant physical abuse
-(SA) (lewd touching) no (only that)
(SA) Completely, because he wouldn't have survived a day...or a month
-Extreme captivity
-Cult mark
-Malnutrition
-Extreme psychological trauma
-Physically unharmed, could walk, move, run...?
Yes.
He could run, leave
Sit down
Yes
Rciel
Short captivity
Were they always taking him out?
Abuse (SA) (constant, daily)
(Constant, repetitive, extreme physical abuse)
(Was he taken to noblemen's rooms?...)
Complete SA abuse: physical, daily, humiliation, depravity, victim of fetishism.
Marks all over his body...
(Irreversible damage to his body, legs, arms; physical immobility; immediate and prolonged prostration)
Victim of intermittent genocide
All of the above...
Did he appear unharmed?
Couldn't walk...couldn't move, couldn't run?
Couldn't move?
He wasn't in the same condition as Ociel.
He would have ended up bedridden, and Ociel would have saved him.